Fact-checking claims about California’s ballot measures
PolitiFact California has fact-checked claims about many of the state’s most controversial ballot measures, from Prop 64’s effort to legalize marijuana to Prop 62’s proposal to abolish the death penalty to Prop 60’s condom requirement in adult films.
Campaigns for and against the state’s 17 measures are spending hundreds of millions of dollars on advertisements and often making Half True or Mostly False claims.
We’ll update this page leading up to Election Day on Nov. 8.
If you have a ballot measure you think we should fact-check, please submit your idea here.
Below is a list of our fact checks:
Prop 55 -- Income tax on high-income earners
Supporters of Prop 55 say it would ‘prevent $4 billion in new cuts' to California public schools. The claim paints an overly dire financial picture and ignores key facts. PolitiFact California rated it Mostly False.
Prop 56 -- Tobacco tax increase
Big Tobacco is flooding radio airwaves with the misleading claim that California's tobacco tax -- Prop 56 -- "cheats schools out of at least $600 million a year." PolitiFact California checked the facts, and rated the statement Mostly False.
Opponents of California's proposed tobacco tax say it 'cheats' schools. Photo by Florian Christoph / Flickr
Prop 57 -- Prison reform
The No on 57 campaign seized on the notorious Brock Turner sexual assault case to make a questionable claim about a California prison reform proposal. PolitiFact California rated the claim Mostly False.
California U.S. Senate candidate Loretta Sanchez compared Prop 57 to a ‘get out of jail free’ card for felons who commit gun crimes. PolitiFact California found that claim way off-the-mark and rated it False.
Prop 60 -- Condom requirement in adult films
Opponents of California's Prop 60, requiring condoms in pornography, say the measure would expose adult film workers to lawsuits. They have a point. But they left out the key context that only workers with a financial stake in the content would be liable. We rated the claim Half True.
Prop 61 -- Prescription drug prices
Sanders says Prop 61 'is great for taxpayers,' but independent analysts are less certain about the prescription drug measure. Because his claim is a prediction, PolitiFact California did not rate it. Instead we outlined the facts as they are known about the measure’s future effect on taxpayers.
Californians for Lower Drug Prices claimed in March Big Pharma had piled up more cash to defeat a November ballot measure than all other state initiative campaigns have raised – combined. PolitiFact California crunched the numbers and rated the claim Half True.
Condemned inmate Martin Navarette peers out his cell on death row at San Quentin State Prison near San Francisco, in December 2015. (AP Photo/Ben Margot)
Prop 62 -- Abolishing death penalty
The campaign to abolish the state’s death penalty said "California is home to the largest death row population in the Western Hemisphere." It turns out, the state has nearly twice as many death row inmates as the next closest state or country. We rated the claim True.
Potential gubernatorial candidate Tom Steyer said recently: "Since 1978, California has spent $5 billion to put 13 people to death." That cost, however, has been spread over hundreds of cases since 1978, not just the 13 that led to executions. We rated Steyer’s claim Mostly False.
A Glock 30SF .45 Auto semi-automatic pistol with a Glock 13-round extension magazine installed, and 13 rounds of hollow-point ammunition are seen in Alexandria, Va., Wednesday, Feb. 10, 2016. (AP Photo/Cliff Owen)
Prop 63 -- Gun, ammo control
A gun rights group claimed California's Prop 63 would restrict not only gun ammunition sales, but "criminalize the sharing of bullets between hunting and shooting partners." PolitiFact California found the claim is a far, far stretch. We rated it Mostly False.
A claim by Lt. Gov. Gavin Newsom-backed Yes on 63 says "More than 32,000 Americans lose their lives to gun violence each year." It needs a key clarification, but we rated it Mostly True.
The Yes on 63 campaign claims "there are at least twice as many licensed firearm dealers in the state as there are McDonald’s." It’s a colorful claim and PolitiFact California found hard data to back it up.
Prop 64 -- Legalizing marijuana
Sen. Dianne Feinstein says Prop 64 "allows marijuana smoking ads in prime time, on programs with millions of children and teenage viewers." There’s an element of truth to this cloudy claim, but it’s Mostly False.
Prop 67 -- Plastic bag ban
Opponents of Prop 67 say 'not one penny' of the 10 cent paper bag fee imposed by the initiative would fund the environment. We found that statement is partially accurate, but ignores some key facts. We rated it Half True.