"700 jobs (were) lost because Allen Boyd" voted for the health care bill.
National Republican Congressional Committee on Sunday, September 12th, 2010 in a TV ad.
Allen Boyd cost Sallie Mae employees their jobs with health care vote, Republicans claim
Republicans hoping to take back the U.S. House of Representatives have their sights set on North Florida Democrat Allen Boyd.
A "Blue Dog" Democrat and a seven-term congressman, Boyd faces a serious challenge this November from Republican funeral-home owner Steve Southerland. The St. Petersburg Times labeled Boyd one of the two most vulnerable incumbents in Florida, and the National Republican Congressional Committee has identified the race in Florida's 2nd Congressional District as one its top prospects.
The NRCC reserved a big chunk of fall television time in Tallahassee, and already is airing an ad criticizing Boyd for voting for the massive federal health care legislation.
The ad is called "Allen Boyd sides with Nancy Pelosi," and says that the passage of the federal health care bill will cost Boyd's district 700 jobs.
"Our economy is hurting, but Allen Boyd sides with Nancy Pelosi and he's killing our jobs," the ad begins. "When Allen Boyd voted for Obamacare, he voted to shut down a local facility that employs 700 people. 700 jobs lost because Allen Boyd sided with Nancy Pelosi."
It's important to note that while this fact check -- that Boyd's vote on health care cost his district 700 jobs -- is about the federal health care legislation, it's not specifically about health care. The massive legislation tacked-on changes to how students receive loans to pay for college.
It's those changes to the student loan programs that cost North Florida 700 jobs, the NRCC is claiming.
We'll explain the whys and hows in a moment, but first a primer on the student loan changes adopted in the health care bill.
The student loan changes
Before the health care bill passed and was signed into law by President Barack Obama in March 2010, there were basically two kinds of college loan programs: the Federal Family Education Loan Program, in which private lenders make and secure loans to students and receive subsidies from the federal government; and the William D. Ford Direct Loan Program, in which the federal government directly loans to students.
The federal health care bill eliminated those subsidies to private lenders and shifted student lending to the government's Direct Loan program, which Obama believes is more efficient and cost-effective. The shift is expected to save $68 billion over the next 11 years, $36 billion of which would be used to expand Pell Grants, a federal program that helps low-income students pay for college. Other money, about $9 billion, will help pay for some of the additional health care costs.
Boyd voted against the original version of the health care bill to pass the House in November 2009 -- which included the student loan changes -- but voted for the final version that passed the House 220-211 and ultimately became law.
He said he decided to support the final version because he believed it met four key principles: It reduced health costs, increased access, ensured patient choice and did not add to the federal deficit.
"This bill is not perfect, but I believe it meets these four principles of responsible reform by providing the largest middle class tax credits for healthcare in our nation's history and preserving a patient’s ability to choose their own doctor," Boyd said in a release announcing his support.
The question for this fact check to address then comes down to those 700 jobs, how they were impacted by the health care bill, and what Boyd could have done to stop any job losses.
Saving Sallie Mae jobs
Boyd's 2nd Congressional District includes a student loan processing facility operated by Sallie Mae, the nation's largest private provider of student loans. The facility is located in Lynn Haven, just north of Panama City. It employs about 540 full-time workers, and had in the past hired about 160 temporary workers. The company did not hire those workers in 2010.
Sallie Mae officials said repeatedly that if the health care bill passed with changes to the student loan rules, all of the Bay County jobs could be in jeopardy.
Boyd initially appeared to side with Sallie Mae and its employees, visiting the Bay County facility in November 2009 after voting against the first version of the health care bill. He also voted against the Student Aid and Fiscal Responsibility Act (H.R. 3221) in the House, which attempted to accomplish the same changes to the student loan program.
"Sallie Mae is one of our most vibrant and reliable employers in North Florida," Boyd said in a Sallie Mae press release. "I will continue working to protect these valuable jobs and preserving the current student lending infrastructure that has served our students and schools well for years."
Boyd attempted to remove the student loan language from the health care bill, and offered an amendment to that effect in front of the Budget Committee on March 15, but the amendment failed 4-32, Congressional Quarterly reported. Boyd said switching to federal loans would result in the loss of thousands of jobs for employees in the student loan industry, but acknowledged he had not been able to reach a compromise with other Democrats, CQ reported.
But on March 21, Boyd voted for the health care bill, which included the student loan changes. He said he believed he still thought it possible to save the Panama City Sallie Mae jobs.
"I am disappointed that the student loan issue is included in the health care bill," Boyd said in March. "I have had many conversations with Sallie Mae, the Department of Education, and the White House, and I believe there are a number of steps we can take to prevent job losses at the Lynn Haven facility. I will continue working with Sallie Mae and Education Secretary (Arne) Duncan to ensure that this new process will not jeopardize the future of the hardworking people in Lynn Haven."
A month later Sallie Mae announced it was closing its Bay County location. The company said it was going to cut about a third of its 8,600-employee nationwide workforce and reduce its physical locations from 25 to five to seven. "We've been warning about the impact of this legislation, and this is a direct result of that," Sallie Mae spokesman Conwey Casillas told the Panama City News Herald.
Boyd issued a news release that same day saying he was working the Department of Education and the White House to help protect the Sallie Mae jobs, hoping the employees could transition to a different type of loan processing position. He later lobbied BP claims administrator Kenneth Feinberg to place workers from the closing facility in oil spill-related damage claim processing jobs. News reports suggest he is still searching for jobs for the Sallie Mae employees.
But not before the first round of layoffs -- affecting about 50 employees -- came in July.
The facility is expected to be shut down by the end of the year.
"The decision to close our Bay County facility is based on the fact that this is the location where the loan origination function was performed," said spokesman Conwey Casillas. "Effective July 1, 2010, the Federal Family Education Loan Program, first enacted in 1965, was eliminated along with the role Sallie Mae and other private sector companies performed in the origination of federal student loans."
In the ad, the National Republican Congressional Committee says "700 jobs" were lost because Allen Boyd voted for the federal health care bill.
In the strictest analysis, the NRCC is slightly off on both points. The company plans to lay off about 540 full-time employees. It also chose not to rehire about 160 temporary employees. Boyd's vote, meanwhile, wouldn't have changed the outcome of the legislation.
Still, the ad has some elements of truth. After voting against the first version of the health care bill, Boyd did vote for a final version that tacked on significant changes to the student loan program. Sallie Mae warned that those very changes could threaten the jobs at its Panama City facility, and one month after the health care bill passed, the company announced it was closing that facility.
But it was Sallie Mae's decision to eliminate the Panama City jobs, cutting those specific jobs wasn't mandated by Washington.
We are certain this will be an issue Boyd will confront over and over again between now and Nov. 2. And it's certainly complicated -- so much so that he might not be able to explain the nuance of his actions and what happened in 30-second commercials. Luckily, we have no such time or word limit. The fact is, the federal health care bill that passed in March contained massive changes to the health care system, as well as changes to how college students get student loans.
Boyd in the end liked the health care provisions and didn't like the changes to the student loan system. He tried to eliminate the student loan provisions through an amendment to the overall legislation, but failed. And there is no "yes, except for that" vote in Congress.
It's much more accurate, for instance, to say that the 700 jobs were lost because the health care bill passed. Boyd's vote didn't change the outcome of the legislation, it would have passed either way. And if you believe Sallie Mae, that means he wouldn't have been able to stop what's happening to Sallie Mae's Panama City-area employees. We rate the claim Barely True.
Editor's note: This statement was rated Barely True when it was published. On July 27, 2011, we changed the name for the rating to Mostly False.
Published: Thursday, September 16th, 2010 at 2:19 p.m.
National Republican Congressional Committee, e-mail interview with Andy Sere, Sept. 14, 2010
Allen Boyd campaign, e-mail interview with JR Starrett, Sept. 14, 2010
Sallie Mae, e-mail interview with Conwey Casillas, Sept. 15, 2010
Sallie Mae, "Rep. Boyd pledges to continue fighting for student loan reform legislation that keeps jobs in Florida," Nov. 11, 2009
New York Times, "Obama Signs Bill on Student Loans and Health Care," March 30, 2010
Republican Party of Florida, "Did Allen Boyd Trade North Florida Jobs for Support from Organizing for America?" Aug. 6, 2010
PolitiFact, Barack Obama campaign promises
Thomas, Health Care and Education Reconciliation Act of 2010, accessed Sept. 15, 2010
Allen Boyd, health care news release, March 21, 2010
Panama City News Herald, "Sallie Mae plant facing layoffs," March 22, 2010
WJHG, "Rep. Allen Boyd Votes for Landmark Health Care Reform," March 22, 2010
Panama City News Herald, "Boyd defends health care vote," March 23, 2010
Panama City News Herald, "Why Sallie Mae's fate was linked to health care," April 11, 2010
Panama City News Herald, "Sallie Mae closing; Boyd holds out hope," April 21, 2010
Allen Boyd press release, "Boyd continues fighting to protect local Sallie Mae jobs," April 21, 2010
WJHG, "Update: Sallie Mae jobs," May 16, 2010
WMBB, "Sallie Mae Layoffs to Begin in July," May 19, 2010
Panama City News Herald, "Boyd proposes new plan for Sallie Mae employees," July 20, 2010
Congressional Quarterly, "Panel Advances Bill Intended to Alter Pending Health Care Overhaul," March 15, 2010
We want to hear your suggestions and comments. Email the Florida Truth-O-Meter with feedback and with claims you'd like to see checked. If you send us a comment, we'll assume you don't mind us publishing it unless you tell us otherwise.