PolitiFact.com
Powered by PolitiFact.com and ajc.com
The Truth-O-Meter Says:
McCullen

"The Georgia Lottery Corp. has only once in the past 16 years paid out the agreed upon 35 percent of proceeds to the account which funds the HOPE scholarship."

Allie McCullen on Wednesday, March 2nd, 2011 in a speech

Luck runs out for student on lottery claim

With the cost of higher education rising every year, some students probably think they need to win the lottery to afford tuition.

But others -- math majors probably -- believe there’s a more likely way for the Georgia Lottery Corp. to help students pay their bills. Student organizations along with some state lawmakers have called on the corporation, the quasi-governmental entity that runs the game, to provide a higher percentage of its proceeds to the HOPE scholarship fund.

Last month Georgia Students for Public Higher Education, a group that has participated in public protests related to a variety of issues, and other student organizations criticized elected officials and the Geogia Lottery Corp. at a rally in downtown Atlanta in response to cuts in the HOPE scholarship program.

Allie McCullen, a statewide organizer with Georgia Students for Public Higher Education and a senior at the University of Georgia, said in a speech: "The Georgia Lottery Corp. has only once in the past 16 years paid out the agreed upon 35 percent of proceeds to the account which funds the HOPE scholarship."

Not a single PolitiFact scribe has yet to retire on a big-ticket prize. So we decided that in the meantime we’d look into whether the odds of the Georgia Lottery Corp. paying the agreed upon percentage to the HOPE scholarship are better than the 1 in 175 million odds of winning the Mega Millions jackpot.

McCullen said she obtained the figure from an article published in February in the University of Georgia’s student newspaper The Red and Black, a publication she has been quoted in several times this year.

The Georgia Lottery Corp.’s numbers show the lottery provided 36.1 percent of its revenue toward education in 1995, 35 percent in 1996 and 35 percent in 1997.

But McCullen, who has also been quoted in The New York Times, points to the steadily declining percentage of revenue going toward education as proof that the theme of her speech still stands.

Since 1997 the percentage of revenue declined from 35 percent to a low of 25.6 percent in 2009. And the lottery has not provided 30 percent of its revenue to the education fund since 2004.

"I do recognize I had incorrect information, but since 1997 we have not seen a return to the 35 percent," she said. "I think the opinion I expressed remains the same."

Also in dispute, however, is what percentage of revenue the lottery is required to provide the scholarship fund.

The statute states that net proceeds of the lottery should be 35 percent of gross revenue "as nearly as practical."

The Georgia Lottery Corp. said in a statement to PolitiFact that the phrase was added to the statute to allow the lottery to be flexible and maximize its revenue.

If the organization was legally required to provide 35 percent, it could not provide large enough cash prizes to entice those looking for a lucky day, the corporation said.

"In fiscal year 1997, the Georgia Lottery returned 35 percent of lottery revenues to the state for lottery-funded educational programs in the amount of $581 million," the corporation said in a written statement. "In FY10, the Georgia Lottery raised a record $883.9 million for HOPE and Pre-K, accounting for 26.1 percent of lottery revenues. Undoubtedly, more Georgia students benefited from the larger dollar amount, not the larger percentage."

The dollar amount in 2010 is more, but the Georga Lottery Corp. did not make a straight comparison. In 2010 dollars the $581 million in 1997 would be the equivalent of $789 million.

But some elected officials do not believe the 35 percent number included in the legislation is meaningless.

Rep. Stacey Evans, D-Smyrna, said the intent of the legislation was to ensure the lottery comes close to 35 percent. She said that intent is not respected today.

"I’m not sure they’re even trying anymore," she said. "We need more oversight of them and need them to come close to that 35 percent."

If McCullen had said the Georgia Lottery Corp. has not hit its target of 35 percent since 1997, the accuracy of her statement would have hinged on what "as nearly as practical" means and why the legislation even included the number 35 percent. The legislators who PolitiFact spoke with agreed that the number was included for a reason and the corporation has not come close to reaching that target in recent years.

But, alas, McCullen said that in the past 16 years the Georgia Lottery Corp. met the 35 percent goal only once, but it has met the target three times. So she has a better chance of winning the lottery than receiving a True on the Truth-O-Meter.

We rate her statement False.

Advertisement
About this statement:

Published: Wednesday, April 27th, 2011 at 6:00 a.m.

Subjects: Education

Sources:

Interview with Allie McCullen, statewide organizer with Georgia Students for Public Higher Education, April 19, 25, 2011

Interview with state Rep. Stacey Evans, D-Smyrna, April 22, 2011

Interview with state Sen. Jim Butterworth, R-Cornelia, April 22, 2011

Interview with state Sen. Jason Carter, D-Decatur, April 22, 2011

Interview with state House Minority Leader Stacey Abrams, D-Atlanta, April 22, 20011

Official State of Georgia Tabulation by Counties for Presidential Electors, U.S. Representatives, State Officers, Constitutional Amendments and General Assembly of Georgia, 1992

Statement from the Georgia Lottery Corp, April 21, 2011

Interview with Tandi Reddick, a spokeswoman for the Georgia Lottery, April 25, 2011

Georgia Department of Audits and Accounts audit of the Georgia Lottery Corp.

New York Times, "Georgia Facing a Hard Choice on Free Tuition," January 6, 2011

Written by: M.B. Pell
Researched by: M.B. Pell
Edited by: Jim Denery, Jim Tharpe

How to contact us:

We want to hear your suggestions and comments. Email the Georgia Truth-O-Meter with feedback and with claims you'd like to see checked. If you send us a comment, we'll assume you don't mind us publishing it unless you tell us otherwise.

Browse The Georgia Truth-O-Meter:
Subscribe: