State governments have little ability to stimulate job growth in the short run.
David Wyss on Monday, December 13th, 2010 in a newspaper article
Economist says state can do little for short-term job growth
Georgians need jobs. Last election season, that's just what politicians promised.
Gov.-elect Nathan Deal's commercials focused on bringing "real jobs for real people." His Democratic foe, former Gov. Roy Barnes, said he would put the state "back to work."
But during a boot camp for state legislators in December, prominent economist David Wyss said there's little Georgia government can do to kick-start the labor market for the near term.
"It doesn’t work well on the state level because states can’t run budget deficits," Wyss said in a Dec. 13 article in The Florida Times-Union. He is chief economist for the credit rating company Standard & Poor's.
"So anything you do in reducing taxes has to come back with a reduction in spending, which basically wipes out any stimulus you get," he said
Really? But what about all those promises politicians made?
Jobs were a central issue during the elections. A poll conducted before the primaries for The Atlanta Journal-Constitution and other papers found that across party, gender and racial lines, Georgians were worried about their economic futures.
Three in four had qualms about their household finances and job security.
Georgians still have good reason to be anxious. Unemployment hovered just above 10 percent in November, according to the state Department of Labor.
Wyss also spoke during a biennial conference of state legislators sponsored by the University of Georgia. The meeting updated lawmakers on the issues they face starting Monday, when the 2011 legislative session begins.
We called Wyss, who stressed that state government can enact policies that foster long-term job growth. They can train a work force specifically suited for a business's needs, for instance, or collaborate with local universities to foster technological innovation.
States such as Georgia also have agencies specifically charged with economic development. And governors have been known to go on trade missions.
But those efforts, too, are aimed at creating jobs in the long term.
Wyss was talking about the short term. And in the short term, state legislators and governors don't have many options.
Georgia and other states have to balance their budgets -- it's a constitutional requirement in Georgia. So if the state decides to cut taxes to stimulate business growth, it has to come up with the lost revenue somewhere else, Wyss said.
That means government spending cuts. It could even mean layoffs.
"There's no free lunch here," Wyss said.
AJC PolitiFact Georgia asked seven experts with wide-ranging perspectives for their input. For the most part, they agreed with Wyss' assessment.
Kelly McCutchen, president of the Georgia Public Policy Foundation, a Libertarian-influenced think tank, called the idea "absolutely correct." If a state spends money to spur job growth, lawmakers have to make cuts elsewhere.
Jon Shure, deputy director of the State Fiscal Project for the liberal Center on Budget and Policy Priorities, agreed with Wyss as well.
"Short-term job gains are dictated mostly by the economy. And those are mostly regional, national and global issues," Shure said.
One slight exception was Brian Riedl, lead budget analyst for the Heritage Foundation, a conservative think tank. He said tax cuts could bring a "marginal" improvement in the short term and are worth trying, but they can't bring a big boost.
"There is no magic wand," Riedl said.
We found that experts placed the state's ability to create jobs for the short term between limited and marginal. None argued that state government could cause an immediate, major gain.
We find Wyss' statement True.
Published: Wednesday, January 5th, 2011 at 6:00 a.m.
The Florida Times-Union, "Puny tax collections a problem in Georgia," Dec. 13, 2010
The Atlanta Journal-Constitution, "Voters: Show us the jobs," July 18, 2010
Interview, Jeffrey Humphreys, director, Simon S. Selig Jr. Center for Economic Growth, University of Georgia, Dec. 16, 2010
E-mail interview, Sarah Beth Gehl, deputy director, Georgia Budget & Policy Institute, Dec. 16, 2010
Interview, David Wyss, chief economist, Standard & Poors, Dec. 17, 2010
Interview, Jon Shure, deputy director, State Fiscal Project, Center on Budget and Policy Priorities, Dec. 21, 2010
Interview, Greg LeRoy, executive director, Good Jobs First, Dec. 20, 2010
Interview, Kelly McCutchen, president, Georgia Public Policy Foundation, Dec. 21, 2010
Interview, Brian Riedl, lead budget analyst, the Heritage Foundation, Dec. 21, 2010
We want to hear your suggestions and comments. Email the Georgia Truth-O-Meter with feedback and with claims you'd like to see checked. If you send us a comment, we'll assume you don't mind us publishing it unless you tell us otherwise.