"When you look at the number of crashes before the cameras were installed compared to after, they’re virtually the same."
Steve Acenbrak on Sunday, November 11th, 2012 in an article
Red-light cameras don't impress Roswell
Roswell city leaders recently met to discuss a proposal to hit the brakes on red-light cameras.
The idea to remove them is not new, but a claim about their effectiveness was interesting enough that we thought it should be put on the Truth-O-Meter.
"When you look at the number of crashes before the cameras were installed compared to after, they’re virtually the same," said Steve Acenbrak, the city’s transportation director.
Is that true?
Roswell, a north Fulton city with a population of 91,168, has two red-light cameras. One sits at the intersection of Ga. 9 and Ga. 92/Holcomb Bridge Road. The other camera is located at Ga. 9 and Ga. 140/Mansell Road. The cameras were installed in February 2007.
Red-light cameras became popular in many cities and counties as a way to reduce the number of motorists who run red lights and hit other vehicles or pedestrians who assumed they had the right of way.
There is an ongoing argument about whether the cameras are effective when it comes to reducing accidents.
The National Motorists Association, a group advocating motorists’ rights, has led the fight against the cameras.
"There is no evidence that these ticket camera systems make drivers more safe," the association states on its website. "In fact, the opposite has proven true. Ticket cameras increase accidents!"
A study by the Federal Highway Administration found that red-light cameras "provide a modest aggregate crash-cost benefit." The study found the cameras tend to reduce severe side-impact crashes, but increase less-severe rear-end collisions.
The city of Alpharetta has red-light cameras at more intersections (seven) than any community in Georgia, according to state records. Atlanta has working cameras at six intersections, the records show.
The city of Snellville, though, removed its cameras a few years ago. City officials said the number of violators was so small that it wasn’t cost-effective to keep them.
Roswell officials have made a similar case to scrap its cameras, The Atlanta Journal-Constitution reported.
Acenbrak said the city researched the number of wrecks at those intersections three years before the cameras were installed and three years afterward. The state Department of Transportation does not do its own research of wrecks at intersections with red-light cameras. It collects the data from the cities and counties with cameras, a spokeswoman said.
Here’s what Acenbrak shared with PolitiFact Georgia at both intersections.
At the Ga. 9 and Holcomb Bridge Road intersection, there was a slightly higher ratio of collisions there after the camera was installed. Acenbrak said there were three wrecks in the 25 months prior to the cameras. There were three wrecks in the 22 months after the cameras were installed, he said.
At Ga. 9 and Mansell Road, there was a higher percentage of wrecks before the cameras were installed as opposed to the total afterward. Acenbrak’s numbers show there were three wrecks in the 13 months before the cameras were installed, a ratio of one collision about every four months. The director said there were two crashes in the 22 months afterward, a ratio of one wreck every 11 months.
Acenbrak said those numbers prove his point, along with other data he presented to us, such as less than 3 percent of wrecks throughout the city each year can be attributed to motorists running red lights.
"We still have red-light runners, but they’re not causing crashes," he said.
To summarize, Acenbrak said the number of wrecks at Roswell’s red-light camera intersections was virtually the same before and after the cameras were installed. At Ga. 9 and Holcomb Bridge Road, it was almost identical. At Ga. 9 and Mansell Road, the ratio of wrecks after the cameras were installed was smaller.
With that bit of clarity about the Mansell Road intersection, we rate Acenbrak’s claim Mostly True.
Published: Tuesday, November 27th, 2012 at 6:00 a.m.
The Atlanta Journal-Constitution, "Roswell looks past red-light cameras," Nov. 11, 2012.
Email and telephone interview with Steve Acenbrak, transportation director for the city of Roswell, Nov. 13 and 14, 2012.
Email from Georgia Department of Transportation spokeswoman Jill Goldberg, Nov. 16, 2012.
National Motorists Association red-light camera studies, accessed Nov. 26, 2012.
U.S. Census Bureau quick facts on Roswell, accessed Nov. 26, 2012.
U.S. Federal Highway Administration Safety Evaluation on Red-Light Cameras, Executive Summary, April 2005.
We want to hear your suggestions and comments. Email the Georgia Truth-O-Meter with feedback and with claims you'd like to see checked. If you send us a comment, we'll assume you don't mind us publishing it unless you tell us otherwise.