"We have the highest per-pupil cost in the country."
Steve Oroho on Wednesday, May 25th, 2011 in a story in The Star-Ledger
Sen. Steve Oroho says New Jersey has nation’s highest per-pupil cost
What’s so bad about finishing in first place?
Plenty, if you’re New Jersey and per-pupil costs top those of any other state in the nation, according to State Sen. Steve Oroho (R-Dist. 24). He cited that statistic in a May 26 Star-Ledger news story about how the Legislature will fit a Supreme Court-ordered $500 million payment to New Jersey’s 31 Abbott districts in the state budget. Lawmakers have to reach an agreement before July 1, the beginning of the new fiscal year, on how to spend approximately $30 billion.
Oroho said in that story that he won’t vote for a budget that sends the $500 million just to the Abbott districts.
"We have the highest per-pupil cost in the country," he said. "No one can say there’s not enough money in education."
PolitiFact New Jersey decided to check whether Oroho was right.
The senator, a certified financial planner who serves on the Senate’s Budget and Appropriations and Economic Growth committees, told us he researched National Center for Education Statistics data going back to the 2004-05 academic year. He said his statement was based on data for 2006-07, which showed that New Jersey’s per-pupil cost -- for grades K-12 and including all school districts -- was $17,794.
PolitiFact New Jersey contacted the nonpartisan National Center for Education Statistics to vet Oroho’s statistic. We studied nearly 10 years’ worth of data and found that among states, New Jersey has had the highest per-pupil cost in the nation since at least the 1999-00 school year. It’s worth noting that Washington, DC -- not a state -- had higher per-pupil costs than New Jersey from 1999-03 and from 2006-07.
Cathy Clement, operations officer for the National Center for Education Statistics, explained that the center’s data comes from information reported by local jurisdictions to states, which then report the data to the U.S. Department of Education. The national center is part of the Education Department’s Institute of Education Sciences.
The New Jersey Education Association, however, disputes Oroho’s claim.
Spokesman Steve Baker shared with PolitiFact New Jersey the Public Education Finances: 2009 report issued May 20 by the U.S. Census Bureau. It shows that New Jersey was third in per-pupil spending for the 2008-09 year, at $16,271. New York was highest, at $18,126, followed by Washington, DC, $16,408.
The National Center for Education Statistics told us the discrepancy stems from slight differences in what costs get reported and factors such as whether public charter schools are included.
We also checked with the New Jersey Department of Education to see which agency’s figures they would rely on for accurate per-pupil cost data.
"We often cite National Center for Education Statistics," said Alan Guenther, department spokesman.
So why is education so expensive in New Jersey?
Both Oroho and Baker say there are multiple factors involved. Oroho points to administrative costs and regulatory requirements as possible factors. The NJEA’s Baker, referring to the School Finance 101 blog by Bruce Baker, no relation, an associate professor in the Graduate School of Education at Rutgers University, cited special-needs programming and interventions, as well as education needs for children in poverty, as elements that contribute to per-pupil costs.
Let’s return to Oroho’s statement. The senator says New Jersey has the highest per-pupil costs in the country, but admits basing that statement on data for the 2006-07 and 2007-08 school years. Still, our analysis of data from a nonpartisan arm of the U.S. Department of Education shows that among states only, New Jersey has held the title of highest per-pupil costs in the nation for nearly a decade. The U.S. Census Bureau, however, ranks New Jersey’s per-pupil spending for 2008-09 as third-highest in the nation. Therefore, we rate Oroho’s statement Mostly True.
To comment on this ruling, join the conversation at NJ.com.
Published: Monday, June 13th, 2011 at 5:00 a.m.
National Center for Education Statistics website, data tables for revenues, expenditures and state profiles, accessed May 30, 2011
Phone and e-mail interviews with Cathy Clement, operations office, National Center for Education Statistics, U.S. Department of Education Institute of Education Sciences, May 27, 2011 and May 30, 2011
E-mail interviews with New Jersey Education Association spokesman Steve Baker, May 27, 2011 and May 30, 2011
Phone interview with New Jersey Department of Education spokesman Alan Guenther, May 30, 2011
Rutgers University Professor Bruce D. Baker’s School Finance 101 blog
Phone interview with state Sen. Steve Oroho (R-Dist. 24), May 26, 2011
The Star-Ledger, "Ruling forces tough calls for lawmakers," May 26, 2011
We want to hear your suggestions and comments. Email the New Jersey Truth-O-Meter with feedback and with claims you'd like to see checked. If you send us a comment, we'll assume you don't mind us publishing it unless you tell us otherwise.