"It costs $10,000 a year to keep a child in school; it costs $30,000 a year to keep someone in prison."
John Kitzhaber on Monday, January 14th, 2013 in in State of the State speech
Does Oregon spend $10,000 a year per student, $30,000 per inmate?
In his annual address, Gov. John Kitzhaber called on lawmakers to make a range of difficult decisions in order to put more money into schools. The actions include reducing the costs of health care and corrections. State forecasters estimate the prison population will grow, in part due to tougher sentencing measures and in part due to overall population growth, at an extra cost of $600 million over the next 10 years. The governor said most of the beds will be occupied by nonviolent offenders.
Kitzhaber acknowledged that politicians don’t like to appear "soft on crime." But he asked them to keep two numbers in mind as they go forward.
"It costs $10,000 a year to keep a child in school; it costs $30,000 a year to keep someone in prison," he said. "If we are unwilling to act on this issue, in this upcoming legislative session, we will by default be choosing prisons over schools."
Obviously, it’s more expensive to house and feed an inmate than to teach a child. One is a round-the-clock operation; the other isn’t. But are the governor’s numbers right? Is there a 3-to-1 ratio? We figured this would be a simple check.
Right away, through the magic of the Internet, we found a news report from 2012 in The Oregonian that stated that "the state spends an average of $30,000 a year to house, feed and care for an inmate."
Of course, PolitiFact Oregon is all about primary sources, so we went to the Department of Corrections, where we found a quick facts page.It states that the daily cost of housing an inmate in the 2011-13 budget period is $84.81 -- which comes out to nearly $31,000 a year.
The governor’s Commission on Public Safety reports a slightly lower number still in the ballpark -- $82.48 a day or $30,105 a year. The cost is for "security, health care, food, recidivism reduction programs like mental health and drug treatment, and other operational costs, but excludes community corrections grants, debt service, capital construction, and new prison start‐up costs."
(The $82.48 figure is the same as in a Legislative Fiscal Office analysis of the Corrections budget, dated September 2011. What we’re trying to say is that both per day breakdowns come from the same source, the state.)
OK, one number down, another to go.
The Oregon Department of Education also has nifty numbers, including spending per pupil. In 2010-11, operational expenses were nearly $9,400 per student, statewide. (Capital spending per child was $777, but we’re going to stick with the $9,400 figure because the corrections cost does not include capital spending.)
The costs range, of course, from $27,947 apiece for 35 students in the Burnt River School District in Baker County to $5,566 in the Scio School District in Linn County. Portland Schools, the largest in the state, spends about $11,830 per student.
We should note here that prosecutors are not enthusiastic about Kitzhaber’s plans to "reform" public safety, and say that the Oregon’s corrections system is fine as is. John Foote, Clackamas County’s district attorney, served on the governor’s public safety commission and submitted a minority report supported by district attorneys, the association of chiefs of police and the state sheriffs’ association.
We contacted Foote. He concurs on the math, but he says Oregon is considered a high cost state, in that we don’t incarcerate a lot of people but the cost is high when we do. The obvious fix, he says, is to lower the daily cost of incarceration.
Are we very high on daily costs? That’s a perfectly fine question for another PolitiFact. In this PolitiFact, we’re checking Kitzhaber’s math.
Kitzhaber, in his State of the State speech, implored lawmakers to work with him to boost spending for children and families, including more money into classrooms. As part of that initiative, he proposed lowering costs in health care and in prisons, as well as taking a hard look at tax expenditures and public pension reform.
He asked lawmakers to keep two numbers in mind: $10,000 to keep a child in school, versus $30,000 to keep an inmate in prison. The average operational cost of educating a child is even lower, on statewide average, further underscoring his point. We rate the statement True.
Published: Friday, January 18th, 2013 at 4:34 p.m.
The Oregonian, "Judge grants Measure 11 convict a rare early release," April 19, 2012
The Oregonian, "Oregon Prison Puzzle: Cut costs but keep public safe," Oct. 28, 2012
The Oregonian, "Gov. John Kitzhaber praises Oregon Legislature, outlines difficult agenda," Jan. 14, 2013
Text of Gov. John Kitzhaber’s State of the State address, Jan. 14, 2013
Oregon Department of Education, Actual Operating vs Capital Expenditures Per Student (#51)
Oregon Department of Corrections, "Issue Brief - 2012"
Commission on Public Safety, "Final Report to the Governor," December 2012
John S. Foote, "Alternative Report and Recommendations in the Governor’s 2012 Commission on Public Safety," December 2012
Emails from John Foote, Jan. 16, 2013
Emails from and interview with Tim Raphael, governor’s spokesman, Jan. 17, 2013
Oregon Department of Corrections, "Governor Kitzhaber’s Public Safety Commission," Sept. 30, 2011
Oregon Legislative Fiscal Office, "Correctional Spending Trends," September 2011
We want to hear your suggestions and comments. Email the Oregon Truth-O-Meter with feedback and with claims you'd like to see checked. If you send us a comment, we'll assume you don't mind us publishing it unless you tell us otherwise.