Pants on Fire!
Bloggers
Spicer: "Trump has the legal right to cancel SCOTUS because they serve at his pleasure"

Bloggers on Wednesday, June 21st, 2017 in a blog

It's fake news that the president can disband the Supreme Court

This fake news story about the president's ability to disband the Supreme Court came from USPOLN, a satirical news website.

A June 21 fake news story on USPOLN.com reported that White house press secretary Sean Spicer declared that the president holds the power to disband the U.S. Supreme Court.

"President Trump not only has the power to fire Robert Mueller; he also has the legal ability and right to cancel and disband the Supreme Court of the United States as well, should he feel the need for it. And no one could argue with such a decision," Spicer is quoted as saying in the story.

The story claims Spicer shared this information in a press briefing media outlets were banned from airing, in which he also announced Trump was sending his thoughts and prayers to the victims of a U.S. Navy ship wreckage and of a terrorist attack in London.

The press conference the post references indeed took place, on June 19. While it was not televised, a transcript was shared on the White House website. Spicer did offer the White House’s condolences to the victims and said Mueller’s fate was in Trump’s hands, but he never suggested the president holds the power to disband the Supreme Court.

In fact, the Supreme Court was not mentioned during the briefing.

The story manipulated Spicer’s quote that "everyone who serves the president serves at the pleasure of the President," referring to the fact that Mueller’s superior, Deputy Attorney General Rod Rosenstein, ultimately answers to the president. The Supreme Court, however, does not.

The checks and balances put in place by the U.S. Constitution are designed to ensure equilibrium of power between the legislative, executive and judicial branches — that means one branch can’t just shut down another.

The Constitution prohibits the president from firing a justice, much less all nine of them, or disbanding the institution they represent. It also hands power over to the courts to decide on the legality of an executive action.

The president may nominate Supreme Court justices, court of appeals judges and district court judges, although these must be vetted by the Senate. Neil Gorsuch is the only Supreme Court justice Trump has appointed so far.

The website that published the story did not respond to a request for comment, but it does contain a disclaimer published in the "about us" tab.

"USPOLN may include information from sources that may or may not be reliable and facts that don’t necessarily exist," the disclaimer reads. "These articles should be considered satirical and any and all quotes attributed to actual people complete and total baloney."

While some of the details about the press conference are correct, Spicer’s comments about the presidential ability to disband the courts is complete and total baloney.

We rate this statement Pants on Fire!

Share the Facts
1
1
7
PolitiFact rating logo PolitiFact Rating:
Pants on Fire
Spicer: "Trump has the legal right to cancel SCOTUS because they serve at his pleasure"
Wednesday, June 21, 2017