"If the House of Representatives fails to extend the middle-class tax cuts, 400,000 middle-class Rhode Island families will see their federal income taxes increase."
Barack Obama on Wednesday, December 5th, 2012 in a report
Obama says fiscal cliff poses risk to 400,000 middle class Rhode Island families
If the fiscal cliff talks don't come to a resolution by Jan. 1, people will have to start paying more in taxes because the Bush tax cuts will no longer be in effect.
In an attempt to give taxpayers a sense of the impact of not extending the cuts, the Obama administration has issued state-by-state estimates of how many families would be affected if the cuts expire.
In a report tailored for Rhode Island, the administration claims: "If the House of Representatives fails to extend the middle-class tax cuts, 400,000 middle-class Rhode Island families will see their federal income taxes increase."
Rhode Island only has a million people (1,051,302 according to the latest census estimate). So 400,000 middle-class families seemed like a high number to us. We decided to check.
The latest data from the Census Bureau says there are 412,259 households in Rhode Island, but only 256,181 households with families. The rest are non-family households, mostly people living alone. That's a huge difference.
(There's an identical problem with the national numbers the Obama administration is using. The White House says 114 million middle-class families across the United States would be affected. The number of families is actually 76 million.)
The second problem: Not all Rhode Island’s 256,000 families are middle-class families.
The federal poverty level is about $15,000 a year for a family of two. According to the latest census income data from 2011, 8.4 percent of Rhode Island families -- about 21,500 -- had an income of less than $15,000.
Subtract that number from 256,000 and you get about 234,500 families.
(If you do the same calculation on a national level, the 114 million middle-class families that the White House talks about is really fewer than 70 million families.)
Another complication: There is no official definition of middle class. People in a wide range of income levels consider themselves to be there.
"Everybody thinks he's middle class," said Nick Kasprak, an analyst with The Tax Foundation, a business-backed group that studies tax policy. Kasprak said the category is meaningless.
In addition, Kasprak said, everyone who already pays taxes will be in the same boat if a deal isn't reached, whether they would be considered middle class or not.
"The only people who are unaffected by the fiscal cliff are the people that don’t file a tax return," Kasprak said in an e-mail. Tax increases "hit pretty much everyone" who files. "If you pay taxes at all, they will go up – there’s no cutoff line."
We contacted the White House to ask about its numbers, but no one would talk to us for the record.
In summary, the Obama administration is taking the number of households in the United States -- and Rhode Island -- and inaccurately categorizing them as middle-class families.
There's no need to exaggerate the numbers. Without an agreement on tax reform, a lot of people are going to be affected.
But saying that the number of middle-class Rhode Island families to be affected is 400,000 is a substantial exaggeration. We rate Mr. Obama's claim False.
(With staff reports from Paul Edward Parker and Philip Marcelo. If you have a claim you’d like PolitiFact Rhode Island to check, e-mail us at email@example.com. And follow us on Twitter: @politifactri.)
Published: Sunday, December 16th, 2012 at 12:01 a.m.
WhiteHouse.gov, "Extending the Middle-Class Tax Cuts: It's the Right Thing To Do," accessed Dec. 11, 2012
FactFinder2.Census.gov, "Your source for population, housing, economic, and geographic information," U.S. Census Bureau, Tables S1101 and S1901 for Rhode Island and the United States, accessed Dec. 10 and 14, 2012
PolitiFact.com, "Are You Middle Class?" Sept. 30, 2008
U.S. Department of Health and Human Services, "2012 HHS Poverty Guidelines," accessed Dec. 11, 2012
E-mail, Nick Kasprak, The Tax Foundation, Dec. 11, 2012
We want to hear your suggestions and comments. Email the Rhode Island Truth-O-Meter with feedback and with claims you'd like to see checked. If you send us a comment, we'll assume you don't mind us publishing it unless you tell us otherwise.