"A miscarriage is considered an abortion."
Eddie Lucio, Jr. on Thursday, February 17th, 2011 in remarks on the Senate floor
State Sen. Eddie Lucio said a miscarriage is considered an abortion
State Sen. Eddie Lucio Jr., among supporters of a proposal requiring women seeking an abortion to first get a sonogram, made a dramatic statement in the floor debate before senators advanced the measure to the House.
"There are literally millions of abortions going on each year in our own state," the Brownsville Democrat said Feb. 17, adding that he would "like to see the definition of abortion really be looked at. A miscarriage is considered an abortion, and I don’t think it should be considered an abortion because that’s a natural thing that unfortunately happens."
After we sought more information from Lucio’s office, Lucio spoke again in the debate, saying: "A while ago I was speaking with numbers, I misspoke with my numbers."
For other articles, we’ve confirmed that there have been about 50 million abortions nationally since the 1973 U.S. Supreme Court Roe v. Wade ruling and that 80,000 abortions took place Texas in 2008.
As we started to check Lucio’s other floor statement — that a miscarriage is considered an abortion — Lucio told us in an e-mail statement that friends who lost a baby and underwent a procedure to remove the fetus from the womb told him their insurance company considered the procedure an abortion. He said he didn’t intend to suggest that a miscarriage in itself should be considered an abortion. "I have strong beliefs about life," Lucio said. "In an effort to articulate my beliefs... I misspoke."
We sought independent guidance on whether a miscarriage is considered an abortion.
Carrie Williams, a spokeswoman for the Texas Department of State Health Services, told us miscarriages are sometimes referred to as "spontaneous abortions," though she said that the agency doesn’t include them in its annual abortion counts.
No law requires the agency to track miscarriages, Williams said. "Unfortunately miscarriages are very common and often happen before a woman even knows she’s pregnant making complete and accurate data collection very difficult," she said.
She cited the legal definition of abortion in Texas. According to the Texas Health and Safety Code, an abortion is "an act or procedure performed after pregnancy has been medically verified and with the intent to cause the termination of a pregnancy other than for the purpose of either the birth of a live fetus or removing a dead fetus."
According to the Guttmacher Institute, which studies and advocates on issues related to reproductive health, 66 percent of 6.4 million pregnancies in 2008 resulted in live births and 19 percent ended in abortions. In Texas, 70 percent of 579,700 pregnancies were live births and 15 percent ended in abortions. An estimated 15 percent of pregnancies result in miscarriages, according to the institute.
Rebecca Wind, an institute spokeswoman, told us that while "spontaneous abortion" is the medical term for an abortion, miscarriages aren’t included in abortion statistics and there is no national effort to track miscarriages. "In many cases, women who have miscarriages may not know they have had them," Wind said, because one can happen early in a pregnancy.
Next, we contacted the Texas Medical Association, which represents 45,000 physicians and medical students. Spokeswoman Pam Udall confirmed that doctors usually call a miscarriage a spontaneous abortion because "the body itself is aborting the pregnancy," she said. "It is a natural consequence that affects up to one in four pregnancies."
Udall pointed us to a 2002 pamphlet written by the American Congress of Obstetricians and Gynecologists, which says "the loss of a pregnancy before 20 weeks is called early pregnancy loss. Often the loss is a miscarriage (sometimes called spontaneous abortion by doctors)."
Where does that leave us?
There’s truth in Lucio’s statement: In medical terms, a miscarriage is also termed a spontaneous abortion. Where the senator got off track was in conflating those natural occurrences with elective abortions — medical procedures that terminate a pregnancy.
We rate his statement as Half True.
Published: Tuesday, March 1st, 2011 at 6:00 a.m.
State Sen. Eddie Lucio’s remarks on the Senate floor, Feb. 17, 2011
Guttmacher Institute, State facts about abortion: Texas, accessed Feb. 17, 2011
Guttmacher Institute, Trends in abortion in Texas, 1973-2008, January 2011
Texas Department of State Health Services, Induced terminations of pregnancy, updated July 20, 2010, accessed Feb. 17, 2011
Texas Department of State Health Services, Vital statistics annual reports, last updated Aug. 4, 2010, accessed Feb. 17, 2011
Texas Department of State Health Services, Handbook on fetal death registration, accessed Feb. 21, 2011
Texas Constitution and Statutes, Health and Safety code, Title 4. Health facilities, Subtitle B. Licensing of health facilities, Chapter 245. Abortion facilities, Sec. 245.002. Definitions, accessed Feb. 18, 2011
The American Congress of Obstetricians and Gynecologists, Early pregnancy loss: Miscarriages and molar pregnancy, 2002
E-mail statement from state Sen. Eddie Lucio, Jr., Feb. 18, 2011
E-mail interview with Rochelle Tafolla, vice president of marketing and communications, Planned Parenthood of Houston and Southeast Texas, Feb. 17, 2011
E-mail interview with Carrie Williams, press officer, Texas Department of Health and Human, Feb. 17, 2011
E-mail interview with Chris Van Deuesen, assistant press officer, Texas Department of State Health Services, Feb. 21, 2011
Interview with Rebecca Wind, senior communications associate, Guttmacher Institute, Feb. 22, 2011
We want to hear your suggestions and comments. Email the Texas Truth-O-Meter with feedback and with claims you'd like to see checked. If you send us a comment, we'll assume you don't mind us publishing it unless you tell us otherwise.