The story

Obama Girl gets Giuliani right

By John Frank
Published on Tuesday, August 14th, 2007 at 02:23 p.m.


SUMMARY: In her second music video, Obama Girl takes aim at Rudy Giuliani, saying that "at least Obama didn't marry his cousin" as Giuliani did. She is correct about the marriage.

The sexy-sensational YouTube video that appears as the sequel to "I've Got a Crush on Obama" criticizes Giuliani for marrying his cousin. The "Debate 08: Obama Girl vs. Giuliani Girl" music spoof also notes the former New York City mayor's three marriages and previous appearances in drag.

Despite the silly rhymes and contagious beat (which we can't get out of our heads), we find Obama Girl's claims are accurate.

In 1968, Giuliani wed his second cousin, Regina Peruggi, who was the daughter of his father's first cousin. (Think of your son/daughter marrying your cousin's daughter/son.)

Giuliani at different points labeled the family connection as "second cousins once removed" and "third cousins," before he was corrected.

In a 1993 memo for his mayoral campaign, a Giuliani strategist noted the "weirdness" factor of the marriage, according to a memo posted on the Smoking Gun Web site, but such a marriage is completely legal. In New York, even first cousins can wed.

Robin Bennett, senior genetic counselor at the University of Washington, said there is not much scientific research about the risk of developmental difficulties for the offspring of second cousins but she said "for second cousins, the risks are likely similar to the risks of couples from the same ethnic population who also may have common ancestors."

Giuliani and Peruggi did not have any children, and the marriage ended after 14 years. A Catholic priest who was a long-time Giuliani friend granted his request for an annulment on the grounds that the church had never given dispensation for the relatives' union.

Two years later, he married Donna Hanover, a Miami television reporter. But that marriage ended in 2002 with a bitter divorce. Within a year, he wed a third time to Judith Nathan, a former pharmaceutical sales manager turned-Giuliani-speech-writer.

Giuliani's propensity to dress in drag is also well-documented. When mayor in 1997, he appeared as a busty woman at a political roast and even dressed the part for an appearance on Saturday Night Live. (Type "Giuliani in drag" into YouTube and enjoy/beware.) As for how he looked, we make no ruling. Here's the video:

Advertisement
Bookmark this
About this story

Sources: The Los Angeles Times: May 7, 2007 "Private lives and public tolerance; Giuliani, with two marriages and a messy divorce behind him, hopes the post-Clinton era will be kind to him."

New York Times, "RACE FOR CITY HALL: The Republican Candidate; A Mercurial Mayor's Confident Journey"

The Associated Press, "Rudy Giuliani in a dress: Will voters care?"

The Smoking Gun, Rudy Giuliani's "Vulnerabilities" Memo

Researchers: Angie Drobnic Holan

Personalities: Barack Obama, Rudy Giuliani

Related rulings:
Obama Girl on Candidate Biography, Thursday, July 19th, 2007. Ruling: True | Details

Contribute

No, we don’t want to take your money. But we are more than willing to listen if you know of any facts or story ideas for the Truth-O-Meter. truthometer@politifact.com

PolitiFact.com

PolitiFact is a project of the St. Petersburg Times and Congressional Quarterly to help you find the truth in the presidential campaign. Every day, reporters and researchers from the Times and CQ will analyze the candidates' speeches, TV ads and interviews and determine whether the claims are accurate. >> More

Logos
Sorting out the truth in politics
Candidates

Search PolitiFact via Google

Browse
Feeds

Get PolitiFact:

Knight Batten Award
Advertisement