The article:

Visiting Iraq

By Alexander Lane
Published on Friday, May 30th, 2008 at 4:23 p.m.

SUMMARY: As the experience question is raised again, Sen. John McCain says his many visits to Iraq are part of what makes him better prepared than Sen. Barack Obama to lead the country, which in turn raises the question of how valuable those congressional trips really are.

McCain, his surrogates and his allies have lambasted Obama in recent days for having visited Iraq just once during the war, which they say reflects a failure on his part to learn about the conflict and bone up on national security issues.

"Sen. Obama and I have a strong disagreement on this issue," McCain told a crowd at a town hall meeting in Reno, Nev., on May 28, 2008. "And Sen. Obama has been to Iraq once. A little over two years ago he went."

It echoed a charge in an advertisement by the anti-Obama group Vets for Freedom . "The last time Barack Obama visited Iraq was in January 2006," the ad said. "Since then, much has changed." The Republican National Committee chimed in with a new feature on its Web site that counts the days since Obama last visited Iraq.

Indeed, it is true that Obama has visited Iraq just once, in early 2006. McCain has visited Iraq eight times during the war, so to the extent that he steers the debate to time spent in the war zone, he would seem to argue from a position of strength. That's not the whole story though. Two of McCain's Iraq trips have been marked by gaffes that critics said called into question his command of the issues in Iraq. And the larger record of senatorial visits to Iraq suggests that elected officials get a limited view of the action there.

First, though, McCain's side of the story: Obama's scant time in Iraq reflects the larger problem that he is inexperienced on matters of national security, and has not made enough of an effort to learn about what is happening in Iraq, Republicans argue.

"He really has no experience or knowledge or judgment about the issue of Iraq," McCain said in an interview with the Associated Press on May 26. "If there was any other issue before the American people, and you hadn't had anything to do with it in a couple of years, I think the American people would judge that very harshly."

A close ally of McCain's, South Carolina Republican Sen. Lindsey Graham, suggested recently that Obama travel with McCain to Iraq. McCain said that would be fine with him. "I go back every few months because things are changing in Iraq," McCain told the Associated Press. "I would also seize that opportunity to educate Sen. Obama along the way."

The record shows that McCain's first trip was in August 2003, about three months after President Bush declared an end to major combat activity in Iraq – and it was indeed a learning experience.

McCain was troubled by what he saw, and upon his return became somewhat critical of the war effort, an uncommon stance at the time for a Republican. He said on NBC's Meet the Press that the president should send more troops and resources to Iraq.

"Time is not on our side," he told host Tim Russert. "People in 125-degree heat with no electricity and no fuel are going to become angry in a big hurry. The sophistication of the attacks on U.S. and allied troops have increased. And what we do in the next several months will determine whether we're in a very difficult situation or not, and there's still time, but we've got to act quickly."

Prominent Democrats had been saying much the same thing, and lauded McCain's candor. However, remarks he made after two more recent trips to Iraq – last spring lauding security in a market that was heavily guarded just for his visit, and in March mistakenly accusing Shiite-dominated Iran of training the Sunni group Al Qaeda in Iraq – have sparked questions about his own knowledge of the situation on the ground in Iraq.

Obama's campaign did not respond to a request for comment, but Democrats and independent experts have called into question the value of senatorial visits to Iraq. Sen. Jim Webb, D-Va., referred to the trips as "dog and pony shows" in July 2007. Majority Leader Sen. Harry Reid of Nevada told reporters in March 2008 that after visiting Iraq he came to see the trips as a waste of military resources. "We had helicopters moving around, we had numerous security people around me, and my personal feeling is, I would rather those people trying to protect me were trying to protect other people," the Democratic leader said.

Ted Galen Carpenter, a defense expert at the libertarian Cato Institute and critic of the Iraq war since before the invasion, said that judging by the reports and news accounts the congressional trips to Iraq are "basically guided tours by the U.S. military." "Anyone in a congressional delegation or in any other capacity who thinks they will have the ability to really see Iraq and understand what's going on is I think being a little nave," Carpenter said. Nevertheless, Obama told the New York Times that he was considering visiting Iraq this summer after he wins the nomination, but he was not likely to go with McCain. "I think that if I'm going to Iraq, then I'm there to talk to troops and talk to commanders," he said May 28, 2008. "I'm not there to try to score political points or perform. The work they're doing there is too important."

On MSNBC's "Morning Joe" that day, Obama spokesman Robert Gibbs said Obama would want to talk to troops and commanders to "see what sort of difficulties they're facing and see how it is that we can begin to carefully remove them and carefully bring them back to their families and bring them back to the United States."

McCain spokesman Brian Rogers portrayed that as an intention to surrender. "It's unfortunate that Sen. Obama continues to refuse to seek the facts but instead will go to Iraq, look our troops in the eye, and admit defeat," Rogers said in a press release.

About this article:

Sources:The Hill, 'Have You Been to Iraq?' — 76 Sens. Say They Have" by Patrick Fitzgerald, August 1, 2007

Chicago Sun-Times, "Obama Sees No Military Solution in Iraq: He Visits Baghdad, Calls For Sunni Participation, U.S. Troop Reductions" by Lynn Sweet, Jan. 8, 2006

Los Angeles Times, "Lawmakers Call on Iraq to Shape Up" by Borzou Daragahi, Jan. 8, 2006

Youtube, John McCain: Obama Should See Iraq for Himself from May 28, 2008, speech in Nevada

Chicago Daily Herald, "Obama: 'Everything's Up for Grabs' in Iraq" by Eric Krol, Jan. 8, 2006

Milwaukee Journal-Sentinel, "Feingold reports no ground made against the insurgency" by Katherine M. Skiba, March 29, 2006

Washington Post, "Biden to fight Iraq troop buildup" by Walter Pincus, Dec. 27, 2006

Fort Worth Star-Telegram, "Surge: a mission to accomplish what?" Jan. 10, 2007

New York Times, "McCain Missteps on Iraq; Democrats Pounce" by Michael Cooper, March 19, 2008

Washington Post, "McCain Arrives in Iraq, Plans to Meet Maliki" by Joshua Partlow, March 17, 2008

MSNBC's "FirstRead" blog, "McCain: Visiting Baghdad," March 17, 2008

"Meet the Press" transcript, August 24, 2003

Associated Press, "U.S. Soldiers Question Use of More Armor" by Ryan Lenz, Jan. 8, 2006

Chicago Daily Herald, "In Baghdad, Reality Is Easy to Picture but Hard to Truly See" by Chuck Goudie, Jan. 9, 2006

St. Louis Post-Dispatch, "After Iraq Visit, Bond Warns of Compromised Intelligence" by Bill Lambrecht, Jan. 14, 2006

Republican National Committee Web site Days since Obama visited Iraq

Morning Joe Transcript of interview with Obama spokesman Robert Gibbs, May 29, 2008

Congressional Quarterly Transcripts, Harry Reid press conference, March 11, 2008

Meet the Press, transcript for July 15, 2007

New York Times, "Obama Weighs a Visit to the Troops in Iraq" by Jeff Zeleny, May 29, 2008

Interview with McCain spokesman Brian Rogers, May 29, 2008

Researchers: Alexander Lane

Names in this article: John McCain, Barack Obama

How to contact us:

We want to hear your suggestions and comments.

For tips or comments on our Obameter and our GOP-Pledge-O-Meter promise databases, please e-mail the Obameter. If you are commenting on a specific promise, please include the wording of the promise.

For comments about our Truth-O-Meter or Flip-O-Meter items, please e-mail the Truth-O-Meter. We’re especially interested in seeing any chain e-mails you receive that you would like us to check out. If you send us a comment, we'll assume you don't mind us publishing it unless you tell us otherwise.

Browse The Truth-O-MeterTM: