The Truth-O-Meter Says:
Wirch

"Over the course of one four-year term, it costs taxpayers more than $1 million simply to operate" the governor’s mansion.

Bob Wirch on Monday, November 15th, 2010 in a news release

State Sen. Bob Wirch says it costs Wisconsin taxpayers more than $1 million over four-tear term to run the governor's mansion

The governor’s mansion -- a kingly abode for the governor and his family, right?

Don’t think like a peasant. It is so much more.

"Executive residences," as the National Governors Association calls them, are "regarded as an important symbol of the state’s culture and heritage. As state treasures, executive residences provide an appropriate setting for official state entertaining and are often highly valued as a venue for community functions."

Oh.

The NGA goes on:

"Given the critical role executive residences play in official state and cultural activities, considerable care is required in managing, staffing and maintaining the executive residence."

Gee, sounds like that could get kinda expensive. Just how much does it cost taxpayers to run the Wisconsin governor’s mansion -- ahem, executive residence?

Too much, says state Sen. Bob Wirch, a Democrat from Pleasant Prairie in Kenosha County. Echoing a call he made in 2002, when Democratic Gov. Jim Doyle was elected, Wirch wants Republican Governor-elect Scott Walker to sell or lease the 34-room manor.

"Over the course of one four-year term," Wirch claimed in a news release Nov. 15, 2010, "it costs taxpayers more than $1 million simply to operate."

Wirch also noted Walker’s own call to citizens for ideas on how to make state government run more efficiently. After all, with a structural deficit, lost revenue because of a state Supreme Court decision and other issues, the new governor faces a projected shortfall of $3 billion for the 2011-’13 budget.

"It is hard to set a good example," Wirch said in his statement, "if you are living in a mansion."

Walker, who will be inaugurated Jan. 3, 2011, plans to move with his family from Wauwatosa into the residence, said his spokesman, Cullen Werwie.

He said Walker has no comment on Wirch’s recommendation to sell or lease the mansion, which is perched on the shores of Lake Mendota.

The home’s "replacement value" is $1.63 million, according to the state Department of Administration. But Wirch believes that with its 3.7 acres of land, the estate is worth more than $2.5 million.

Perhaps, like us, you’ve never been to the mansion (although you can see it in pictures).

Well, according to the Department of Administration, the state Historical Society and the office of first lady Jessica Doyle, it:

  • Is a three-story, 21,000-square-foot (including basement) Georgian Revivalin Maple Bluff, a village northeast of Madison.
  • Was built in 1921 for Madison industrialist Carl A. Johnson and became home to governors after being purchased by the state in 1949.
  • Has 13 bathrooms, seven bedrooms, seven fireplaces and seven garden areas.


Nice. So, who takes care of it?

Seven employees, according to Vicki Heymann, the mansion’s residence director. Full-timers include Heymann, a chef, a gardener and a "facilities maintenance specialist." The part-timers are a housekeeper, a "laundress and flower arranger," and the head of the waitstaff, who has worked at the mansion for more than 32 years.

OK, now let’s get to Wirch’s claim that operating the mansion costs more than $1 million during a four-year term.

Wirch’s office said the state Legislative Fiscal Bureau put the operating costs at $265,000 per year. That would come to $1.06 million over four years.

The senator’s per-year number is a touch high, but his four-year figure of more than $1 million is on target.

The fiscal bureau told PolitiFact Wisconsin that the mansion’s operating expenses are budgeted at $262,500 in 2009-’10 and the same amount for 2010-’11, nearly all of which is salaries. That’s a total of $1.05 million over four years.

In fact, actual expenditures are running higher, according to the state Department of Administration. They were $290,462 in 2008-’09 and $273,340 in 2009-’10. If that were carried out over four years, the total would be $1.13 million.

Wisconsin is one of 44 states that provided a governor’s residence as of 2004, according to the most recent survey done by the National Governors Association.

Here’s how three of the other six treat their governors:

  • Rhode Island doesn’t have a mansion -- and probably doesn’t need one. You can drive across the state in an hour, said Amy Kempe, spokeswoman for the governor.
  • Idaho had a governor’s residence, then didn’t, then did again when one was donated by a billionaire potato magnate. Gov. C.L. "Butch" Otter had been receiving a monthly housing allowance of more than $4,000. But Otter stopped taking the money in March 2009 when the 7,400-square-foot Idaho House became available and he opted to continue commuting from his ranch, his spokesman said.
  • California’s governors are on their own, because the state doesn’t provide a residence or a housing allowance, said Joe Wolfenden, senior guide at the California Governor’s Mansion. Now a state park destination, the mansion was last used by a governor in 1967, when Ronald Reagan lived there for three months before moving to a home that had been purchased by friends.


OK, let’s bring all this mansion talk home.

In calling on Governor-elect Scott Walker to save taxpayer dollars, state Sen. Bob Wirch said selling or leasing the governor’s mansion would enable the state to cut more than $1 million over four years on the cost of operating the mansion. Based on the latest budget and expenditure figures, the operating costs do exceed $1 million over four years.

We rate Wirch’s statement True.

Advertisement
About this statement:

Published: Sunday, November 21st, 2010 at 9:00 a.m.

Subjects: State Budget

Sources:

California Governor’s Mansion senior guide Joe Wolfenden, interview, Nov. 18, 2010

California State Parks, governor’s mansion web page

Interview, Idaho Gov. C.L. "Butch" Otter spokesman Jon Hanian, Nov. 18, 2010

J.R. Simplot Co., origins and founder web page

Milwaukee Journal Sentinel, Madison mansion a target again, Nov. 29, 2002

Milwaukee Journal Sentinel, Court strikes down raid on malpractice fund, July 20, 2010

National Governors Association, Managing the executive residence, 2005

National Governors Association, Staffing, organizing and operating the governor’s office, 2006

New York Times, Talk of selling an empty house has Boise buzzing, Feb. 26, 2010

Rhode Island Gov. Donald L. Carcieri spokeswoman Amy Kempe, interview, Nov. 18, 2010

State of Idaho, The governor’s house website

Wisconsin Department of Administration, Governor’s executive residence website

E-mail interview, Wisconsin Department of Administration spokeswoman Emily Winecke, Nov. 17, 2010

Interview, Wisconsin Executive Residence director Vicki Heymann, Nov. 17, 2010

Wisconsin First Lady Jessica Doyle, executive residence website

Wisconsin Governor-elect Scott Walker, citizen suggestions web page

Interview, Wisconsin Governor-elect Scott Walker spokesman Cullen Werwie, Nov. 18, 2010

Interview and e-mails, Wisconsin Legislative Fiscal Bureau analyst Jere Bauer, Nov. 16 and 17, 2010

Wisconsin Legislative Fiscal Bureau, 2009-’11 and 2011-’13 General Fund Budget (page 5), July 9, 2010

Wisconsin Historical Society, Governor’s mansion

Wisconsin Sen. Bob Wirch, news release, Nov. 15, 2010

E-mail interview, Wisconsin Sen. Bob Wirch spokesman Michael Tierney, Nov. 16, 17 and 18, 2010

Wisconsin State Legislature, Bob Wirch biography

University of Wisconsin-Madison, How large is Wisconsin’s budget gap for the 2011-’13 biennium, 2010

Written by: Tom Kertscher
Researched by: Tom Kertscher
Edited by: Greg Borowski

How to contact us:

We want to hear your suggestions and comments. Email the Wisconsin Truth-O-Meter with feedback and with claims you'd like to see checked. If you send us a comment, we'll assume you don't mind us publishing it unless you tell us otherwise.

Browse The Wisconsin Truth-O-Meter:
Subscribe:

Keep up to date with Politifact Wisconsin: