"One out of every four students fails to earn a high school diploma. In our major cities across America, half of our kids don’t graduate."
Paul Ryan on Tuesday, December 4th, 2012 in a speech
One in four kids and half in big cities don't graduate high school, Paul Ryan says
On Dec. 4, 2012, a month after the presidential election, Republican stars Paul Ryan and Marco Rubio gave speeches at a Washington event that were described as charting a new path for the GOP.
Ryan, coming off a defeat as Mitt Romney’s vice-presidential running mate, spoke about the government’s response to poverty. He argued that "in most cases, we’re still trying to measure compassion by how much we spend, not by how many people we actually help."
The Wisconsin congressman and House Budget Committee chairman then ticked off a number of poverty-related statistics, including these two, saying:
"One out of every four students fails to earn a high-school diploma. In our major cities across America, half of our kids don’t graduate. Half."
Do so many students fail to finish high school?
Let’s check both parts of Ryan’s claim.
1 in 4 don’t graduate?
We’ll note from the top there are different ways to measure graduation rates, depending on how you account for things such as students who take more than four years to earn a diploma and those who obtain equivalents such as a GED.
The National Center for Education Statistics, the primary federal entity for education data, calculates something called the Averaged Freshman Graduation Rate (AFGR) for students in public high schools. It estimates the rate of public school students who started as freshmen and finished high school within four years -- in other words, those who graduated "on time."
(We’ll also note that while the government tracks enrollment for private high school students, it doesn’t track graduation rates. About 15 million students attend public high schools and about 1.3 million attend private high schools; that means about 8 percent of all students are in private high schools.)
Ryan press secretary Kevin Seifert cited the most recent AFGR to support the first part of Ryan’s claim -- that "one out of every four students fails to earn a high school diploma." The figures show that in the 2008-2009 school year, the AFGR was 75.5 percent.
To express that another way, three out of four high school students graduated on time -- or, as Ryan put it, one in four did not.
(Wisconsin, by the way, had the highest graduation rate: 90.7 percent.)
Separately, we found that Editorial Projects in Education Research Center, a nonprofit research center and publisher of Education Week, found a nearly identical result using a different calculation. The graduation rate for the class of 2009, the most recent year available, was 73.4 percent.
So, the first part of Ryan’s claim is on target -- as far as it goes. It doesn’t take into account public school students who take more than four years to get a diploma and it doesn’t take into account more than a million kids who attend private high schools.
Half in major cities don’t graduate?
For the second part of Ryan’s claim -- "in our major cities across America, half of our kids don’t graduate" -- Seifert cited a report done by the Editorial Projects in Education Research Center for America’s Promise Alliance. Colin Powell, the retired Army general and secretary of state, is the founding chairman of the alliance, which is dedicated to helping children and youth.
Again, we’re dealing only with public school students.
The April 2009 report, the most recent available, found that 53 percent of public high school students in the nation’s 50 largest cities, including Milwaukee, graduate on time.
(The research center also did a separate calculation for the nation’s 50 largest school districts. Milwaukee Public Schools’ high school graduation rate for 2009 was listed at 52.6 percent, ranking 45th.)
We also contacted some other national experts on high school graduation. Spokesmen for the
Alliance for Excellent Education, which is a partner of the Everyone Graduates Center at Johns Hopkins University; and the Council of the Great City Schools, which represents Milwaukee and 66 other large-city public school districts, said the two sources cited by Ryan are the best and most recent available for public school graduation rates.
Ryan said: "One out of every four students fails to earn a high-school diploma. In our major cities across America, half of our kids don’t graduate."
The claim suggests Ryan was speaking about all students, but his figures apply only to those who attend public school.
We rate the claim Mostly True.
Published: Sunday, December 23rd, 2012 at 9:00 a.m.
C-SPAN, U.S. Rep. Paul Ryan speech (at 18:55), Dec. 4, 2012
Email interview, U.S. Rep. Paul Ryan press secretary Kevin Seifert, Dec. 6, 2012
National Center for Education Statistics, "Public high school graduation rates"
America’s Promise Alliance, "Cities in crisis 2009: Closing the graduation gap," April 22, 2009
Interview, Achieve strategic communications & outreach coordinator Chad Colby, Dec. 12, 2012
PolitiFact National, "Lack of good data makes it impossible to know yet," Aug. 31, 2012
PolitiFact National, "Barack Obama in State of the Union says up to a quarter of U.S. high schoolers drop out," Jan. 25, 2011
National Center for Education Statistics, "Characteristics of the 100 largest public elementary and secondary school districts in the United States: 2008-09," November 2010
Email interview, National Center for Education Statistics staff member Chris Chapman, Dec. 12, 2012
Email interview, Council of the Great City Schools director of communications Henry Duvall, Dec. 14, 2012
Email interview, Alliance for Excellent Education director of communications Jason Amos, Dec. 13, 2012
Email interview, Editorial Projects in Education Research Center senior research associate Sterling Lloyd, Dec. 13, 2012
Email interview, Editorial Projects in Education Research Center research and development vice president Christopher Swanson, Dec. 14, 2012
Editorial Projects in Education Research Center, "Graduation in the 50 largest districts," 2009
We want to hear your suggestions and comments. Email the Wisconsin Truth-O-Meter with feedback and with claims you'd like to see checked. If you send us a comment, we'll assume you don't mind us publishing it unless you tell us otherwise.