By eliminating the public intervenor’s office, "I was the first one to fire Kathleen Falk."
Tommy Thompson on Monday, June 4th, 2012 in a speech
Tommy Thompson says he "fired" Kathleen Falk by eliminating the state public intervenor's office
Republican U.S. Senate candidate Tommy Thompson made an extra effort to demonstrate his passion for property rights while addressing a tea party audience in Oconomowoc on June 4, 2012.
He talked up life on his 700-acre farm. He said as governor he "took on the DNR" -- the Department of Natural Resources -- and also took control of appointing the agency’s leader. He blasted "Agenda 21," the United Nations environmental program.
And, with a touch of glee in his voice, he recounted how as governor he got rid of Kathleen Falk as a public intervenor, a position in the state Attorney General’s office that served as a sort of watchdog in environmental disputes.
Falk, a Democrat appointed to the position by Attorney General Bronson La Follette, later was elected four times as Dane County executive. She lost races for governor in 2002, attorney general in 2006 and governor again in the 2012 recall primary.
"Who had the guts to take away the public intervenor in this state?" Thompson said at a meeting of the Lake Country Area Defenders of Liberty.
"I got rid of Kathleen Falk!" he added, to big laughs in the crowd. "I was the first one to fire Kathleen Falk!"
Did then-Governor Thompson eliminate the public intervenor’s office, getting "rid" of Falk and becoming the "first to fire" her?
Let’s roll back the clock.
The issue arose in 1995, when Thompson -- then in his third term as governor -- sought to eliminate the public intervenor’s office in his two-year budget.
"It’s a law office hired by the state to sue us," Thompson complained at the time. He considered the intervenors "state-financed lawyers for the environmental movement."
Proponents said the office saved the state money by solving problems and heading off lawsuits by environmental groups.
The office was created in 1969 by Gov. Warren Knowles, a Republican, as an independent mediator to represent the public's interest in court and state agency decisions.
The intervenors were assistant attorneys who often sued other state agencies to register objections to plans for highway, dredging and mining projects.
When Thompson made his move, two assistant attorneys general -- Falk and Thomas Dawson -- had full-time intervenor status. Both had served as intervenors under both Republican and Democratic attorneys general.
In his budget bill, Thompson proposed doing away with the intervenor’s office by wiping out the attorney general’s authority to appoint intervenors.
Although Republicans both chambers of the Legislature, the Senate passed a compromise abolishing one intervenor, and moving the other to the Thompson-controlled DNR with no power to sue.
Two years later, the Legislature and Thompson eliminated the DNR position, with Democrats saying it had little authority.
So Thompson can take credit for abolishing the office, which directly led to Falk losing the intervenor job.
But does that mean Thompson fired her?
Both Falk and Dawson stayed on as assistant attorneys general, just doing different assignments. Both positions were under the civil service system, so they could not lose their job by the stroke of Thompson’s pen.
Falk stayed in the office for about two years until she left in 1997 to become Dane County executive. Dawson is a staff attorney in the office. Though Falk and others campaigned in subsequent years for restoring the intervenor’s office, it was never brought back.
Thompson, of course, said he was the "first" to fire Falk.
His campaign said he meant that statewide voters had later rejected her. That rings hollow because she never lost a campaign while holding an office. How can you be "fired" from a job you don’t have?
Thompson said he was the "first to fire" Falk by eliminating the environmental watchdog known as the state public intervenor’s office.
In making the remark, he did so in the context of abolishing the office, so he’s on target there.
In a colloquial sense, "fired" may fit because Thompson knew Falk would no longer be intervenor due to his actions. But he went too far in leaving the impression Falk was out on the street. And Falk was never removed from any other job we know of, so Thompson misfired with "first to fire."
We rate the claim Half True.
Published: Thursday, July 5th, 2012 at 9:00 a.m.
Tommy Thompson, remarks at June 4 campaign appearance, accessed June 28, 2012
Milwaukee Journal Sentinel, "Tea party group grills Thompson," June 4, 2012
Milwaukee Journal and Journal Sentinel archives
Phone interview with Kathleen Falk, June 29, 2012
Phone interview with Thomas Dawson, assistant attorney general, Wisconsin Department of Justice, June 29, 2012
Phone interview with Edwina Kavanaugh, staff attorney, Wisconsin DNR, June 29, 2012
Email interview with Brian Nemoir, spokesman, Tommy Thompson campaign
Phone interview, Peter Davis, Wisconsin Employment Relations Commission, June 29, 2012
We want to hear your suggestions and comments. Email the Wisconsin Truth-O-Meter with feedback and with claims you'd like to see checked. If you send us a comment, we'll assume you don't mind us publishing it unless you tell us otherwise.