Friday, December 19th, 2014

Archived initial version of "McAuliffe says Cuccinelli tried to make it harder for moms to get divorces"

Terry McAuliffe: Says Ken Cuccinelli tried to make it more difficult for mothers to obtain divorces.

On Wednesday, September 4th, 2013 in a TV ad.

Terry McAuliffe, Democratic Party gubernatorial candidate, turned to divorce law this month in his ongoing effort to portray Republican Ken Cuccinelli as insensitive to women.

Here’s the text of a TV ad McAuliffe launched on Sept. 4 that contains a picture of a woman pushing two young children on swings:

"2008. Ken Cuccinelli writes a bill to give Virginia among the most extreme divorce laws in America.

If Cuccinelli had it his way, a mom trying to get out of a bad marriage, over her husband’s objections, could only get divorced if she could prove adultery or physical abuse or her spouse had abandoned her or was sentenced to jail.

Why is Ken Cuccinelli interfering in our private lives?

He’s focused on his own agenda. Not us."

The ad follows a series of McAuliffe claims that Cuccinelli has sought to limit access to abortion and birth control. We wondered whether Cuccinelli really did introduce legislation aimed at making it harder for moms to end bad marriages.

Let’s start with a quick primer on Virginia’s divorce laws. The grounds for ending a marriage include adultery, felony conviction, cruelty or fear of bodily harm, wilful desertion and voluntary separation of 12 months when there are minor children or six months when there are no minor children and a property agreement exists.

Even when other grounds exist, couples often use the separation rule so they can obtain a so-called "no-fault" divorce, according to Edward Barnes, president of Barnes & Diehl, a family law firm. He said the process ends up being a little less expensive and neither party is blamed for the divorce in a final decree, which is among the paperwork available as public records. And if there’s been adultery or other grounds for ending a marriage, the no-fault grounds can be used as a bargaining chip in divorce proceedings by the innocent party.

"I think a lot of lawyers will think in terms of benefit to the children," Barnes said. "There will not be an adultery decree that could be waved around later to hurt the children."

All states have unilateral no-fault divorce grounds, although they vary greatly in the separation time frame required.

Cuccinelli, as a state senator in 2008, introduced legislation that would have eliminated the ability for a spouse in a couple with minor children to unilaterally file for divorce under the separation ground. The bill would have allowed the other spouse to block the process by filing a written objection. The legislation died in the Senate Courts of Justice Committee.

Cuccinelli explained his support for tougher divorce laws in 2007 and 2009 campaign statements. "Studies show that the dissolution of marriage has long term negative impacts on children and those marriages that last for five years are much more likely to go the distance," he wrote. "For this reason, the state has an interest in marital preservation. I support family law reform that establishes mutual consent divorce and requires counseling where children are involved, unless abuse is involved."

McAuliffe’s TV ad suggests Cuccinelli’s 2008 bill would have weakened the options of moms seeking divorce and strengthened the hands of dads. McAuliffe’s campaign backed that message sending us links of columns from a conservative father’s rights groups supporting tightening divorce rules and from the Pennsylvania chapter of the National Organization for Women defending the no-fault divorce rules in that state.

Neither article addressed Virginia law, Cuccinelli’s bill, or laid out specific arguments that no-fault divorce is more advantageous to mothers than fathers. The father’s group contended that children are best-served by being raised in a household with both of their parents; NOW said it is traumatic for children to remain in homes with dysfunctional marriages.

Barnes said it is misleading for McAuliffe to portray the bill as aimed against mothers. "It’s gender-neutral. Neither side can remarry. Both sides, if they’re living apart, can’t files tax returns as a couple and that costs them."

Our ruling

McAuliffe’s ad says Cuccinelli introduced legislation in 2008 that would have made it more difficult for mothers to obtain divorces.

Cuccinelli’s unsuccessful bill would have eliminated the ability for a spouse in a couple with minor children to unilaterally file for a no-fault divorce. The legislation would have allowed the other spouse to block the process by filing a written objection.

No doubt, the bill would have it harder for moms to obtain divorces. But McAuliffe, in trying to portray it as an attack on women, omits that the legislation would have made it equally more difficult for dads to get divorces.

So McAuliffe’s claim contains an element of truth but ignores critical facts that would give voters a different impression. We rate it Mostly False.

SOURCES

Terry McAuliffe, "Interfering" (TV ad), Sept. 4, 2013.

Emails from Rachel Thomas and Josh Schwerin, McAuliffe spokespeople, Sept. 4, 2013.

Email from Anna Nix, spokeswoman for Cuccinelli, Sept. 4, 2013.

The Washington Post, "New McAuliffe ad in Va. governor race hits Cuccinelli for opposition to no-fault divorce," Sept. 4, 2013.

The Washington Post, "Ken Cuccinelli’s family law stand won him support of fathers’ rights movement," Aug. 28, 2013.

Interview with Edward Barnes, founder and president of Barnes & Diehl, Chesterfield, Sept. 5, 2013.

Richmond Times-Dispatch, "Bills Seek to Make Marriage Sacred Again," Feb. 9, 2008.

Way Back Machine internet archive of Ken Cuccinelli’s website, Feb. 5, 2009.

Way Back Machine internet archive of Ken Cuccinelli’s website, Feb. 3, 2007.

Virginia State Bar, "Divorce in Virginia," accessed Sept. 5, 2013.

Email from Lynne Marie Kohm, John Brown McCarty Professor of Family Law at

Regent University School of Law, Sept. 5, 2013.

Divorce Law Firms, "States That Allow Covenant Marriage and Divorce," accessed Sept. 5, 2013.

Virginia State Bar, Family Law, accessed Sept. 5, 2013.

National Affairs, "The Evolution of Divorce," Fall 2009.

Virginia Bar Association, "Understanding Realistic Reconciliation in an Age of Divorce," June 1, 2006.

Crisis Magazine, "The No Blame Game," Jan. 3, 2009.

Journal of Marriage and Family, "The Well-Being of Adolescents in Households With No Biological Parents," Nov. 2003.

Journal of Marriage and Family, "Residential Mobility and the Onset of Adolescent Sexual Activity," May 2005.

The Heritage Foundation, "Marriage Still the Safest Place for Women and Children," March 9, 2004.

Journal of Interpersonal Violence, "Correlation Between Different Experiences of Intrafamilial Physical Violence and Violent Adolescent Behavior," 2002.

Pennsylvania National Organization for Women, "No-Fault Divorce Laws Under Attack from Right," January 1997.

Hillary Clinton, "Talking it Over," Jan. 27, 1996.

Written by: Nancy Madsen
Researched by: Nancy Madsen
Edited by: Warren Fiske