"It’s gotten to a point where the average federal worker makes twice as much as the average private sector worker."
John Boehner on Wednesday, November 10th, 2010 in a news conference
Rep. John Boehner says federal workers make twice as much as their private sector counterparts
House GOP Leader John Boehner talks a lot about the need to create jobs as he prepares to take the U.S. House of Representatives’ helm next year.
But the federal government is one entity Boehner thinks shouldn’t create jobs. While talking with reporters Nov. 10, Boehner advocated a hiring and pay freeze on federal workers.
"It’s gotten to a point where the average federal worker makes twice as much as the average private sector worker," Boehner said.
Boehner’s office says he bases that claim on an August 13, 2010 USA Today article, headlined "Federal workers earning double their private counterparts."
The article uses Bureau of Economic Analysis data from the U.S. Commerce Department to conclude that federal civil servants earned average pay and benefits of $123,049 in 2009, while private workers made $61,051 in total compensation.
Although the USA Today statistics back up Boehner’s claim, a BEA spokesman says the newspaper’s numbers don’t account for the different mix of jobs performed by federal and private sector employees.
The statistic cited by USA Today also includes benefits, which tend to be higher for federal employees. That’s an important distinction because we think the average person would interpret "makes twice as much" as getting twice the wages.
We said as much recently when we examined a claim about federal worker pay by Rand Paul, the Republican senator elect from Kentucky. In that item we found BEA statistics show federal employees earned an average salary of $81,258, when benefits were stripped out, compared with $50,464 for private sector employees.
That’s nearly 40 percent short of double.
A statement on BEA’s website explains that the private sector workforce includes a broader range of jobs than the federal government, from minimum wage positions to CEOs. Federal civilian jobs focus on professional areas like law, accounting and economics that require higher education. The federal government has also contracted out many of its lower-skilled, lower paid positions to private industry, which makes the federal average go higher.
John Berry, director of the federal Office of Personnel Management, says it’s untrue that federal workers are paid double the private sector. The USA Today article, he says, compares "apples to oranges." OPM maintains that federal workers actually make 24 percent less than their private-sector counterparts.
"The federal workforce today is highly specialized," he says. "Thirty years ago, over 22 percent of our workforce was in blue collar jobs. Now that percentage has dropped by half while the percentage of IT and health professionals has doubled. Data clearly shows that many of these highly specialized workers – doctors, nurses, cybersecurity professionals – are paid less than their private sector counterparts and are making a significant sacrifice in pay to serve their neighbors."
OPM spokeswoman Jennifer Dorsey did not respond to repeated requests for data that would show lower federal pay for those workers. She did send an email that said the average federal salary is $65,000, and "the figure that was used by the USAToday reporter was and is inaccurate."
So we looked at some federal statistics ourselves, using Bureau of Labor data for mean annual salaries from May 2009. Those statistics list a $43,460 mean yearly salary for the nation’s 130.6 million private sector workers, and a $71,500 mean salary for its 1.9 million federal employees.
That’s about 35 percent short of double.
Just as the BEA data does, the labor data’s private sector average also incorporates hundreds of jobs for which there’s no federal counterpart. So we looked at some specific examples -- the doctors, nurses and cybersecurity professionals that Berry mentioned.
Federally-employed doctors make about the same ($173,400 a year) as their private sector counterparts ($173,860). Federal registered nurses actually make more: $77,830, compared with $66,530. BLS didn’t have a "cybersecurity professionals" category. We found federal "computer specialists" made $88,920, compared to $78,010 for their private-sector counterparts.
So where does that leave us?
- Using the BEA data, the average federal worker salary is considerably short of the "twice as much" level Boehner claimed.
- Using the Bureau of Labor’s data, the gap is a little wider, but the average federal worker pay still is considerably short of double.
That’s why we rate Boehner’s claim False.
Published: Thursday, November 18th, 2010 at 2:31 p.m.
John Boehner news conference, Nov. 10, 2010
USA Today, "Federal workers earning double their private sector counterparts," Aug. 13, 2010
PolitiFact, "Rand Paul says federal workers paid $120,000 a year. The average private employee makes $60,000 a year," Nov. 11, 2010
Bureau of Economic Analysis statement.
Office of Personnel Management statement on employee pay, August 16, 2010
Federal Times, OPM: Pay gap widens; feds fall further behind the private sector, Nov. 1, 2010
Interview with Bureau of Economic Analysis spokesman Ralph Stewart, Nov. 12, 2010
Emails with Office of Personnel Management spokeswoman Jennifer Dorsey, Nov. 12, 2010
The Bureau of Labor Statistics, May 2009 National Industry-Specific Occupational Employment and Wage Estimate: NAICS: 99910 Federal Executive Branch, accessed Nov. 12, 2010
The Bureau of Labor Statistics, May 2009 National Occupational Employment and Wage Estimates, accessed Nov. 12, 2010
We want to hear your suggestions and comments. Email the Ohio Truth-O-Meter with feedback and with claims you'd like to see checked. If you send us a comment, we'll assume you don't mind us publishing it unless you tell us otherwise.