Without a Medicaid expansion, 275,000 more Ohioans could be getting their primary care in emergency rooms, costing "everybody a lot of money."
John Kasich on Monday, February 4th, 2013 in a news conference
Gov. John Kasich says expanding Medicaid would help uninsured who use emergency rooms for primary care
Gov. John Kasich remains opposed to the Affordable Care Act, the health care reform law known as Obamacare. But Kasich's proposed two-year state budget endorses the expansion of Medicaid, the state-federal health program for certain poor and disabled people, that is one of the legislation's key elements.
He made an impassioned case for the expansion in his State of the State address on Tuesday. He said it will guarantee that Ohio tax dollars return to Ohio to pay for it, and that it will deliver basic primary health care to the poor.The federal government will pay 100 percent of the cost for three years, decreasing to 90 percent in 2020 and beyond.
"We don't want 275,000 Ohioans getting their primary care in an emergency room," Kasich said in announcing the plan. "It is not sustainable, it doesn't work, it is not humane and it costs everybody a lot of money -- and more than just the cost of the visit."
PolitiFact Ohio wondered what supported the statement. We were given background by the Governor’s Office of Health Transformation, which was created by executive order two years ago.
Kasich's figure of 275,000 is based on expanding Medicaid coverage to adults making $15,415 or less per year -- 138 percent of the federal poverty line -- which the U.S. Supreme Court made optional for states in its health care decision last June.
Ohio currently covers adults with dependents at up to 90 percent of the federal poverty level and doesn't cover childless adults.
Ohio Medicaid estimated the net change in enrollment would be an increase of 274,753 -- about 275,000 -- using figures from the U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics and the federal Census Bureau.
As for cost, the governor's office pointed to uncompensated care -- the cost of services provided to the uninsured that the uninsured do not pay for themselves.
Those services, the health office said, typically are in hospital emergency departments. Those departments are required to provide care, even if an individual lacks the ability to pay, and end up being used as primary care outlets in non-emergency situations, at a higher cost than care from more appropriate providers.
Uncompensated care accounts for 2.8 percent of all health care spending, according to the Congressional Budget Office and the nonpartisan Urban Institute, and it raises private insurance premiums by up to 1.7 percent. Research by the Kaiser Family Foundation reported the same figures.
It’s a matter of opinion how significant the impact of uncompensated care is on the cost of private insurance. Regardless, the impact would be almost certain to increase without an expansion of Medicaid: Hospitals are reimbursed some of the costs of uncompensated care through the federal Disproportionate Share Hospital (DSH) program, a subsidy that will be scaled back starting in 2014.
Where does that leave Kasich’s statement?
He was correct in stating that according to his administration’s calculations, the Medicaid expansion would cover 275,000 Ohioans whose primary health care might otherwise be provided in emergency rooms, at a higher cost.
Whether that higher expense "costs everybody a lot of money" is largely a matter of how "a lot" is defined. Since uncompensated care represents a relatively small percentage of health care spending, Kasich could be accused of a bit of exaggeration.
With that clarification, we rate the statement as Mostly True.
Published: Thursday, February 21st, 2013 at 4:59 p.m.
WCPN, "Kasich Proposes Medicaid Expansion Offered Under Affordable Care Act," Feb. 4, 2013
WTVG, "Income Tax Cut, Medicaid Expansion in Kasich's Budget," Feb 6, 2013
Dayton Daily News, "Kasich expands Medicaid under Obamacare," Feb. 4, 2013
The Plain Dealer, "Gov. John Kasich focuses on Medicaid, job creation, tax reforms in State of the State address," Feb. 19, 2013
The Plain Dealer, "Ohio to expand Medicaid, despite Gov. John Kasich's opposition to Obamacare," Feb. 4, 2013
Gov. John Kasich, "Transforming Medicaid," Feb. 4, 2013
Email and phone interview with Eric Poklar, director of government affairs, Governor's Office of Health Transformation, Feb. 8, 2013
Governor’s Office of Health Transformation, "Extend Medicaid Coverage and Automate Enrollment," Jan 31, 2013
Governor’s Office of Health Transformation, "Coverage Saves Jobs," Jan. 31, 2013
Urban Institute, "The Cost of Uncompensated Care with and without Health Reform," March 9, 2010
Kaiser Family Foundation, "The Cost and Coverage Implications of the ACA Medicaid Expansion: National and State-by-State Analysis," Nov. 26, 2012
Urban Institute, "Consider Savings as Well as Costs," July 2011
Kaiser Family Foundation, "Covering the Uninsured in 2008:A Detailed Examination of Current Costs and Sources of Payment, and Incremental Costs of Expanding Coverage," August 2008
Health Affairs, "Covering The Uninsured In 2008: Current Costs, Sources Of Payment, And Incremental Costs," August 2008.
We want to hear your suggestions and comments. Email the Ohio Truth-O-Meter with feedback and with claims you'd like to see checked. If you send us a comment, we'll assume you don't mind us publishing it unless you tell us otherwise.