Stand up for facts and support PolitiFact.
Now is your chance to go on the record as supporting trusted, factual information by joining PolitiFact’s Truth Squad. Contributions or gifts to PolitiFact, which is part of the 501(c)(3) nonprofit Poynter Institute, are tax deductible.
I would like to contribute
As U.S. House Speaker Paul Ryan discussed the repeal and replacement of the Affordable Care Act, a top priority of President-elect Donald Trump, he made a claim about the financial health of Medicare.
The Affordable Care Act certainly has its detractors. When Ryan claimed the same month that Obamacare is not a popular law, our rating was Mostly True. The polls generally showed most Americans had an unfavorable opinion of it.
But surprisingly for Ryan, who is regarded as a federal budget expert, his claim about the law flies in the face of evidence that it actually helps shore up Medicare.
What the ACA did on Medicare
Here’s how Marc Goldwein, senior policy director at the Committee for a Responsible Federal Budget, lays it out:
On one side of the ledger, Obamacare slowed the growth of Medicare spending by, among other things, reducing increases in payments made to nearly all health care providers.
On the other side of the ledger, the law included a surtax on high-income earners that brings more money into Medicare.
Two health care policy experts further told us that the combination of spending curbs and revenue increases for Medicare Part A -- which covers hospital, nursing home and home care services, and is financed mainly through payroll taxes -- has extended the solvency of Medicare.
(Medicare Part B, which is voluntary, covers doctor visits and some medical care.)
Paul Ginsburg, a professor of the practice of health policy and management at the University of Southern California, pointed us to an October 2016 report from the nonpartisan Congressional Research Service.
The report noted that in 2010, the Medicare trustees projected that Obamacare’s spending curbs and revenue increases would mean Medicare’s Hospital Insurance Trust Fund, which finances Part A, would remain solvent until 2029.
That’s 12 years later than had been projected a year before the Affordable Care Act became law.
(The projection has since been revised to 2028.)
Michael Sparer, a professor health policy and management at Columbia University in New York, put it this way, financially speaking:
If Obamacare were repealed completely, "it would put Medicare in worse shape, not better shape."
Finally, it’s worth noting that both Factcheck.org and the Washington Post Fact Checker also concluded that Ryan’s claim is wrong. They both also noted that, even if the Part A trust fund did become depleted in 2028, the program wouldn’t be broke, in that it is still set up to cover an estimated 87 percent of expenses.
FactCheck.org’s rating was false and the Fact Checker gave Ryan its worst rating, four Pinnocchios, which is for statements deemed to be "whoppers."
Ryan’s office opted not to provide us any information to support his claim.
Ryan said: "Because of Obamacare, Medicare is going broke."
Financially, Medicare isn’t entirely in the clear, given that actuaries project that a key reserve fund will run out of money in 2028.
But the Medicare trustees themselves, along with a host of experts, say the Affordable Care Act’s changes to Medicare -- including holding the line on spending and raising taxes -- actually puts Medicare in better shape than before the law was adopted. That’s a long way from making Medicare go broke.
We rate Ryan’s statement Pants on Fire.
Fox News, Paul Ryan interview (6:00), Nov. 10, 2016
Email, Paul Ryan press secretary Ian Martorana, Dec. 12, 2016
Interview, Committee for a Responsible Federal Budget senior vice president and senior policy director Marc Goldwein, Dec. 19, 2016
Center on Budget and Policy Priorities, "To Repeat: Medicare Isn’t Going ‘Bankrupt,’" Dec. 5, 2016
Congressoinal Research Service, "Medicare: Insolvency Projections," Oct. 5, 2016
Email, University of Southern California professor of the practice of health policy and management Paul Ginsburg, Dec. 20, 2016
Email, Urban Institute Health Policy Center co-director Stephen Zuckerman, Dec. 19, 2016
Interview, Columbia University professor health policy and management Michael Sparer, Dec. 20, 2016
Read About Our Process
In a world of wild talk and fake news, help us stand up for the facts.