Stand up for the facts!
Our only agenda is to publish the truth so you can be an informed participant in democracy.
We need your help.
I would like to contribute
Conservative commentator Todd Starnes recently wrote: "Students at the University of Texas in Austin have been advised not to wear cowboy boots or cowboy hats on Halloween."
Starnes went on: "Telling a Texan not to wear cowboy boots is like telling Colonel Sanders not to fry chicken."
And did UT-Austin tell students not to don cowboy hats or boots?
Some guidance went to students in advance of Halloween 2016, we confirmed. But those nudges didn’t single out cowboy hats and boots.
Starnes said in his Oct. 28, 2016, opinion piece posted by Fox News that he learned of the advice about hats, boots and other no-no’s from a story posted the same day by the College Fix, a conservative student-written website.
Its story opened: "Leave your cowboy boots and Hawaiian leis at home this Halloween unless you want to hear from University of Texas-Austin administrators."
Like other accounts including a subsequent Houston Chronicle news story and a blog post on the Austin American-Statesman website, the story included a web link to what's described as the relevant checklist for UT students.
An introduction to that checklist, titled "Costume & Theme Selection," states: "You don’t have bad intentions, but your social theme or costume idea could have a negative impact. Themes and costumes may intentionally or unintentionally appropriate another culture or experience."
Hunting for mentions of hats and boots, we saw that at the bottom of the second page, under "Harmful Themes and Costumes," the document lists:
--Any time you paint or tint your skin in an attempt to appear to be a different skin tone, race, or culture (e.g., Blackface)
--Generalized representation/stereotypes of Asian cultures
--’Cowboys and Indians’/anything ‘Squaw’ or generalized depiction of an indigenous person or peoples
The list of discouraged themes or costumes goes on to specify eight other questionable themes. But the mention of "cowboys and Indians" was the closest reference to cowboy hats or boots, as far as we could tell.
Starnes, speaking by phone in response to our inquiry, told us he "extrapolated" his statement about the university advising against cowboy boots and hats solely from the "cowboys and Indians" admonition.
On behalf of the university, administration spokesman J.B. Bird responded to our inquiry by saying the pages highlighted in news accounts fail to note a preceding page in the presentation. Bird then pointed us to UT’s post of a full copy of the guidelines showing that a three-paragraph statement on the first page says the "voluntary guidelines" are intended "to educate students about costume and party theme selection."
That opening section continues: "UT Austin does not place limits on students' freedom of expression. We do not regulate their speech or enforce costume guidelines as rules. Our philosophy is to educate students and remind them that they are accountable to each other and that their actions can negatively impact other members of the university community.
"We offer these voluntary guidelines in that spirit," the section closes.
We asked Bird if the "cowboy/Indian" mention might reasonably be read to deter students from donning cowboy boots or hats on Halloween. Negative, Bird said by phone, in part because nothing there or elsewhere in the guidelines explicitly counsel against simply wearing such hats or boots.
For a student perspective, we reached Will Deer, a senior who told us he’s close to ending a one-year term as the student president of the University of Texas Interfraternity Council, which oversees 29 fraternity chapters.
By phone, Deer said he personally sees the guidelines as mandates that help ensure student events are culturally appropriate. "That’s because I am a representative for the entire IFC community," he said.
But by his read, Deer said, the "cowboys and Indians" portion of the guidelines speaks solely to party themes the university would advise against. Commentator Starnes' claim specific to hats or boots, Deer said, "kind of took that out of context. It’s incorrect."
"The culture here in Texas is cowboy boots and cowboy hats," Deer said.
Starnes wrote: "Students at the University of Texas in Austin have been advised not to wear cowboy boots or cowboy hats on Halloween."
Voluntary student guidelines distributed before Halloween 2016 listed "cowboys and Indians" among potentially harmful themes or costumes to avoid. However, the administration’s advice didn’t stretch to counseling students not to wear cowboy boots or hats.
We rate this claim False.
FALSE – The statement is not accurate. Click here for more on the six PolitiFact ratings and how we select facts to check.
Commentary, Todd Starnes, "University of Texas: No cowboy or Indian costumes," Fox News, Oct. 28, 2016
Story, "University of Texas issues 29-point checklist on offensive Halloween costumes," The College Fix, Oct. 28, 2016
Telephone interview, J.B. Bird, director of media relations, University of Texas at Austin, Nov. 2, 2016
Telephone interview, Todd Starnes, New York, Nov. 2, 2016
Document, "Costume and Theme Selection," Office of the Dean of Students, the University of Texas at Austin, October 2016 (web link received by email from J.B. Bird)
News story, "University of Texas releases 17-point checklist to advise against offensive Halloween costumes," Houston Chronicle, Oct. 31, 2016
Blog post, "UT issues checklist to help students avoid offensive costumes, parties on Halloween," Austin American-Statesman, Oct. 31, 2016
Telephone interviews, Will Deer, president, the University of Texas Interfraternity Council, Nov. 3, 2016
Read About Our Process
In a world of wild talk and fake news, help us stand up for the facts.