Stand up for the facts!
Misinformation isn't going away just because it's a new year. Support trusted, factual information with a tax deductible contribution to PolitiFact.
I would like to contribute
Tim Kaine says Donald Trump has a fondness for dictators, including the late Libyan leader Col. Moammar Gadhafi.
During a speech in Wilmington, N.C., Kaine said Trump, the Republican presidential nominee, even was willing to host to the Libyan president, in 2009, two years before rebels killed Gadhafi during a NATO air campaign in that country.
"When Moammar Gadhafi was set to visit the United Nations, and no one would let him stay in New York, Trump allowed Gadhafi to set up an elaborate tent at his Westchester County (New York) estate," Kaine, the Democratic vice presidential nominee, said on Sept. 6.
Sarah Peck, the Virginia communications director for Democratic presidential nominee Hillary Clinton’s campaign, pointed us to a June 7 article in BuzzFeed News about the tent episode.
BuzzFeed examined Trump’s rental of his estate to Gadhafi during the Libyan leader’s September 2009 trip to New York City, where the dictator gave a rambling address to the U.N. General Assembly. BuzzFeed noted that when Gadhafi traveled, he often did so with a North African-style tent where he could stay overnight.
They also sought to put the tent in Englewood, N.J., just outside the city, but local officials there balked.
The tent instead was erected on Trump’s 213-acre Seven Springs estate in Bedford, a suburb north of New York City.
The Journal News, a local newspaper covering that town, reported in a Sept. 24, 2009, article that Gadhafi’s plans were to entertain guests at Trump’s estate.
The Libyan campsite there included the camel-patterned tent, a couch, chairs, a satellite dish and a fire pit.
Those living quarters were put up without any approval from Bedford officials, who were miffed at the possibility that the notorious dictator was going to visit their town.
Amid the controversy, the news media descended on the upscale neighborhood surrounding Trump’s estate to chronicle the tent flap.
Bedford officials ordered the tent taken down, saying it violated zoning laws. Trump, through a spokeswoman, said in a statement that he had asked the Libyans to take down the tent.
The Libyans complied but only for a while. They put it back up amid reports Gadhafi was planning to visit the estate.
Town officials, under police escort, went onto the property and ordered the tent struck yet again. The tent was taken down again and hauled away the next day.
Joel Sachs, Bedford’s town attorney, told us there’s no indication Gadhafi ever made it to the property. Local news reports said the Libyan leader never got to see the estate. Sachs told The Journal News in 2009 that officials at the estate said one of Gadhafi’s sons did venture to Seven Springs.
Gadhafi ended up staying at Libya’s U.N. mission in midtown Manhattan.
Sachs told us this week that Trump, in 2009, denied to town officials that he knew Gadhafi was the one renting space on his property, telling the town he thought it was being leased by some of his Middle Eastern business associates.
Sachs said he didn’t find the denial plausible and told us that officials at the estate indicated Trump was aware of Gadhafi’s plans to use the property.
The Associated Press has noted that in in the years after the episode, Trump acknowledged he rented the property to Gadhafi.
"If you remember, he came to the country, and he had to make a deal with me because he needed a place to stay. And he paid me a fortune, never got to stay there. And it became sort of a big joke," Trump said.
During an interview five years earlier on Fox News, Trump made similar comments.
"I rented him a piece of land … and then I didn’t let him use the land," Trump said, according to the transcript of the March 21, 2011, Fox interview.
"I don’t want to use the word ‘screw,’ but I screwed him. That’s what we should be doing. I rented him a piece of land in Bedford, New York. I rented him a piece of land. He paid me a fortune, and I didn’t let him use the land."
Trump also addressed the issue in a 2011 CNN interview.
"What did I do with Gadhafi? I leased him a piece of land for his tent," Trump said.
BuzzFeed reported in its article that a Libyan entourage had stayed at Trump’s estate for weeks before Gadhafi’s visit to New York, as did members of a public relations firm representing Libya.
Kaine said, "When Moammar Gadhafi was set to visit the United Nations, and no one would let him stay in New York, Trump allowed Gadhafi to set up an elaborate tent at his Westchester County (New York) estate."
There’s no doubt Gadhafi rented space at Trump’s estate to put up his tent. Trump acknowledges now that he leased land to Gadhafi, although he couches it as a boast to show he snookered the Libyan leader out of a lot of money.
We rate Kaine’s statement True.
Tim Kaine’s speech in Wilmington, NC, Sept. 6, 2016. (His comment is at just over 14:15 into the video).
Email from Sarah Peck, Hillary Clinton communications director in Virginia, Sept. 12, 2016.
Hillary Clinton campaign, "Senator Tim Kaine denounces Trump as dangerously unfit to be commander-in-chief," Sept. 6, 2016.
BuzzFeed, "The Donald and the dictator," June 7, 2016.
Associated Press, "Trump says he ‘made a lot of money’ in deal with Gadhafi," June 6, 2016.
Interview with Joel Sachs, Bedford town attorney, Sept. 13, 2016.
Politico, "Trump’s Qadhafi boast raises questions about charity claim," June 10, 2016.
CBS Face the Nation transcripts, June 5, 2016.
Fox News Network transcript of interview with Donald Trump, March 21, 2011.
CNN interview with Donald Trump, March 22, 2011.
CNN, "Trump’s big give," March 22, 2011.
CNN, "Trump: How I duped Gadhafi," March 22, 2011.
The Washington Post, "Tim Kaine: Trump is too ‘emotionally volatile, fact-challenged, self-obsessed’ to be commander in chief," Sept. 6, 2016.
The Journal News, "Gadhafi’s tent removed in Bedford," Sept. 23, 2009.
The Journal News, "Bedford halts work on Gadhafi’s tent," Sept. 23, 2009.
The Journal News, "Bedford issues stop work order on Gadhafi Trump tent," Sept. 22, 2009.
The Journal News, "Gadhafi sent packing from Bedford," Sept. 24, 2009.
The Journal News, "Bedford serves summons over Gadhafi’s tent," Sept. 24, 2009.
The Journal News, "Libyan Leader’s tent back in Bedford," Sept. 25, 2009.
The Journal News, "Gadhafi’s tent, like dictator, hits the road," Sept. 26, 2009.
New York Times, "Still no place in New York for Gadhafi’s tent," Sept. 23, 2009.
ABC News, "Trump: Mr. Gadhafi, tear down that tent," Sept. 23, 2009.
Read About Our Process
In a world of wild talk and fake news, help us stand up for the facts.