Stand up for the facts!
Misinformation isn't going away just because it's a new year. Support trusted, factual information with a tax deductible contribution to PolitiFact.
I would like to contribute
In his first tweet about this summer’s California wildfires, President Trump blamed environmental laws for making the blazes worse by preventing firefighters from using a "massive amount of readily available water."
He said it’s "being diverted into the Pacific Ocean."
The problem with that claim? The state’s firefighting agency said it’s had no complications accessing water, while fire experts said the state’s hot, dry and windy conditions are to blame for the infernos, not any water policy.
Here’s what Trump tweeted on Aug. 5, 2018:
With blazes continuing to ravage the state, we set out on a fact check. We focused on the first portion of the tweet about water policy.
Scott McLean, a spokesman for the California Department of Forestry and Fire Protection told us, it’s the hot and dry conditions taking place earlier in the year that are leading to the extreme fires.
"We have had no issues accessing water to fight the fires," McLean wrote in an email. "This year’s changing weather pattern is leading to more severe and destructive wildfires."
Keith Gilless is a UC Berkeley professor of forest economics and chairman of the California Board of Forestry and Fire Protection.
He said he believes Trump is conflating two very different issues. There’s long been a conflict between farmers and environmental groups over how much water should go to crops versus rivers and lakes. But that fight hasn’t had any effect on firefighting.
"I think there’s some real confusion in the tweet," Gilless said. "The issues over the allocation of water between environmental and agricultural interests have nothing to do with firefighting. And I’m not aware of any situation in which those conflicts have restricted the availability of water for firefighting purposes."
Heat, dry conditions blamed for fires
Gilless said the reason California’s wildfires are so destructive this year is the state’s "high heat, low relative humidity, high wind speeds and high fuel loading." He said climate change is making these conditions more frequent.
"California is going through a really heartbreaking fire season right now," he added. "Environmental laws about water have nothing to do with it from my perspective."
Gilless said Trump’s language about water "being diverted into the Pacific Ocean," doesn’t make sense, as water naturally flows to the ocean. The argument about how much water should be captured before it gets to the ocean, again, is part of a different, unrelated debate.
The second portion of Trump’s tweet, that California "Must also tree clear to stop fire spreading!", is also confusing. Forestry experts say thinning trees is a well-established practice that can reduce the severity of fires. But clearing trees is more commonly associated with commercial logging practices, not fire management.
Leroy Westerling, a UC Merced professor and wildfire specialist, told the San Francisco Chronicle that Trump’s tweet, "On the water side, it boggles the mind."
The White House did not immediately respond to a request for evidence to support Trump’s tweet.
A day before the tweet, the Trump administration approved California's request to declare a "major disaster" as the state continues to fight wildfires that have claimed at least nine lives. The declaration makes federal funds available to residents of Shasta County, where the Carr Fire outside Redding, California, has destroyed more than 1,000 homes.
President Trump claimed in a tweet that California’s wildfires are "made so much worse by the bad environmental laws" which prevent firefighters from accessing water. He added in the tweet that water "is being diverted into the Pacific Ocean."
Trump appears to have conflated the state’s real water controversy between farmers and environmentalists with the unrelated issue of firefighting. The state’s fire agency, CalFire, said it has not had problems accessing water. And fire experts said it’s the state’s hot and bone-dry conditions, not environmental laws, that are making blazes more extreme.
We rated Trump’s claim False.
FALSE – The statement is not accurate.
Click here for more on the six PolitiFact ratings and how we select facts to check.
President Trump, tweet, Aug. 5, 2018
Scott McLean, spokesman, California Department of Forestry and Fire Protection, email exchange Aug. 6, 2018
Daniel Berlant, assistant deputy director, California Department of Forestry and Fire Protection, email exchange Aug. 6, 2018
Keith Gilless, UC Berkeley professor of forestry economics, phone interview, Aug. 6, 2018
San Francisco Chronicle, Trump tweet blaming water diversion for fires baffles experts, Aug. 5, 2018
Marketwatch, Trump wrongly blames California’s worsening wildfires on water diversions, Aug. 6, 2018
Read About Our Process
In a world of wild talk and fake news, help us stand up for the facts.