Stand up for the facts!
Misinformation isn't going away just because it's a new year. Support trusted, factual information with a tax deductible contribution to PolitiFact.
I would like to contribute
An out-of-context clip of Joe Biden speaking in New Hampshire is deceptively edited in a way that suggests he made a racist comment.
"The culture, our culture, our culture is not imported from some African nation or some Asian nation, it is our English jurisprudential culture — our European culture," Biden said in the video, which was first published on Twitter on Jan. 1.
When heard in isolation, the video makes it sound like Biden is making a racist statement promoting America’s European roots and dismissing minorities. But when we listened to his full statement, that wasn’t the point of the quote at all.
The clip was posted by the Twitter user @mooncult and has been viewed more than 1.4 million times. The edited clip was one in a thread of similar videos posted by @mooncult, who has more than 12,000 followers and frequently posts anti-Biden content.
The 17-second clip comes from a 13-minute answer Biden gave to a woman who asked about his work on domestic assault and sexual violence. (Her question at the Dec. 30 campaign event starts around minute 39.)
Biden’s lengthy answer started with him explaining lessons from his father who told him that "the cardinal sin is a man raising his hand to a woman or a child."
Biden then pivoted to talk about the phrase "rule of thumb," which he said stemmed from a court ruling in England in the late 1300s that no man could beat a woman with a rod bigger than the circumference of his thumb. (There’s ample reason to doubt that the ruling is the origin of the phrase.)
Biden recounted his work while in the U.S. Senate holding hearings about violence against women.
As a U.S. senator from Delaware, Biden championed the Violence Against Women Act of 1994. The measure increased funding and provided more legal tools for combating violent crimes against women.
In his comments in New Hampshire, Biden said as vice president he also worked to try to persuade university presidents to take action to combat sexual violence.
About 11 minutes into his answer, Biden then said:
"Folks this is about changing the culture, our culture, our culture. It’s not imported from some African nation or some Asian nation. It’s our English jurisprudential culture, our European culture that says it’s alright."
Listened to in context, it appears that Biden was saying that the roots of violence against women are rooted in European culture and that the United States must change the culture of violence against women.
The edited video on Twitter omits Biden saying "this is about changing…" and just cuts right to
"The culture, our culture, our culture is not imported from some African nation or some Asian nation, it is our English jurisprudential culture — our European culture."
In March, Biden made a similar statement when speaking about his role in the Supreme Court confirmation hearings for Clarence Thomas and his treatment of Anita Hill. Speaking about a culture that allows violence against women, he said: "It’s an English jurisprudential culture, a white man’s culture. It’s got to change."
@mooncult’s bio says it is "an exclusive 'weird twitter' posting collective operated by an anonymous rotating cast of your favorite online personalities & podcast hosts." Weird Twitter is characterized by loose groups of users who experiment with spelling, punctuation and post format to create elaborate jokes or art.
The Biden video is the latest example of how selective editing can cause misinformation on social media.
RELATED FACT-CHECK: Viral video of Nancy Pelosi slowed down her speech
RELATED FACT-CHECK: Trump retweets false claim that Ilhan Omar partied on 9/11 anniversary
A video posted on Twitter purports to show Joe Biden making a racist comment about America’s European roots.
The clip selectively shortened something Biden said at a campaign event in New Hampshire. He was responding to a woman’s question about what he’s done to address domestic assault and sexual violence. In that response, Biden said, "this is about changing the culture, our culture." The tweeted clip does not include that context.
More importantly, the video clip watched in isolation makes it falsely appear that Biden was making a racist comment dismissing minorities. When watched in full, his comment related to what he said were the roots of domestic violence in America.
We rate this video clip False.
See a fishy video on social media that you want us to fact-check? Send it to [email protected].
Washington Post, A deceptively edited video of Joe Biden signals what’s coming, Jan. 2, 2020
Daniel Dale, Tweet, Jan. 1, 2020
GQ, Misleading Joe Biden Video Is the First Viral Controversy of 2020, Jan. 2, 2020
Tweet from @mooncult, Jan. 1, 2020
ABC News, Joe Biden in Derry, New Hampshire, Jan. 1, 2020
Know Your Meme, accessed Jan. 2, 2020
Associated Press, Video Edited to Suggest Biden Made Racist Remark, March 27, 2019
Associated Press, Biden criticizes ‘white man’s culture,’ role in Hill hearing, March 27, 2019
PolitiFact, "How much have domestic violence rates fallen since the Violence Against Women Act passed?" Feb. 22, 2019
The New York Times Magazine, "On Language; Misrule of Thumb," Jan. 25, 1998
Chronicle of Higher Education, In Letter to College Presidents, Biden Urges Continued Fight Against Sexual Assault, Jan. 5, 2017
New York Times, Betsy DeVos Reverses Obama-era Policy on Campus Sexual Assault Investigations, Sept. 22, 2019
PolitiFact, "Viral video of Nancy Pelosi slowed down her speech," May 24, 2019
PolitiFact, Trump retweets false claim that Ilhan Omar partied on 9/11 anniversary, Sept. 19. 2019
Read About Our Process
In a world of wild talk and fake news, help us stand up for the facts.