Stand up for facts and support PolitiFact.

Now is your chance to go on the record as supporting trusted, factual information by joining PolitiFact’s Truth Squad. Contributions or gifts to PolitiFact, which is part of the 501(c)(3) nonprofit Poynter Institute, are tax deductible.

More Info

I would like to contribute

Jill Terreri Ramos
By Jill Terreri Ramos June 20, 2020

GOP renews line against McMurray’s work, and it’s still wrong

If Your Time is short

  • Republican House candidate Chris Jacobs says his rival, Democrat Nate McMurray, helped send American jobs to Asia. 
  • McMurray worked as a lawyer in Asia, and was one of thousands of members of a business group that supported the U.S.-Korea trade agreement, which took effect in March 2012.
  • The U.S. goods trade deficit grew after the agreement, but McMurray's work in Asia was not related to offshoring U.S. jobs.  

 

 

Republican Chris Jacobs, running for Congress in New York’s 27th District, uses a familiar line of attack against his opponent, Democrat Nate McMurray.

The Jacobs ad, "Steals," says: "As a lawyer working in Korea, Nate McMurray helped send American jobs to Asia, supporting trade agreements costing us thousands of jobs. McMurray even helped American companies hire foreign workers." 

Just two years ago, when Rep. Chris Collins campaigned against McMurray, the Collins camp sent direct mail to voters with the claim "Nate McMurray lobbied to send our jobs to China. (And Korea, too.)"

Voters in all or part of eight counties in Western New York cast their ballots in a special election on June 23. We wanted to fact-check this persistent claim, specifically that "As a lawyer working in Korea, Nate McMurray helped send American jobs to Asia."

Jacobs’ argument 

McMurray worked in Asia as a corporate lawyer from 2006 to 2013, first in China, then in Korea. In Korea, he helped foreign companies invest there and resolve employment issues. 

We reached out to the Jacobs campaign about the ad, and received information regarding McMurray’s involvement with a chamber of commerce when he worked as a lawyer in Korea, as well as a list of news articles that detailed how companies moved operations to Asia, or established new operations there. 

The Jacobs campaign says that in 2011, McMurray was a vice chairman of the Foreign Investment Committee of The American Chamber of Commerce in Korea, which we verified through a document from the chamber. The chamber paid roughly $30,000 to lobby for the U.S.-Korea Free Trade Agreement, according to a 2011 U.S. Senate Lobbying Report, provided by Jacobs. 

In their memo on the ad, the GOP campaign also sent articles that stated that the U.S.-Korea trade deal from 2012, supported by the chamber, led to a more than doubling of the U.S. goods trade deficit, according to Reuters, and "more than 95,000 lost U.S. jobs," according to an analysis from the union-backed Economic Policy Institute in 2016. (The White House said in 2018 that the goods trade deficit grew by 75 percent under the 2012 agreement.) The biggest source of the trade deficit was related to car sales, according to Vox in 2018. 

The Jacobs memo also has links to articles about Western New York companies that moved their operations, though many of these moves happened before the trade deal took effect in March 2012, or the work went to countries other than South Korea. These examples included American Axle closing its Cheektowaga plant in 2011, and Ford laying off 150 workers at its Buffalo stamping plant, also in 2011. Also on the list was New Era’s shutdown of its Derby plant in 2019, and its move to manufacturing in China, Vietnam, Bangladesh and Haiti, as well as an operation in Miami. In another example from the memo, New Era opened an office in South Korea around 2013, leading to retail stores there.        

The Jacobs campaign’s argument is that because McMurray was a co-chair of a committee in the chamber, he had something to do with the chamber’s lobbying activities in favor of the U.S.-Korea trade agreement. 

But in 2011, the chamber had around 2,000 individual members and 1,000 member companies. In 2018, McMurray’s campaign told us that McMurray did not participate in lobbying activities. 

McMurray’s work

As a lawyer in Korea, McMurray helped American companies enter the Korean market, according to Thomas Pinansky, a former partner at Barun Law in Seoul. Pinansky recruited McMurray and spoke to PolitiFact in 2018.  

McMurray helped American companies succeed in the Korean market, historically a difficult market to penetrate, Pinansky said. "He would have no authority to export jobs, U.S. jobs overseas," he said. 

Two years ago, McMurray’s former campaign manager told us about McMurray’s work as a lawyer in Asia, and said: "In none of these positions did he have the authority to outsource any jobs." 

When PolitiFact fact-checked a claim that McMurray "lobbied to send our jobs" to China and Korea, we found it to be False.  

Our ruling 

Repeating a talking point from the Collins campaign, the Jacobs campaign took aim at McMurray for his previous job that it says helped send American jobs to Asia.

This claim is becoming an old chestnut on the campaign trail whenever McMurray is on the ballot.

We rated it False when the Collins campaign made it.

And nothing Jacobs says now is making it any more credible.

McMurray was one of thousands of members of a business association that supported the U.S.-Korea trade agreement, which took effect in March 2012. After the trade deal took effect, the trade deficit grew.

But nothing Jacobs provided showed that McMurray was responsible for American jobs moving to Asia, whether it was New Era moving their manufacturing offshore, but not to Korea, or New Era seeking to sell their products in retail stores in Korea, or American Axle closing its Cheektowaga plant months before U.S.-Korea trade deal even took effect.

It was False two years ago.

And it remains False now.

 

Our Sources

YouTube, Chris Jacobs 4 Congress, "Steals," June 17, 2020. Accessed June 18, 2020. 

Email interview, Cam Savage, spokesperson, Chris Jacobs campaign, June 18, 2020. 

PolitiFact, "Collins tries to use McMurray's work in Asia against him," Oct. 12, 2018. Accessed June 18, 2020.  

Vox, "Trump’s new trade deal with South Korea, explained," Sept. 25, 2018. Accessed June 18, 2020. 

Reuters, "Exclusive: Trump vows to fix or scrap South Korea trade deal, wants missile system payment," April 27, 2017. Accessed June 18, 2020. 

Economic Policy Institute, blog, "U.S.-Korea trade deal resulted in growing trade deficits and more than 95,000 lost U.S. jobs," May 5, 2016. Accessed June 18, 2020. 

The Buffalo News, "For Buffalo businesses in South Korea, it's calm in 'the center of the storm,'" May 16, 2017. Accessed June 18, 2020.  

The Buffalo News, "Citing Covid-19, Buffalo's New Era furloughs majority of workforce," Accessed June 18, 2020.

The Buffalo News, "Ford plans 150 layoffs at plant in Woodlawn; September move tied to a closure in Ontario," June 10, 2011. Accessed June 18, 2020. 

The Buffalo News, "American Axle closing last plant here; Eighty-six jobs will be eliminated with end of Cheektowaga operation early next year," Aug. 19, 2011. Accessed June 19, 2020. 

The Buffalo News, "New Era Cap reaches severance agreement with workers, will close plant at end of March," Feb. 12, 2019. Accessed June 19, 2020. 

The Wall Street Journal, "American Axle to Close Plant in Blow to UAW," Aug. 18, 2011. Accessed June 18, 2020. 

AMCHAM, press release, "AMCHAM Korea Hails Approval of KORUS FTA by the Korean National Assembly," Nov. 22, 2011. Via Wayback Machine. Accessed June 18, 2020. 

The White House, "Fact Sheet on U.S.-Korea Free Trade Agreement Outcomes," September 2018. Accessed June 19, 2020.

Browse the Truth-O-Meter

More by Jill Terreri Ramos

GOP renews line against McMurray’s work, and it’s still wrong

Support independent fact-checking.
Become a member!

In a world of wild talk and fake news, help us stand up for the facts.

Sign me up