Stand up for the facts!
Misinformation isn't going away just because it's a new year. Support trusted, factual information with a tax deductible contribution to PolitiFact.
I would like to contribute
On the day Turkish President Recep Tayyip Erdogan sought international support for his country’s battle against the Kurds and warned Kurdish fighters to withdraw from the Syrian border "this very night," President Donald Trump claimed the Kurds are actually in a safer position now.
Telling reporters that Erdogan would be meeting in Turkey the next day with Vice President Mike Pence and Secretary of State Mike Pompeo, as American officials continue to press Turkey for a ceasefire, Trump said:
"We have a lot of great people over there; we'll see. In the meantime, our soldiers are not in harm's way, as they shouldn't be as two countries fight over land that has nothing to do with us. And the Kurds are much safer right now. But the Kurds know how to fight."
After saying "they’re not angels," Trump added: "Syria is protecting the Kurds."
The White House and his campaign did not respond to our requests for information to support his claim.
But while it is true that the Kurds have forged a new alliance with Syria, that occurred only because the U.S. withdrawal from the region that Trump ordered opened the door to Turkey's attacks on the Kurds.
"This statement is totally disconnected from reality given the long-standing, deep and intensely abiding enmity between Turkey and the Kurds and the entire purpose of the Turkish military offensive, which is to forcibly clear the border of Kurds and Kurdish forces," Bruce Hoffman, senior fellow for counterterrorism and homeland security at the Council on Foreign Relations, told PolitiFact.
Here’s a timeline of recent events:
Oct. 5 — Turkey threatens incursion: Erdogan announces the completion of preparations for a military incursion into northeast Syria.
Oct. 6 — Trump announces withdrawal: Trump announces after a call with Erdogan that the United States would withdraw from the "immediate area" into which Turkish troops were expected to advance. The White House denies that Trump offered Turkey a "green light" to slaughter U.S.-backed Kurdish forces.
Oct. 7 — Kurds fear massacre: Kurdish leaders condemn Trump’s decision "to allow Turkish forces to invade Northeast Syria," saying: "The Turkish military has been occupying the predominantly-Kurdish city of Afrin, Syria, since early 2018. Their military and militias have committed grave atrocities and human rights abuses there. We do not want a repeat of the invasion and occupation of Afrin."
Oct. 10 — 150 Kurds killed: Turkey announces it has killed 150 Kurdish fighters.
Oct. 12 — Nearly 200,000 displaced: The Syrian Kurdish-led administration in northeastern Syria says that 191,069 people have been displaced as a result of Turkish military operations.
Oct. 13 — Kurds embrace Syria: The Kurdish fighters announce a new alliance with the government of Syria.
Oct. 16 — Kurds further threatened: Erdogan calls for Kurdish fighters battling his troops in northeastern Syria to lay down their weapons and withdraw from the border area "this very night." Erdogan also requests international support for his country’s battle against Kurdish fighters, whom he considers terrorists, and says Turkey would not stop fighting until it had established a planned "safe zone" in Syria roughly 20 miles deep.
Missouri State University Kurdish expert and history professor Djene Rhys Bajalan said the Kurds’ new agreement with Syria’s Assad regime, which is backed by Russia, limits the areas under attack by Turkish forces.
But the Syrian government "does not have a strong record on respecting Kurdish rights and the dire military position means they will have very little leverage in negotiations to maintain the autonomy of northeastern Syria," he said.
And "compared with the situation prior to the U.S. pullout, the Kurds certainly are not safer."
Will Todman, associate fellow in the Middle East program and the Center for Strategic and International Studies, offered a similar view.
"It is certainly true that the Kurds were in great danger after the U.S. withdrawal and before forming an agreement with the regime, which the Russians mediated. Now that Russia is acting as their security guarantor, their position is more secure and they are better able to repel the Turkish-led offensive," Todman said.
"But the Kurds are certainly not safer under the control of the Assad regime and Russia in comparison to when the United States had a presence. Regime forces are overstretched, there is significant local opposition to the return of regime forces which has led to unrest, and ISIS has already seized on the situation to conduct new attacks in the area."
Another Missouri State expert on Kurdish politics, political scientist David Romano, was more emphatic.
The Kurds "have not faced such an existential threat ever before," Romano told PolitiFact. "They remain at risk of ethnic cleansing and genocide by Turkey."
Trump said: "The Kurds are much safer right now."
In the days since Trump announced the U.S. withdrawal from the Syrian border with Turkey, Turkey has attacked the area, killing scores of Kurds and displacing thousands more. And the Turkish president, who views the Kurds as terrorists, has vowed not to heed calls for a ceasefire.
We rate Trump’s statement False.
C-SPAN, Donald Trump answering questions from reporters (19:20), Oct. 16, 2019
PolitiFact, "Fact-checking Donald Trump’s claims about Syria and US troop withdrawal," Oct. 8, 2019
New York Times, "Turkey Urges Kurdish Fighters to Lay Down Their Arms," Oct. 16, 2019
New York Times, "Trump Followed His Gut on Syria. Calamity Came Fast," Oct. 15, 2019
New York Times, "Abandoned by U.S. in Syria, Kurds Find New Ally in American Foe," Oct. 14, 2019
New York Times, "Trump’s Abrupt Shifts in Middle East Unnerve U.S. Allies," Oct. 14, 2019
Axios, "White House insists Trump didn't give Turkey a ‘green light’ in Syria," Oct. 7, 2019
Fox News, "Turkey’s military assault in Syria leaves more than 150 Kurdish fighters dead, officials say," Oct. 10, 2019
Center for Strategic and International Studies, "The Implications of a Turkish Intervention in Northeastern Syria," Oct. 7, 2019
Syrian Democratic Council, statement, Oct. 7, 2019
Reuters, "Syrian Kurdish-led authority: nearly 200,000 people displaced by attack," Oct. 12, 2019
Email, Bruce Hoffman, senior fellow for counterterrorism and homeland security at the Council on Foreign Relations, Oct. 16, 2019
Email, Michael O’Hanlon, a senior fellow in foreign policy at the Brookings Institution, Oct. 16, 2019
Email, Missouri State University Kurdish expert and history professor Djene Rhys Bajalan, Oct. 16, 2019
Email, Missouri State University Kurdish expert and political scientist David Romano, Oct. 16, 2019
Email, Will Todman, associate fellow in the Middle East program and the Center for Strategic and International Studies, Oct. 16, 2019
Read About Our Process
In a world of wild talk and fake news, help us stand up for the facts.