Democratic presidential candidate Joe Biden accused President Donald Trump of backtracking on expanding gun background checks after mass shootings in Parkland, Fla., and more recently in Texas and Ohio.
In a video released Aug. 21 about Trump’s "broken promises," the Biden campaign lines up clip after clip of Trump speaking about background checks following attacks, with broadcasters and news headlines showing his reversal.
The video ends with this statement: "Joe Biden has beaten the NRA twice and will do it again," a reference to a 1994 bill he moved in the Senate to ban assault weapons, which has since expired, and the Brady handgun background check bill in 1993.
Generally, Biden’s highlight reel is on point: Trump did speak in favor of stronger background checks immediately following those mass shootings, only to amend his position later.
It’s a challenge, though, to declare Trump’s outright position. His promises to strengthen checks are vague, lacking details about what "weaknesses" he wants strengthened. Then it seems he’s moved on from the idea, highlighting instead "very strong" requirements under current law and the mental health of shooters — only for him to mingle both positions in the same breath days later.
"I would say he has broken promises on background checks," said University of Central Florida sociologist Jay Corzine. "That said, it is not easy to tie him back to specifics about background check proposals."
Under federal law, firearms dealers must be licensed. Licensees are prohibited from knowingly transferring any firearm to certain groups of people, including felons and people who were involuntarily committed to mental institutions. However, background checks are not generally required for private sales under federal law. Many states and Washington, D.C. have laws that require some sort of check on private sales for at least some kinds of firearms.
After a shooter, a former student, killed 17 people at Marjory Stoneman Douglas High School, Trump repeatedly called for stronger background checks. But about two weeks after the shooting, his White House sounded far less supportive of any major change on background checks. Later he threatened to veto legislation with stronger background checks.
Here’s how it changed:
As he listened to students and teachers a week after the attack, Trump said, "We’re going to be very strong on background checks. We’re going to be doing very strong background checks."
On Twitter, he vowed to push for "comprehensive background checks with an emphasis on mental health."
But after Trump met with a leader from the National Rifle Association, the message from the White House softened.
Trump then focused his efforts on signing a large federal spending bill that revised the National Instant Criminal Background Check System. The legislation pushes federal agencies to upload records to the background check system. However, it did not include any expansion of background checks to close loopholes sought by advocates of tougher gun laws.
Early in 2019, with Democrats in charge of the U.S. House, Trump showed a lack of support for stronger background checks when he threatened to veto House bills passed that require federal background checks for all gun sales. (The measures stalled in the Republican-led Senate.)
Again, after mass shootings in El Paso and Dayton left 31 people dead, Trump expressed initial support for strengthening background checks. And again, a couple of weeks later, his talking points changed.
In the days after the shootings, Trump tweeted, "Republicans and Democrats must come together and get strong background checks … ."
Days later, Trump touted the existing background check system to prevent people with criminal histories from buying guns. He said, "People don’t realize we have very strong background checks right now."
President Donald Trump speaks at a campaign rally in Manchester, N.H., Aug. 15, 2019. (AP)
Hours after Biden’s video went live, Trump talked more about background checks, but not in a way that was entirely clear, muddling it a bit with immigration policy, too.
On Aug. 21, Trump told reporters, "I have an appetite for background checks. We are going to be doing background checks. We are working with Democrats. We are working with Republicans. We already have very strong background checks. But we are going to be filling in some of the loopholes, as we call them, at the border."
While Trump has left open the possibility of expanded background checks, we don’t know exactly what he means.
"Stronger" background checks could mean universal checks involving all transactions that include the exchange of a firearm. Or, it could mean adding mandatory checks only to transactions at gun shows.
"So far, it seems like the president claims he will support background checks and red flag laws in the immediate aftermath of mass shootings — when there is the most public outrage and most demands for action," said University of Alabama criminologist Adam Lankford. "But then he does not actually stick to those promises or push for any meaningful policy changes."
Joe Biden campaign video, Donald Trump's Broken Promises on Gun Safety Reform, Aug. 21, 2019
The Hill, Trump: I will veto Obama actions on guns, Jan. 2, 2019
New York Times, After Lobbying by Gun Rights Advocates, Trump Sounds a Familiar Retreat, Aug. 19, 2019
New York Daily News, White House walks back Trump's gun control comments hours after Oval Office meeting with NRA, March 2, 2018
ABC News, A timeline of Trump's record on gun control reform, Aug. 5, 2019
Politico, White House pushes Trump's commitment to gun rights after president meets top NRA lobbyist, March 2, 2018
Washington Post The Fix, Trump’s backtrack on gun control has begun, Feb. 26, 2018
President Donald Trump, Tweet, Aug. 5, 2019
President Donald Trump, Tweet, Feb. 22, 2018
White House, Remarks by President Trump and Vice President Pence at Listening Session with Students, Teachers, and Parents, Feb. 21, 2018
White House, Remarks by President Trump at 2018 White House Business Session with Governors, Feb. 26, 2018
Giffords Law Center, Universal Background Checks, Accessed Aug. 22, 2019
The Hill, Trump calls for 'intelligent background checks' in response to mass shootings, Aug. 9, 2019
ABC News, Trump says he has 'tremendous support' from GOP on 'meaningful' background checks, Aug. 9, 2019
NPR, Trump Shifts From Background Checks To Mental Illness Reform At N.H. Rally, Aug. 15, 2019
Washington Post, Sarah Huckabee Sanders clarifies: Trump said lots of stuff this week he may not mean, March 2, 2019
Washington Post The Fix, Trump’s gun meeting went off the rails quickly, Feb. 28, 2019
New York Times, Past Flip-Flops Cloud Trump’s Position on Background Checks, Aug. 9, 2019
New York Times, N.R.A. Gets Results on Gun Laws in One Phone Call With Trump, Aug. 20, 2019
USA Today, Trump reverses again on gun background checks, says he backs them and never told NRA otherwise, Aug. 21, 2019
Washington Post, Trump tells NRA chief that universal background checks are off the table, Aug. 20, 2019
Washington Post, It’s been 20 years since the Brady bill passed. Here are 11 ways gun politics have changed, Feb. 28, 2014
Atlantic, Trump’s Phone Calls With Wayne LaPierre Reveal NRA’s Influence, Aug. 20, 2019
Politico, Trump now says he has 'an appetite' for stronger gun background checks, Aug. 21, 2019
AP, AP FACT CHECK: Trump’s made-up claims on shootings, tariffs, Aug. 12, 2019
Washington Post, Trump denies that he told NRA chief universal background checks are off the table, Aug. 21, 2019
Washington Examiner, Trump revives 'an appetite for background checks' stance after talks with NRA head, Aug. 21, 2019
PolitiFact, Donald Trump says he's done more than other presidents to solve the gun problem. Has he? Aug. 8, 2019
PolitiFact, Donald Trump fully flip-flops, lately opposes ban on assault weapons, April 12, 2016
Email interview, Andrew Bates, Joe Biden campaign spokesman, Aug. 21, 2019
Email interview, Zachary Parkinson, Donald Trump campaign spokesman, Aug. 21, 2019
Email interview, University of Central Florida sociologist Jay Corzine, Aug. 21, 2019
Email interview, University of Alabama criminologist Adam Lankford, Aug. 22, 2019