Stand up for the facts!

Misinformation isn't going away just because it's a new year. Support trusted, factual information with a tax deductible contribution to PolitiFact.

More Info

I would like to contribute

A member of the Texas Military Department stands guard along the U.S.-Mexico border Tuesday, May 11, 2021, in Roma, Texas. A member of the Texas Military Department stands guard along the U.S.-Mexico border Tuesday, May 11, 2021, in Roma, Texas.

A member of the Texas Military Department stands guard along the U.S.-Mexico border Tuesday, May 11, 2021, in Roma, Texas.

Amy Sherman
By Amy Sherman July 2, 2021

If Your Time is short

  • Texas Gov. Greg Abbott and Arizona Gov. Doug Ducey, both Republicans, sent letters to governors asking them to send law enforcement personnel to the border. Governors of Florida, South Dakota, Iowa, Nebraska and Arkansas are among those who have responded.

  • The total costs for states are unclear. A wealthy GOP donor agreed to give South Dakota $1 million through his foundation to support the deployment.

  • Border enforcement is a federal responsibility, but states can play a role.

It started with a plea from the Republican governors of Texas and Arizona.

"We respectfully but urgently request that you send all available law enforcement resources to the border in defense of our sovereignty and territorial integrity," Gov. Greg Abbott of Texas and Gov. Doug Ducey of Arizona wrote June 10 in a letter to other governors.

Their Republican colleagues in multiple states, including Florida, South Dakota, Iowa, Nebraska, Arkansas and Idaho, heeded the call, announcing that they are sending state troopers or National Guard troops to the border. 

It’s unclear what these out-of-state forces will be empowered to do, and some states aren’t offering much detail. Based on what we’ve gathered, they will be limited to investigative work and backing up highway patrols 

Abbott and Ducey say that they were prompted to act because the Biden administration’s "failure to enforce federal immigration laws causes harms that spill over into every state," such as drug smuggling.

U.S. Customs and Border Protection says southwest land border encounters for fiscal year 2021, which includes the end of Trump’s term and Biden’s tenure so far, are up compared with the past few years. (Encounters data refers to events, not people, so a person making multiple attempts to cross the border would be counted more than once.)

Homeland Security Secretary Alejandro Mayorkas said in March that the U.S. is "on pace to encounter more individuals on the southwest border than we have in the last 20 years." 

National Guard personnel have been deployed to the border in the past under the orders of  presidents George W. Bush, Barack Obama and Donald Trump, but it is far more unusual for a governor to request personnel from faraway states to help at the border.

A CBP spokesperson said the federal agency will continue to leverage its longstanding relations with state and local law enforcement, but referred questions about Texas’ move to state officials. 

Tasks include help with drug interdiction investigations, vehicle maintenance

During the past few months, Abbott and Ducey have taken a series of steps in response to illegal immigration at the border. On May 31, Abbott declared a state of disaster and directed law enforcement to help prevent criminal activity. The state has deployed 1,000 state troopers and 500 National Guard members, according to the Migration Policy Institute

In June, Abbott announced that he would use $250 million in state funds and crowdsourced private funds to continue to build barriers along the border.

Arizona has also sent state troopers and National Guard forces to its own border with Mexico. 

Abbott and Ducey made their request to states through the Emergency Management Assistance Compact. The compact, which was ratified by Congress in 1996, is a partnership among all the states to provide mutual aid in times of emergencies, historically for disasters such as hurricanes or wildfires. The compact’s website did not list border enforcement as a past use by the states.

The states that responded are offering limited information about what tasks their forces will handle.

A spokesperson for the Florida Department of Law Enforcement, Gretl Plessinger, told us that assignments would vary daily based on needs but that agents and analysts are working investigations associated with human smuggling, drugs and weapon smuggling. Each Florida agent is paired with one from Texas.

Plessinger said that Texas has provided Florida officers with arrest powers through the compact but "we aren’t enforcing immigration laws."

Arkansas National Guard Members will be under operational control of the Texas National Guard and help with vehicle maintenance. Arkansas will cover personnel and travel costs for an estimated 20 to 30 people, while Texas will cover lodging.

"These are all verbal agreements at this point as we are early in the coordination and planning process," said Shealyn Sowers, a spokesperson for Arkansas Gov. Asa Hutchinson.

Idaho will send five state troopers on a 21-day mission starting July 6 to help Arizona State Police with intelligence gathering and investigative work related to drug interdiction at the border. The troopers will have the same authority given to Arizona state troopers. 

Federal government has tapped states to help in the past

There is precedent for states to help the federal government with border issues, but their authority is limited, said Michele Waslin, program coordinator for the Institute for Immigration Research at George Mason University.

"State police and National Guard cannot enforce immigration laws; they cannot deport people, but they can assist the federal government," Waslin said.

Jessica Bolter, an immigration expert at the Migration Policy Institute, said that in the past, state troopers have conducted surveillance and been tasked with making arrests to enforce anti-smuggling/trafficking laws. But arrests have more often taken place for more minor offenses, such as drunken driving and minor drug charges.

The four states that border Mexico — Arizona, California, New Mexico and Texas — have cooperated with the federal government in the past and devoted additional funding and resources to border enforcement. 

For example, in 2006, they all signed pacts with the federal government to allow National Guard personnel to help patrol the border area and support federal efforts as part of Operation Jump Start

In July 2014, then-Gov. Rick Perry ordered 1,000 Texas National Guard troops to the border in response to the influx of unaccompanied children. In 2010, Arizona’s then-Gov. Jan Brewer announced a border security plan that included National Guard reconnaissance, aerial patrolling and military exercises.

But the federal government has most of the authority to enforce immigration laws, and defines only a limited role for state and local police.

Federal law allows U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement to enter into agreements with state and local agencies and train officers to carry out civil immigration law enforcement functions. But state and local governments can participate only under federal supervision.

For criminal enforcement, Congress has authorized state and local police to arrest violators of two criminal immigration provisions: one barring smuggling and trafficking, and another targeting people who reenter the country illegally following removal, according to the Migration Policy Institute.

Still, state and local police powers are limited.

"First, they cannot stop individuals solely to inquire about their immigration status. There must be another primary reason to detain someone for violating a criminal statute. And the duration of detention cannot exceed what is necessary for criminal law enforcement purposes," the Migration Policy Institute wrote. "And second, state and local authorities can detain someone they suspect of illegally reentering the United States only until federal immigration agents arrive and take that person into custody."

Historically, the Texas Department of Public Safety personnel has worked well with the Border Patrol, said Gil Kerlikowske, commissioner of U.S. Customs and Border Protection from 2014 to 2017. 

"They make traffic stops and also coordinate air surveillance," Kerlikowske said. The role of the state public safety personnel and National Guard generally has been to observe and report or do administrative office work. That frees up Border Patrol agents, who are trained on how to interact with migrants, he said.

But Texas’ latest call on forces from faraway states is something different, he said.

"This is not only ‘political theater,’ it is actually dangerous for these officers," Kerlikowske told PolitiFact. "The border environment and the culture of the border communities is something these (out of state) officers are not familiar with."

Andrew Arthur, a fellow at the Center for Immigration Studies, which supports lower levels of immigration, disagreed with critics who dismiss the Abbott-Ducey effort as a photo opportunity for Republican governors.

He said officers from other states are not enforcing federal border laws in Texas, but are enforcing Texas state law at the border. That could include backing up Texas state troopers or highway patrol pulled off their duties to help with law enforcement along the border, he said.

"They are going to do real police work," said Arthur.

Who will cover the costs?

In most cases, it will be taxpayers from the states funding the resources and personnel.

Seth W. Christensen, a spokesperson for the Texas Division of Emergency Management, told PolitiFact that "resources sent from other states are being sent at their expense."

The law that established the compact among states provides for the requesting states to reimburse other states. Katie Strickland, a spokesperson for Gov. Ron DeSantis, said Florida plans to seek reimbursement from Texas, but its responding agencies "have sufficient resources to absorb the costs."

In Arkansas, Hutchinson’s spokesperson said the cost is about $575,000 for 30 guard members for a 90-day deployment. Idaho has opted to cover its own costs, estimated at $53,391.

In South Dakota, the governor’s spokesperson would not detail the cost of the operation, citing "security reasons." However, a wealthy Republican donor from Tennessee, Willis Johnson, offered $1 million to help cover the costs. Payment came through the nonprofit Willis and Reba Johnson’s Foundation and was received by the state Department of Public Safety.

The unusual private donation for a government function has raised some legal and ethical questions, while state officials have pointed to laws that they say allow such a donation.

Johnson, who regularly donates to Republicans running for Congress, made his fortune as the founder of Dallas-based Copart, a business that handles online auctions for used and damaged cars. He told PolitiFact that his nonprofit foundation provides money for Christian causes.

CORRECTION, July 6, 11:58 a.m.: A previous version of this article incorrectly attributed a statement about Florida’s plans to seek reimbursement from Texas. The article has been corrected.

RELATED: Central America and the root causes of migration to the US

RELATED: Bush lowballs border wall mileage

RELATED: Tillis doesn't tell full story about Biden 'amnesty' bill

Sign Up For Our Weekly Newsletter

Our Sources

Gov. Greg Abbott, Disaster declaration, Updated June 25, 2021

Letter from Governors Greg Abbott of Texas and Doug Ducey of Arizona, June 10, 2021

Idaho Gov. Brad Little, Idaho answers call to help secure the U.S.-Mexico border, June 17, 2021

Gov. Pete Ricketts, Gov. Ricketts Sends Nebraska State Patrol Troopers to Aid Texas in Border Crisis Management, June 19, 2021

Iowa Gov. Kim Reynolds, Gov. Reynolds to send Iowa Law Enforcement Officers to aid border security efforts, June 24, 2021

Florida Gov. Ron DeSantis, Governor Ron DeSantis Deploys State Law Enforcement to Secure Southern Border, June 25, 2021

South Dakota Gov. Kristi Noem, Governor Noem Deploys South Dakota National Guard to Texas for Border Security, June 29, 2021

Arkansas Gov. Asa Hutchinson, Governor Hutchinson Authorizes 90-Day Deployment Of Up To 40 National Guard Members to U.S. Southern Border, June 29, 2021

Idaho Gov. Brad Little, Gov. Little details his plan to help secure U.S.-Mexico border and protect Idahoans, July 1, 2021

Emergency Management Assistance Compact, Accessed July 1, 2021

Associated Press, GOP donor funds South Dakota National Guard troops in Texas, June 29, 2021

Associated Press, Texas governor: State, crowdsourcing will fund border wall, June 17, 2021

Migration Policy Institute, Texas Once Again Tests the Boundaries of State Authority in Immigration Enforcement, June 29, 2021

Arizona Republic, Ducey, Abbott ask other 48 governors to send law enforcement to help patrol US border, June 10, 2021

USA Today, Police help Border Patrol catch migrants, which is bad policy, experts say, May 3, 2021

Texas Tribune, Gov. Greg Abbott announces Texas is providing initial $250 million "down payment" for border wall, June 16, 2021

Valley News Today, "Reynolds deploys state patrol officers to U.S.-Mexico border," June 25, 2021

Sioux City Journal, "Critics call for transparency in Nebraska state troopers’ border deployment," June 23, 2021

Sioux City Journal, " Gov. Ricketts sending state troopers to southern border," June 21, 2021

Military.com, Democrats Raise Ethical Concerns Over GOP Donor's $1 Million Funding of Border Deployment, June 30, 2021

National Guard, Operation Jump Start, 2006

U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement, Delegation of Immigration Authority Section 287(g) Immigration and Nationality Act

U.S. Customs and Border Protection Southwest Land Border Encounters

Gov. Jan Brewer, Governor Brewer Announces Arizona Border Security Plan, April 22, 2010

TIME, Billionaire GOP Donor Bankrolls National Guard Border Deployment, June 29, 2021

New York Times, Noem’s Use of Private Money to Deploy Guard Troops Raises Questions, June 30, 2021

Forbes, Willis Johnson, July 2, 2021

ProPublica, WILLIS AND REBA JOHNSONS FOUNDATION

PolitiFact, Can President Donald Trump send the military to secure the border? April 4, 2018

U.S. Customs and Border Protection, Statement to PolitiFact, June 30, 2021

Email interview, Gil Kerlikowske, nonresident fellow at the Baker Institute Mexico Center, June 30, 2021

Telephone interview, Willis Johnson of the Willis and Reba Johnson’s Foundation, June 30, 2021

Email interview, Ian Fury, South Dakota Gov. Kristi Noem spokesperson, June 30, 2021

Email interview, Gretl Plessinger, Florida Department of Law Enforcement spokesperson, June 30, 2021

Email interview, Katie Strickland, Florida Gov. Ron DeSantis spokesperson, June 30, 2021

Email interview, Michele Waslin, program coordinator for the Institute for Immigration Research at George Mason University, June 30, 2021

Email interview, Jessica Bolter, associate policy analyst with the U.S. Immigration Policy Program at the Migration Policy Institute, June 30, 2021

Telephone interview, Andrew "Art" Arthur, resident fellow in Law and Policy for the Center for Immigration Studies, June 30, 2021

Email interview, Shealyn Sowers, Arkansas Gov. Asa Hutchinson spokesperson, June 30, 20201

Email interview, Marissa Morrison Hyer, Idaho Gov. Brad Little spokesperson, July 1, 2021

Email interview, Pat Garrett, Iowa Gov. Kim Reynolds spokesperson, July 1, 2021

Email interview,Seth W. Christensen, Texas Division of Emergency Management spokesperson, July 1, 2021

Browse the Truth-O-Meter

More by Amy Sherman

GOP governors answer Texas’ call to send forces to the border. But what is their role?