Stand up for facts and support PolitiFact.

Now is your chance to go on the record as supporting trusted, factual information by joining PolitiFact’s Truth Squad. Contributions or gifts to PolitiFact, which is part of the 501(c)(3) nonprofit Poynter Institute, are tax deductible.

More Info

I would like to contribute

By Robert Farley April 15, 2008

One comment does not a platform make

A letter from the conservative group Focus on the Family Action makes a multifaceted attack on Sen. Barack Obama in an attempt to portray him as someone who would be "the most left-wing president in our nation's history." The article, written for the organization's Web site and widely circulated via chain e-mail, tries to paint Obama as bad for families, accusing him of everything from trying to further "the homosexual agenda" to being soft on the war against terrorists.

Focus on the Family Action is the lobbying arm of Focus on the Family, an organization founded by evangelical Christian Dr. James Dobson.

One of the claims in the article, written by Tom Minnery, senior vice president of Focus on the Family Action, states: "Then there's his support for teaching schoolchildren — in 2nd grade, no less — about homosexual relationships."

This is a reference to a question that was asked in a Democratic debate in New Hampshire in September 2007. During the debate, Allison King of New England Cable News talked about a controversial fairy tale about a prince who marries another prince that was taught to a second-grade class in Massachusetts. The Dutch tale, called King and King, is about a prince whose mother pressures him to find a princess but who ends up falling in love with and marrying a princess' brother.

Two parents filed a lawsuit, saying they were upset that a book with homosexual themes was taught to their 7-year-olds without alerting them first. The lawsuit was dismissed.

King asked if the Democratic candidates would be comfortable having the story read to their children as part of their school curriculum.

The question was first put to Sen. John Edwards, who responded, "Yes, absolutely."

Edwards went on to say that he wants his children to understand the discrimination that gay and lesbian couples face.

Featured Fact-check

Asked how he felt about it, Obama responded, "You know, I feel very similar to John. You know, the fact is my 9-year-old and my 6-year-old I think are already aware that there are same-sex couples. My wife and I have talked about it. One of the things I want to communicate to my children is not to be afraid of people who are different, because there have been times in our history where I was considered different, or Bill Richardson was considered different.

"And one of the things I think the next president has to do is to stop fanning people's fears. If we spend all our time feeding the American people fear and conflict and division, then they become fearful and conflicted and divided.

"And if we feed them hope and we feed them reason and tolerance, then they will become tolerant and reasonable and hopeful."

Minnery said that means Obama supports teaching about homosexuality in elementary schools.

"That's obviously the agenda of that book," Minnery said. "If you assent to teaching that book, you assent to that agenda. It's the same thing. They didn't say, 'I'm no longer speaking as a Democratic candidate.' "

Obama's campaign did not respond to questions about the Focus on the Family Action statement. But there's nothing in Obama's stated education platform that speaks to any initiative to require or encourage teaching second-graders about homosexuality.

In fact, the question in the debate was whether the candidates would be comfortable if that book was taught to their child in school. Obama said he would be okay with it. Focus on the Family's statement is a stretch at best. We rate the statement Barely True.

 



Editor's note: This statement was rated Barely True when it was published. On July 27, 2011, we changed the name for the rating to Mostly False.

Our Sources

Focus on the Family Action, "March 2008 Action Update," by Tom Minnery, March 2008

Fox News, "Democratic Candidates Say They're OK With Second-Grade Teacher Reading Gay Prince Fairy Tale," by Catherine Donaldson-Evans, Sept. 27, 2007

MSNBC.com, New Hampshire Democratic Debate transcript, Sept. 26, 2007

Politico.com, "Romney hits Dems on gay issue," by Jonathan Martin, Sept. 27, 2007

BarackObama.com, Obama's education platform

CNSNews.com, "Candidates Split on Pro-Gay Book for 2nd Graders," by Pete Winn, Nov. 29, 2007

Catholic Online, "Court rules against Parents in Homosexual Indoctrination Case," by Matthew Cullinan Hoffman, Feb. 5, 2008

Interview with Tom Minnery of Focus on the Family Action, April 10, 2008

 

Browse the Truth-O-Meter

More by Robert Farley

One comment does not a platform make

Support independent fact-checking.
Become a member!

In a world of wild talk and fake news, help us stand up for the facts.

Sign me up