Stand up for the facts!
Misinformation isn't going away just because it's a new year. Support trusted, factual information with a tax deductible contribution to PolitiFact.
I would like to contribute
If Your Time is short
The Pentagon said it did not leave U.S. military service dogs behind in Afghanistan and that they were evacuated in mid-August.
But some Afghans, U.S. embassy employees and independent defense contractors were unable to bring their dogs with them as they evacuated.
Multiple groups involved in evacuating those dogs cited a series of setbacks, including chartered flights falling through, unrest at the airport and U.S. regulations.
An image of dog crates sitting in front of a battered helicopter spread quickly online during the U.S. withdrawal from Afghanistan, drawing the ire of fans of dogs and the U.S. military.
"Our helpless service dogs, caged and abandoned at the Kabul airport, left to starve to death," tweeted actor James Woods.
"Infuriating," said Sen. Rick Scott, R-Fla. "Biden stranded Americans. He stranded our allies. Now he’s stranded our loyal K-9 warriors."
"The Department of Defense has ordered ALL contract military working dogs to be left behind in #Afghanistan. These aren’t just service dogs left behind, they’re AMERICAN SOLDIERS!!" one Facebook post said.
More than 120,000 people were evacuated from Afghanistan between Aug. 14 and Aug. 30, the Biden administration said. But the tight deadline and deteriorating conditions at the airport resulted in some Americans and thousands of Afghan allies being left behind, including former U.S. interpreters and their families.
But the federal government says the dogs pictured do not work for the military. The Defense Department said its dogs were evacuated with their handlers in mid-August.
"The U.S. military did not leave any dogs in cages at Hamid Karzai International Airport, including the reported military working dogs," Pentagon spokesman John Kirby tweeted on Aug. 31. "Photos circulating online were animals under the care of the Kabul Small Animal Rescue, not dogs under our care."
The nonprofit Military Working Dog Team Support Association, which supports military dogs and their handlers, also disputed the claims: "We are 100% certain that there are zero U.S. military working dogs abandoned in Kabul. Zero. The U.S. military did not leave a single MWD behind."
While the image doesn't show U.S. military-owned dogs, some of these animals likely belonged to defense contractors and could be characterized as "contract working dogs."
SPCA International, which has been working with Kabul Small Animal Rescue to evacuate animals from Afghanistan, said that the dogs in this photo "are contract working dogs that are owned and trained by private companies and are contracted for work that can include military and other operations."
Some animal welfare groups like American Humane dismissed any distinction between the dogs' contract or military status. The organization called on Congress to start classifying contract dogs the same way it does military dogs.
Advocates say the dogs are safe, but where they go from here is uncertain. They said there are a lot of reasons that the dogs were unable to leave.
Here’s an overview of what we know about the dogs left in Kabul.
Kabul Small Animal Rescue, a group that has cared for animals injured or displaced during the war in Afghanistan, posted updates on social media about its efforts to evacuate animals at Kabul’s airport.
The animals in the photo were being flown out as part of "Operation Hercules," the group’s crowd-funded, non-military evacuation effort.
The organization posted on Twitter that the animals included "50+ service dogs" — which might have led to the social media confusion about their military status.
These dogs largely belonged to Afghans, U.S. embassy employees and independent defense contractors who were unable to bring their animals with them as they evacuated.
NPR reported on the rescue’s frantic effort to airlift more than 200 dogs and cats — as well as the organization’s staff and their families — before the Aug. 31 deadline for foreign troops to withdraw from Afghanistan. Charlotte Maxwell-Jones, the group’s American director and founder, told NPR for its Aug. 25 story that some evacuation flights didn’t allow animals.
Veteran Sheepdogs of America, a nonprofit that works with U.S. veterans, posted the now-viral image on Aug. 29 showing some of the 51 dogs in crates in front of a damaged military craft at Kabul’s airport.
Joshua Hosler, the organization’s president, said as recently as Sept. 1 on Twitter that the dogs are safe and efforts to get them out of Afghanistan continue.
Maxwell-Jones posted this update on her rescue group’s Facebook page on Aug. 31: "We are busy making plans, checking them twice, sorting out details, and keeping things quiet to maintain our own and the animals' security. We know it's not the most satisfying feed to follow, but please know that behind the scenes we are busting our tails to do everything we can to save our furry friends, and we deeply appreciate everyone's continued concern and support."
Multiple groups and individuals involved in Operation Hercules have cited a series of setbacks that include multiple chartered flights falling through, unrest at the airport, stringent U.S. safety regulations, and more. Some flights didn’t allow animals so they could prioritize evacuating people.
SPCA International said dogs under the care of Kabul Small Animal Rescue were unable to board military aircrafts, and numerous chartered flights were not granted access to the airport.
"We are heartbroken that the aircraft we secured to transport the rescued dogs of Kabul Small Animal Rescue out of Afghanistan were not ultimately allowed to take the animals and their caretakers safely out of the country," Lori Kalef, SPCA International’s director of programs, said in a news release. "Our team has been working around the clock and has exhausted every possible option and resource we could in our mission to rescue the dogs before the U.S. military withdrawal from Afghanistan. We’ll continue to do everything we can to evacuate Kabul Small Animal Rescue’s staff and animals from the country after August 31."
We reached out to SPCA International for more information but did not hear back.
Defense Department spokesman Eric Phahon told a USA Today reporter that the dogs in the photo could not be flown out on military flights "because of customs," and a chartered plane that was supposed to take the animals never arrived or contacted the agency. The Defense Department did not respond to PolitiFact’s questions, and the White House referred us to Kirby’s tweet.
The SPCA and other groups blamed a temporary ban on bringing dogs into the U.S. from 113 countries — including Afghanistan — deemed to be a high risk for rabies.
The Centers for Disease Control and Prevention said it could grant a permit to people wanting to bring a dog into the U.S. from a high-risk country, but permission needed to be requested at least six weeks before the dog’s U.S. arrival.
"Dogs that arrive from high-risk countries without advance written approval from CDC will be denied entry and returned to the country of departure at the importer’s expense," the agency said.
The SPCA said rescuers applied for an emergency exemption with the CDC to get the dogs out but were not successful.
In response, the CDC told PolitiFact that it will not issue permits for shelter or street dogs from Afghanistan, but it would consider applications for pets with "proper documentation in coordination with the Department of State."
Facebook post, Aug. 30, 2021
Facebook post, Aug. 31, 2021
James Woods tweet, Aug. 30, 2021
Rick Scott tweet, Aug. 31, 2021
WhiteHouse.gov, Press Briefing by Press Secretary Jen Psaki, Aug. 30, 2021
John Kirby tweet, Aug. 31, 2021
Military Working Dog Team Support Association Facebook post, Aug. 31, 2021
ABC News, Facebook video, Aug. 16, 2021
Matt Brown tweet, Aug. 31, 2021
Kabul Small Animal Rescue Facebook page, visited Aug. 31, 2021
Veteran Sheepdogs of America Twitter page, visited Aug. 31, 2021
American Humane, American Humane Condemns Death Sentence Delivered to Contract Working Dogs Left Behind in Kabul, Afghanistan, Aug. 30, 2021
SPCA International, Urgent update and action plan from Charlotte & Kabul Small Animal Rescue, Aug. 31, 2021
U.S. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, Notice of Temporary Suspension of Dogs Entering the United States from Countries Classified as High Risk for Dog Rabies, June 14, 2021
Email interview, Chris Meagher spokesperson for the White House, Aug. 31, 2021
Email interview, Veteran Sheepdogs of America, Aug. 31-Sept. 1, 2021
Email interview, Belsie Gonzalez spokesperson for the CDC, Sept. 1, 2021