Stand up for facts and support PolitiFact.
Now is your chance to go on the record as supporting trusted, factual information by joining PolitiFact’s Truth Squad. Contributions or gifts to PolitiFact, which is part of the 501(c)(3) nonprofit Poynter Institute, are tax deductible.
I would like to contribute
(Published Sept. 19, 2008)
A new Spanish-language TV ad from the Barack Obama campaign called "Dos Caras" (Two Faces) begins as most of the attack ads against John McCain do — with McCain pictured next to President Bush. The ad then cuts to a bewildering cameo from Rush Limbaugh.
In an ad targeted to Spanish-speaking Latino audiences in Florida, New Mexico, Colorado and Nevada, the voiceover begins (according to translations provided by the Obama campaign): "They want us to forget the insults we’ve put up with…the intolerance…they made us feel marginalized in this country we love so much."
The screen flashes a picture of conservative radio talk show host Limbaugh above two quotes:
"…stupid and unskilled Mexicans" Rush Limbaugh
"You shut your mouth or you get out!" Rush Limbaugh
After the Limbaugh references, the announcer continues: "John McCain and his Republican friends have two faces. One that says lies just to get our vote and another, even worse, that continues the policies of George Bush that put special interests ahead of working families. John McCain…more of the same old Republican tricks."
The whole thing raises the question, what are quotes from Limbaugh doing in an attack ad against McCain, especially one that highlights immigration?
Limbaugh is hardly a McCainiac and in particular has been highly critical of McCain’s views on immigration.
Limbaugh and other grass-roots conservatives derided McCain’s 2006 efforts to forge a compromise immigration plan in the Senate that combined border security and work-site enforcement to root out undocumented employees, with a guest worker program for most of the illegal immigrants in the country. Limbaugh called the plan "amnesty," as did some of McCain’s opponents during the Republican primary. We looked at the claim and ruled it True when McCain said his plan was not "amnesty." We based that on the fact that it would have required illegal immigrants to apply for a six-year conditional nonimmigrant visa. They then could apply for legal permanent residence — a green card — on the condition that they pay $1,000 in fines, pay all back taxes, pass a criminal background check, stay employed and demonstrate an effort to learn English and civics.
However, when asked about his support for that immigration plan during a Republican debate in California on Jan. 30, 2008, McCain backtracked some and said he would no longer favor that plan because public opinion favored enforcement over citizenship measures. Instead, he would focus first on securing the border.
In his radio show on Sept. 18, Limbaugh took some time to discuss the Obama campaign ad, and it sure didn’t sound like he’d forgotten McCain’s previous efforts.
"This is just absurd because Bush and McCain were both for amnesty!" Limbaugh said. "Bush and McCain were these illegals’ best friends, along with Ted Kennedy."
There’s another big problem with the Obama campaign ad; the Limbaugh quotes are lifted out of context.
Let’s take the two quotes in order.
First: "…stupid and unskilled Mexicans."
This is a quote from 1993, during the debate over NAFTA. Said Limbaugh: "A caller called here and was giving me grief for not wanting to do what it took to protect American jobs, and so I said to him, ‘If you are unskilled and uneducated, your job is going south. Skilled workers, educated people are going to do fine ‘cause those are the kinds of jobs NAFTA is going to create. If we are going to start rewarding no skills and stupid people, I’m serious, let the unskilled jobs that take absolutely no knowledge whatsoever to do — let stupid and unskilled Mexicans do that work.’"
As is clear here, Limbaugh was not calling Mexicans "stupid and unskilled."
The second quote: "You shut your mouth or you get out!"
This one comes from 2006, and as you’ll see, Limbaugh here is setting up for a punch line — that he is actually citing Mexican law.
"Everybody’s making immigration proposals these days, let me add mine to the mix. Call it the Limbaugh Laws.
"First, you emigrate to our country you have to speak the native language, you have to be a professional or an investor, no unskilled workers allowed. Also, there will be no special bilingual programs in the schools with the Limbaugh Laws, no special ballots for elections, no government business will be conducted in your language. Foreigners will not have the right to vote or hold political office.
"If you’re in our country, you cannot be a burden to taxpayers. You are not entitled to welfare or food stamps or other government goodies. You can come if you invest here an amount equal to 40,000 times the daily minimum wage. If not, stay home. But if you want to buy land, it will be restricted: no waterfront, for instance, and as a foreigner, you have to relinquish individual rights to the property.
"And another thing, you don’t have the right to protest. You’re allowed no demonstrations, no foreign flag waving, no political organizing, no bad-mouthing our president or his policies. You’re a foreigner. Shut your mouth or get out. If you come here illegally, you’re going to jail.
"Now, you think the Limbaugh Laws are harsh? Well, every one of the laws I just mentioned are actual laws of Mexico today. That’s how the Mexican government handles immigrants to their country. Yet Mexicans come here illegally and protest in our streets. How do you say, 'double standard' in Spanish? How about, ‘no mas’?"
In backup material for the ad, the Obama campaign cites a story in which McCain did not come out strongly against Minutemen. McCain said he did not agree with them, "but they are certainly exercising their legal rights as citizens." Hardly damning stuff.
The Obama campaign also noted that McCain and other Republican candidates declined an invitation last summer to address NALEO, the National Association of Latino Elected and Appointed Officials.
And they suggest that McCain has waffled in his support of something called the DREAM Act, Developmental Relief and Education for Alien Minors, a bill he co-sponsored that would allow people under age 16 who have been in the country for five years to remain and apply to be permanent residents. McCain told the editorial board of the Sun News in Myrtle Beach, S.C., last November that although he agreed with it, he would vote against any issue related to immigration reform until the borders are secured. The Obama campaign suggested McCain presented to a different face when speaking to Latinos at the National Council of La Raza Convention in July, but the full text of his answer does not back that up.
Anyway, these relatively minor points raised by the Obama campaign are overshadowed by the larger import of the TV ad, which attempts to link McCain to seemingly racially insensitive remarks by Rush Limbaugh. As ABC’s Jake Tapper so aptly notes in his Political Punch blog , "even if one is uninclined to see Limbaugh’s quotes as having been taken unfairly out of context, linking them to McCain makes as much sense as running a quote from Bill Maher and linking it to Obama."
We are inclined to think the Limbaugh quotes were lifted out of context, and we think that presenting them in an ad about McCain’s immigration policy — as if McCain somehow endorsed those comments — isn’t just wrong, it’s "pantalones en fuego" wrong.
PolitiFact, Backtracking on the path to citizenship
PolitiFact, And it's no free ride , on whether McCain's immigration plan was amnesty
ABC's Political Punch blog, From the Fact Check Desk: Obama's New Spanish Language TV Ad Es Erróneo , by Jake tapper, Sept. 17, 2008
New York Times, e ditorial, Immigration Deception , Sept. 18, 2008
Washington Post, FactChecker: McCain, Obama Mislead on Immigration , by Michael Dobbs
Washington Post, McCain Camp Decries Obama Spanish Ads , by Ed O'Keefe, Sept. 18, 2008
New York Times, Obama Attacks McCain in a Bid to Attract Hispanic Voters , By Larry Rohter, Sept. 18, 2008
Rush Limbaugh Web site, Transcript of Sept. 18, 2008 radio show
Kansas City Star, McCain: Minuteman Civil Defense Corps 'entitled to being engaged ', July 18, 2008
(Myrtle Beach, S.C.) Sun News, "McCain takes immigration stance," Nov. 2, 2007
Read About Our Process
In a world of wild talk and fake news, help us stand up for the facts.