Stand up for the facts!
Misinformation isn't going away just because it's a new year. Support trusted, factual information with a tax deductible contribution to PolitiFact.
I would like to contribute
When the progressive group Pink Slip Rick urged Florida voters to call Gov. Rick Scott, Floridians sounded off about layoffs of government workers, the state of public education and the governor's own wealth. But one caller was tuned in to another issue: public television.
On Aug. 17, 2011, MSNBC's Rachel Maddow played some of Floridians' robocalls that are posted on Pink Slip Rick's website, including a call from Chris S:
"I really can't believe that you cut PBS of all things. My kids sit around and watch PBS in the early morning. They learn so much from it. And to have the state cut funding for PBS is despicable."
Did the jobs governor give Cookie Monster the pink slip? (In a related Truth-O-Meter item we rate a claim made by Debra B., who said Scott spent taxpayer dollars to robocall Floridians.)
On May 26, 2011, Scott announced more than $600 million in budget vetoes including $4,799,110 for public radio and television. (That veto included money for WLRN, a public radio station affiliated with the Miami Herald, a PolitiFact Florida partner.)
The veto meant that the 13 public radio stations each lost about $62,000 and the 13 public TV stations each lost about $307,000 (the impact on the stations varied depending on their total budget). These public stations are generally funded by state and federal dollars as well as membership donations and corporate support.
One piece of public programming was spared Scott's budget ax. WFSU in Tallahassee has a contract for The Florida Channel, which covers the state legislative session and public hearings about redistricting. WFSU lost money along with the rest of the stations but production money for The Florida Channel was not cut, said Janyth Righter, executive director of Florida Public Broadcasting Service Inc.
After his vetoes, Scott launched robocalls to highlight the cuts. A progressive group, Pink Slip Rick, invited Floridians to robocall Scott back.
The Pink Slip Rick campaign is sponsored by Florida Watch Action, a progressive group. The executive director of Florida Watch Action is Susannah Randolph, wife of state Rep. Scott Randolph, D-Orlando, and former campaign manager to former U.S. Rep. Alan Grayson.
Impact of the cut
In Florida, public radio stations reach 1.3 million listeners weekly, covering local news and airing NPR programs such as Morning Edition, All Things Considered and Car Talk. The TV stations, which reach 11 million viewers weekly, also include local content such as town hall meetings and national PBS programs about news, history and culture. The TV stations also buy and air PBS programs that teach children about the alphabet, reading, vocabulary, math and science among other shows including Sesame Street, Clifford the Big Red Dog, It's a Big World and Curious George.
Florida's PBS stations also provide workshops for teachers with a focus on at-risk and low-income families and provide books to Florida's neediest children.
The impact of the veto isn't fully known yet, said Righter, executive director of the Florida Public Broadcasting Service, which represents all of the stations.
"People are going to be laid off and have been," she said. "Stations are still trying to come up with how to fund some of these things."
But Righter said she doesn't expect that the TV stations will drop children's programs such as Sesame Street.
"The way the programs are packaged, we really won't lose our kids programs unless something else happens that creates a big drop in revenue," she said. "We have a big commitment to that childrens block. We plan to continue that."
It's the face-to-face outreach with people in the school districts that may not continue, she said. The TV stations have educators who go into schools to provide workshops for teachers to show them how to use PBS programs to help children engage in reading. The cuts will also probably impact local program production, Righter said.
John Labonia, general manager at WLRN in Miami, said the veto won't affect children's programming at his station.
"Stations pay PBS for the rights to carry those programs. In our case we didn't use any of the state money to purchase programs," he said.
When Pink Slip Rick put out the call to robocall Gov. Scott, Chris S. was among the callers. He said to Scott: "I really can't believe that you cut PBS of all things. My kids sit around and watch PBS in the early morning. They learn so much from it. And to have the state cut funding for PBS is despicable."
The caller is right that Scott vetoed $4.8 million in state funding for public radio and TV, but the particular impact the caller cites -- cuts to children's programs -- are not expected. We rate this claim Mostly True.
Pink Slip Rick, Robocall Pink Slip Rick, Accessed Aug. 18, 2011
MSNBC, The Rachel Maddow Show, Aug. 17, 2011
Gov. Rick Scott, Budget vetoes, May 26, 2011
Florida Senate, Conference report on Senate Bill 2000, 2011 session
PolitiFact, "Pink Slip Rick group says Florida 'jobs governor' lost 331,247 jobs," April 12, 2011
St. Petersburg Times, "Gov. Rick Scott's veto of public TV and radio funds spares WFSU," June 6, 2011
St. Petersburg Times, "Robocalls from Gov. Rick Scott jangle some Floridians," June 29, 2011
St. Petersburg Times The Buzz blog, "Rick Scott's robo-calls backfiring," May 27, 2011
U.S. Library of Congress, H.R. 1076, Referred to a Senate committee March 17, 2011
Interview, John Labonia, WLRN general manager, Aug. 18, 2011
Interview, Janyth Righter, executive director of Florida Public Broadcasting Service Inc., Aug. 18, 2011
Read About Our Process
In a world of wild talk and fake news, help us stand up for the facts.