Stand up for the facts!
Misinformation isn't going away just because it's a new year. Support trusted, factual information with a tax deductible contribution to PolitiFact.
I would like to contribute
We’re gonna make this fact-check sing.
Or -- since this fact-check was inspired by a Spanish teacher played by singer Ricky Martin on the TV show Glee -- we will make it cantar.
Our fact-check is about how many people will be speaking Spanish as their first language in the year 2030. But before we hit play on our claim, we will catch you up with the show that follows a fictional Glee Club, named the New Directions, at a high school in Ohio.
The show is about a group of musically talented misfits who belt out songs in between typical teenage plot twists about dating, spats with their parents, applying to college and the ever-present quest for popularity. The worst is getting "slushied," which means having slushy drinks tossed in their faces by cool football players.
The cast of characters includes Artie, the bespectacled skinny guy in a wheelchair; Santana, the bad-ass Latina lesbian from the wrong side of town; Quinn, the blonde cheerleader/chastity club leader who gets pregnant; and many more. They are led by the Glee Club director/Spanish teacher William Schuester, who is on an annual quest to lead his club to victory at nationals.
The plot of the Feb. 7, 2012, episode: Schuester enrolls in a night Spanish class taught by Ricky Martin’s character, David Martinez. (Yep, Mr. Schuester is a Spanish teacher whose Spanish es muy muy malo.)
Martin tells his students that they need to learn Spanish to function in the U.S. in the future: "Do you know that the U.S. Census believes that by 2030 the majority of Americans will use Spanish as their first language?" (Here’s a clip of Martin singing "Sexy and I know It" and "La Isla Bonita" on the episode.) Schuester uses Spanish as the inspiration for his weekly assignment for the Glee Club: sing a song by a Spanish artist or that includes Spanish.
We decided to take a short intermission from politics to test Glee’s claim about whether the Census Bureau believes the majority of Americans will speak Spanish as their first language by 2030.
U.S. Census projects growth in Hispanic population
Glee’s claim surprised the folks at the U.S. Census Bureau.
"We don’t do projections of language spoken," on a regular official basis, said Robert Bernstein, a census spokesman. "That’s very strange someone would cite us."
Bernstein pointed us to projections about the Hispanic population released in 2008 based on data from 2000.
The census projected that by 2030 there will be about 85.9 million Hispanics out of about 373.5 million people in the U.S., representing about 23 percent of the population. That projection is compared to about 16 percent of the population (49.7 million people) in 2010. So it’s true that the Hispanic population in the U.S. is on track to grow.
But the census projections are about the number of Hispanics -- not how many people will speak Spanish as their first language at home.
Spanish spoken in U.S. in 2010
The American Community Survey, which is a part of the census program, provides estimates of population characteristics including language.
For 2010, the survey showed about 37 million of 289 million people over age 5 spoke Spanish -- or about 13 percent. It doesn’t ask respondents what their "first" language is, but asks what they speak at home and how well they speak English. And those Spanish speakers include Hispanics and non-Hispanics.
"We don’t know how frequently they speak one (language) or the other, or which one they use exclusively or first," said Tiffany Julian, an analyst with the Census Bureau.
The survey also showed that for 2010, of the 45.6 million Hispanics, about 11.2 million speak only English while 34.3 million speak Spanish (including those who don’t speak English and those who speak English of varying ability.) That means 75 percent of Hispanics speak Spanish.
So if we know in 2010 that 75 percent of Hispanics speak Spanish, we could apply that figure to the 85.9 million Hispanics projected for 2030. That would bring us to a projection of 64 million Hispanics speaking Spanish by 2030, and if we divided that into the overall projected population of 373.5 million, we find that Hispanic Spanish speakers would represent about one-sixth of the population.
But what we’ve spelled out here is not a projection by ACS or the Census and may not be accurate: it’s pure math without taking into account any changes in immigration or fertility over the next two decades. Plus, we’ve also left out non-Hispanics who could speak Spanish at home as their first language.
Paper on language projection
At this point, we were about ready to say hasta la vista.
But wait -- we found a couple of experts at the Census Bureau who took a stab at language projections and presented a paper at the Federal Forecasters Conference in April 2011. Their paper projects that somewhere between 13 and 15.3 percent of the age 5 and older population will speak Spanish by 2020 -- the last year cited in the paper.
The authors of the paper, census demographer Jennifer Ortman and survey statistician Hyon Shin, told us that even if they projected out to 2030, the percentage of Spanish speakers likely would have continued to grow slightly -- but nowhere close to a majority of Americans speaking Spanish as their first language.
"That is just blatantly wrong," the two agreed. "We don’t have anything that can support that."
While nationwide immigrants typically continue to speak their native language, their children and grandchildren tend to use mostly -- if not only -- English. That means as the Hispanic population in the U.S. continues to grow, in part due to the descendants of immigrants, those children will speak English.
Spanish is projected to remain the language spoken by a majority of what census researchers call "Language Other Than English" speakers.
But "English is expected to continue to be the only language spoken by a substantial majority of all U.S. residents 5 years and older," the paper by the census experts said.
Ricky Martin’s character said on Glee, "The U.S. Census believes that by 2030 the majority of Americans will use Spanish as their first language." The Census Bureau predicts that in 2030 about 23 percent of the U.S. population will be Hispanic -- but all of those Hispanics in the future won’t speak Spanish as their first language. Two census researchers projected that somewhere between 13 and 15.3 percent of people in the U.S. will speak Spanish in 2020 -- a far cry from the majority of Americans, and we don’t know how many of those will speak it as their first language. They said the numbers from 2030 would still be nowhere close to the 50-percent mark.
Ricky Martin may have looked good singing in his tight pants, but we’re going to light the show’s pants on fire anyway. Pants on Fire! And though they don’t say it like this in Spanish: Pantalones en Fuego!
Fox TV, Glee, Accessed Feb. 13, 2012
YouTube, Various Glee Songs, Accessed Feb. 13, 2012
Washington Post Celebritology blog, "Ricky Martin brings Latin flavor and sparkling teeth to ‘Glee,’" Feb. 8, 2012
PolitiFact, "Spanish language ad says Newt Gingrich said Spanish is the ‘language of the ghetto,’" Jan. 25, 2012
PolitiFact, "Did Romney flip on deporting illegal immigrants?", Feb. 72012
U.S. Census Bureau, Population Projections, Released in 2008
American Community Survey, Language spoken at home by ability to speak English for the population age 5 and over Hispanic or Latino, 2010
American Community Survey, Selected social characteristics in the United States, 2010
Paper by Hyon B. Shin and Jennifer Ortman who work for the U.S. Census Bureau, Language Projections 2010-2020, presented at the Federal Forecasters Conference April 21, 2011
Interview, Chris Alexander, FOX TV spokesman, Feb. 10, 2012
Interview, Robert Bernstein, spokesman for the U.S. Census, Feb. 10, 2012
Interview, Tiffany Julian, U.S. Census analyst, Feb. 10, 2012
Interview, Census demographer Jennifer Ortman, demographer for U.S. Census, Feb. 10, 2012
Interview, Hyon Shin, survey statistician for U.S. Census, Feb. 10, 2012
Interview, Steve Camarota, research director for The Center for Immigration Studies, Feb. 10, 2012
Interview, Shannon O’Neil, a fellow for Latin American Studies at the Council on Foreign Relations, Feb. 9, 2012
Interview, Charles Fennig, managing editor of Ethnologue, Feb. 10, 2012
Read About Our Process
In a world of wild talk and fake news, help us stand up for the facts.