Stand up for the facts!
Our only agenda is to publish the truth so you can be an informed participant in democracy.
We need your help.
I would like to contribute
During a town hall presidential debate in which audience members got to ask the questions, one woman asked Mitt Romney how he would differ from the last Republican to occupy the White House: George W. Bush.
"Since both you and President Bush are Republicans, I fear a return to the policies of those years should you win this election," said undecided voter Susan Katz. "What is the biggest difference between you and George W. Bush, and how do you differentiate yourself from George W. Bush?"
Romney detailed several ways he would depart from Bush’s policies, then President Barack Obama chimed in, saying Romney was actually further to the right than Bush.
"George Bush never suggested that we eliminate funding for Planned Parenthood, so there are differences between Gov. Romney and George Bush," Obama said, as one example.
Planned Parenthood provides low-cost reproductive health services but is also the nation’s leading provider of abortions. Romney and other Republicans have vowed to eliminate its federal funding, a move Obama opposes.
But where did the 43rd president stand on the subject? We decided to check it out.
Planned Parenthood and federal funding
The organization, founded in 1921, has received federal funds since 1970, when President Richard Nixon signed a law amending the Public Health Service Act. Title X of that law provides funding for family planning services, including contraception and family planning information.
Planned Parenthood now operates more than 800 clinics in all 50 states. The bulk of their work is women’s health care: cancer screenings, STD treatment, sex education, contraceptives, pregnancy care and breast exams. In many states, they also perform abortions -- more than 330,000 a year. The group receives millions in federal money every year, in the form of grants and reimbursements for the health services its provides. In 2009, its federal funding totalled $360 million. Planned Parenthood says abortions account for 3 percent of its services, which are prohibited from being paid for with public money. The group says it is careful to keep the money separate.
Still, it’s that 3 percent that makes it a target in the national abortion battle.
What Bush did
In one of his first acts as president, Bush reinstated what is known as the Mexico City policy, or (as abortion rights advocates called it) the global gag rule, in January 2001. The rule denies money to overseas family planning clinics (such as Planned Parenthood’s international arm) that provide abortion counseling in foreign countries.
At the end of Bush’s term, International Planned Parenthood Federation said that during those eight years, they lost more than $100 million for family planning and health programs. The consequence of losing those funds, the group said: 36 million unplanned pregnancies and 15 million induced abortions.
When Obama took office, he revoked the Mexico City policy.
What Bush didn’t do
As president, Bush called himself a "compassionate conservative" and spoke of supporting "a culture of life." He steered money to faith-based groups, and he signed a federal ban on late-term abortions in 2003. When he ran for re-election in 2004, Planned Parenthood endorsed Democrat John Kerry, the first time the group formally backed a presidential candidate.
That said, we searched media reports from Bush’s eight years in office and found no instances of the president pushing to eliminate funding for Planned Parenthood’s work in the United States. We contacted Planned Parenthood itself, which also couldn’t cite evidence of Bush targeting their federal money.
On the contrary, we found ample evidence that Bush was satisfied with the status quo. In 1999, when he was first running for president, he declined to sign a pledge to defund Planned Parenthood, saying he supported "incremental changes helpful to America's pro-life movement."
The Obama campaign also pointed us to information on Title X funding (which pays for the health services Planned Parenthood provides) during the Bush years.
His 2002 budget proposal eliminated contraceptive coverage for federal employees but maintained funding for Title X, including $66 million for Planned Parenthood. A budget bill he signed in 2007 provided "the largest increase in Title X family planning funding since 2000, a $16.8 million increase from the previous year," according to a Planned Parenthood press release.
Eliminating funding for Planned Parenthood has gotten more attention since a Republican majority, backed by the new tea party wave of conservatism, took control of the House of Representatives in 2011.
"This is when we're going to defund Planned Parenthood. Now is the season for us to do this," Rep. Cliff Stearns, R-Fla., said in February 2011. (Stearns later lost his primary battle to a more ardent tea party candidate.)
The House voted in February 2011 to block Planned Parenthood funding, and all money for family planning. (The Democrat-controlled Senate rejected the package.) The message also caught on in the Republican presidential primary contest. Newt Gingrich, at the Iowa Faith and Freedom Coalition dinner that same month, said, "I would immediately move to defund Planned Parenthood and take that money and devote it to adoption services to create an alternative to abortion."
Romney, for his part, has repeatedly pledged to revoke Planned Parenthood’s funding. His website says he would "eliminate Title X Family Planning Funding — Savings: $300 Million. Title X subsidizes family planning programs that benefit abortion groups like Planned Parenthood."
And after he told the Des Moines Register on Oct. 9, 2012, that there’s no abortion legislation on his agenda, he was forced to re-state his anti-abortion stance: "The actions I’ll take immediately is to remove funding for Planned Parenthood. It will not be part of my budget. And also I’ve indicated that I will reverse the Mexico City position of the president."
With the spotlight on the organization, Planned Parenthood President Cecile Richards told the Washington Post in August, "I’ve never seen anything like this. I’ve never seen a presidential election where women’s basic access to birth control is practically on the ballot. Defunding Planned Parenthood is practically on the ballot. It’s been incredible to witness the last year and a half and this debate we’ve had over access to care. ... This is not something that John McCain was campaigning to do. George Bush wasn’t either. I’ve never seen anything quite like it."
Obama said in the debate that, "George Bush never suggested that we eliminate funding for Planned Parenthood."
In fact, one of Bush’s first acts as president was to cut off funding for Planned Parenthood and other groups working overseas that counsel women about abortion. But as for eliminating Title X funding for health services that Planned Parenthood provides in the United States -- which is what Romney and other Republicans of today favor -- Obama is right. We found no evidence that Bush sought such a change, and Title X funding actually increased during his presidency.
We rate Obama’s statement Mostly True.
Editor's note: This report has been changed to note that abortion rights advocates refer to the Mexico City policy as "the global gag rule." Anti-abortion advocates oppose referring to the policy by that term.
CQ Transcriptswire, "President Barack Obama And Former Gov. Mitt Romney Participate in a Candidates Debate, Hofstra University, Hempstead, New York," Oct. 16, 2012
Planned Parenthood By the Numbers fact sheet, accessed Oct. 17, 2012
USA Today, "Bush ends overseas abortion funding President revives ban on family-planning organizations abroad," Jan. 23, 2001, via Nexis
Huffington Post, "The President of the United States Will Decide Women's Choice Globally," Oct. 16, 2012
Interview with Justine Sessions, Planned Parenthood Federation, Oct. 17, 2012
NPR, "Planned Parenthood: A Thorn In Abortion Foes' Sides," April 13, 2011
Chicago Tribune, "GOP targets funding for Planned Parenthood," Feb. 11, 2011, via Nexis
Republican Presidential Candidates Deliver Remarks at Iowa Faith & Freedom Dinner, Feb. 22, 2011, transcript via Nexis
MittRomney.com, "Spending," accessed Oct. 18, 2012
Washington Post, "Romney again promises to defund Planned Parenthood," Oct. 10. 2012
Email interview with Kara Carscaden, Obama campaign, Oct. 17, 2012
Email and phone interview with Robert Terra, Romney campaign, Oct. 17, 2012
Planned Parenthood press release, "Planned Parenthood Scores Victories in Signed Budget Bill," Dec. 27, 2007
Washington Post, "Cecile Richards: ‘I’ve never seen a presidential election where women’s access to birth control is practically on the ballot,’" Aug. 25, 2012
Email interview with Douglas Johnson of the National Right to Life Committee, Oct. 22, 2012
Prolife profiles website, George W. Bush page, accessed Oct. 17, 2012
Read About Our Process
In a world of wild talk and fake news, help us stand up for the facts.