Stand up for the facts!
Our only agenda is to publish the truth so you can be an informed participant in democracy.
We need your help.
I would like to contribute
U.S. Rep. Eric Cantor, R-7th, has launched a TV ad accusing his primary election opponent, Randolph-Macon College professor Dave Brat, of being a closet liberal.
"Brat worked on Democrat Gov. Tim Kaine’s Council of Economic Advisers while Kaine tried to raise our taxes by over $1 billion," the announcer says.
Brat complained to us that the ad perpetuates "a lie" that "I am behind the large tax increases of Kaine." So we decided to examine the facts in Cantor’s ad statement and it’s implication that Brat counseled Kaine, who was governor from 2006 to 2010, on tax policies.
Cantor’s campaign provides backup for the ad on the website http://wecheckthefacts.com/.
The site says, "Professor Brat proudly accepted an appointment by Gov. Tim Kaine to serve on his Board of Economists." It links to a state Senate resolution confirming Kaine’s 2006 appointment of Brat and 11 others to the panel.
The group, now known as the Joint Advisory Board of Economists, or JABE, helps the state’s Finance Department refine predictions for the state’s economy as part of the governor’s annual budget proposal process. Board members do not receive compensation.
Finance Secretary Ric Brown -- who has served in his post under governors from both parties, including Kaine -- said the board weighs in on a national economic forecast prepared by Global Insight and a Virginia forecast offered by the state Department of Taxation. The panel seeks consensus of variables such as anticipated unemployment, wages and inflation.
The board members "respond to forecasts in terms of their areas of expertise," Brown told us. "They do not do revenue, but they do the economic underpinnings."
After a consensus is reached on the direction of the state economy for the next year, the Taxation Department prepares two or three projections for Virginia revenues. Those estimates are reviewed by another board, the Governor’s Advisory Council on Revenue Estimates. This group -- consisting of the governor, senior legislators and chief executives from major companies in Virginia -- reaches a consensus for the revenues projections that the governor folds into his proposed budget.
Brown described JABE, the board Brat served on, as "part of an overall process that does feed into the revenue process and policy changes." But he said the board does not make tax recommendations.
Brat and the 11 other JABE members appointed by Kaine all had doctoral degrees in economics. Ten of the 12 were appointed to council by several governors and served multiple terms. Eight of them, including Brat, were appointed by both Democratic and Republican governors.
Brat was first named to panel by Kaine and reappointed by Gov. Bob McDonnell, a Republican. Two of economists, Christine Chmura of Richmond and Roy Pearson of Williamsburg, have served under six governors. Another, Roy Webb of Richmond, has served under five governors.
Gov. Terry McAuliffe, who took office in January, has not yet made appointments to the council.
Now, let’s address Kaine’s tax-increase record. Cantor’s website linked to several articles from the Richmond Times-Dispatch and PolitiFact Virginia. In 2011, we found that Kaine had unsuccessfully proposed about $4 billion in tax hikes during his administration. He twice sought increases of about $1 billion in transportation taxes. He also proposed a $1.9 billion increase in income taxes, offset by a $650 million cut in local car taxes.
Ray Allen Jr., a political adviser to Cantor, emailed us that the ad contains two "facts which are not in dispute," referring to Brat’s service on the advisory panel and Kaine’s efforts to raise taxes.
"There is no public record of the professor ever disagreeing with Gov. Kaine on taxes," Allen wrote.
Cantor’s TV ad says, "Brat worked on Democrat Gov. Tim Kaine’s Council of Economic Advisors while Kaine tried to raise our taxes by over $1 billion."
Brat clearly served on the panel and Kaine clearly sought tax hikes. The ad does not explicitly say these two events are connected, but mentioning them in the same sentence creates an unfair impression that Brat was part of a group that advised Kaine to raise taxes. There’s no evidence that occurred.
The panel, as pointed out by the state’s long-serving secretary of finance, weighed in on the direction of the state’s economy. It did not advise the governor on revenue and tax policies.
Cantor’s statement is accurate but needs clarification. We rate it Mostly True.
NBC12, "NBC12 Decision Virginia- Cantor ad attacks Brat," Video of ad, April 23, 2014.
Cantor for Congress, www.wecheckthefacts.com, accessed April 23, 2014.
NBC12 Decision Virginia, "Cantor launches hit against primary opponent Brat," April 23, 2014.
Email from Ray Allen, Cantor adviser, April 23, 2014.
Legislative Information System, "Senate Joint Resolution 455," Jan. 24, 2007.
Interview with Ric Brown, Finance Secretary, April 23, 2014.
Richmond Times-Dispatch, "State Budget: Santa and Grinch," Dec. 19, 2009.
Richmond Times-Dispatch, "Kaine proposes 1% rise in state income tax," Dec. 19, 2009.
PolitiFact Virginia, "George Allen says Tim Kaine proposed $6 billion in tax increases while governor," April 16, 2011.
Finance Department, Documents, Joint Money Committees Report, Dec. 2006.
Finance Department, Documents, Joint Money Committees Report, Dec. 2007.
Finance Department, Documents, Joint Money Committees Report, Dec. 2008.
Finance Department, Documents, Joint Money Committees Report, Dec. 2009.
Report of the Secretary of the Commonwealth, 2007-08, 2003-04, 1999-00, 1995-96, 1991-92, 1987-88, 1983-84.
Interview with Dave Brat, chairman of the Economics and Business Department at Randolph-Macon College, April 24, 2014.
Read About Our Process
In a world of wild talk and fake news, help us stand up for the facts.