Stand up for the facts!
Misinformation isn't going away just because it's a new year. Support trusted, factual information with a tax deductible contribution to PolitiFact.
I would like to contribute
News that House Majority Whip Steve Scalise, R-La., allegedly gave a speech to a white supremacist group a dozen years ago is pulling attention away from the game plan Republicans had in mind as they take charge of Congress.
While Scalise says he didn’t know the group’s ideology when he spoke about tax policy in 2002, some are calling on him to step down from his leadership post or resign altogether.
Newt Gingrich, on the other hand, said the entire matter has been blown out of proportion. Speaking on CBS' Face the Nation Jan. 4, 2015, Gingrich compared Scalise's situation to what happened in 2008 when then-presidential candidate Barack Obama was confronted with his association with Rev. Jeremiah Wright.
"The fact is, you have a president who for years went to a church whose pastor said stunningly hateful things about Americans," Gingrich said. "The president explains he didn't hear any of them. Okay? And we all gave him a pass. He gave a great speech in Philadelphia as a candidate. We said, okay, we got it."
Gingrich went on to paint a picture of a "one-sided view of reality" where the left and its supporters ignore mistakes made by its allies but pounce on conservatives for similar trangressions. As for Scalise, Gingrich said, "To the best of our knowledge, (he) gave a speech on taxes 12 years ago. Now, for a 12-year-old speech to be blown up into a national story, I think, is frankly one more example of a one-sided view of reality."
We wondered about Gingrich's description that Obama got "a pass" in the context that Scalise's problems have "blown up into a national story."
We reached out to Gingrich through his production company to learn more and didn’t hear back.
A Wright recap
Obama credited Wright with introducing him to his Christian faith. Wright officiated Obama’s wedding to Michelle and baptized both of their children. The couple attended Trinity United Church of Christ where Wright preached.
On March 8, 2008, ABC News aired a report that included excerpts of Wright’s sermons against racism. In the most controversial video, which was played on network and cable news, Wright exhorted blacks to reject the government that had treated them so badly.
The government "wants us to sing ‘God Bless America.’ No, no, no, not ‘God Bless America.’ God damn America — that's in the Bible — for killing innocent people," Wright said. "God damn America, for treating our citizens as less than human. God damn America, as long as she tries to act like she is God, and she is supreme. The United States government has failed the vast majority of her citizens of African descent."
Following the news reports, Obama called Wright’s views "completely unacceptable and inexcusable." Wright resigned from a committee of African-American clergy who supported Obama. The candidate continued to distance himself from Wright, but the story grew and on March 18, Obama delivered an extended speech on race in America at Independence Hall in Philadelphia (the speech referenced by Gingrich in his comments).
The level of news coverage
We used the Nexis news database to search for newspaper articles that mentioned Wright. In the week before the ABC News broadcast, Wright’s name appeared 15 times, most of them focused on whether his political work endangered his church’s tax status, or on his ties to Louis Farrakhan, the head of the Nation of Islam.
After the ABC News story, the number skyrocketed, more than doubling every two days. By the time Obama spoke in Philadelphia, there had been over 250 stories and editorials in U.S. publications. On top of that, the topic was on every network and cable news channel. By the end of that month, the number of articles topped 2,000.
This chart, which measures two-day periods in March 2008, shows how the story grew.
According to polling by the Pew Research Center, Obama’s relationship with Wright dominated the news. Less than a week after the ABC News broadcast, Pew found that two-thirds of Americans said that they had heard at least a little about Wright’s inflammatory comments.
In a follow-up survey after Obama’s speech on race, about half of the public said they had seen video of Wright’s sermons, and about half said they had watched Obama’s speech itself.
It was far and away the most visible event of all the campaign coverage, with 85 percent of the public saying they had heard at least a little about it.
Pew’s Project on Excellence in Journalism wrote at the time, "The high-risk Philadelphia speech came after several days of what one network correspondent described as Obama ‘damage control’ to try and counter political fallout from the Wright sermons."
While the speech earned Obama much praise, the headlines a few days later show that it was hardly universally well received.
The Buffalo News had "Wright's hate speech spurs serious questions."
In Florida, the Naples Daily News wrote, "Obama's disavowal of minister's anti-America rant unbelievable."
The Charleston Daily Mail said, "Obama's denials just don't ring true."
Gingrich claimed Obama got a pass on his association with the controversial Wright, while saying a 12-year-old speech by Scalise has blown up into a national story.
You can argue that the Wright controversy didn't sway the majority of people's opinions about Obama -- he won election in 2008 and 2012 -- but it's wrong to claim the Wright story wasn't covered the way Scalise's troubles have made national news.
In the days after ABC News first reported the Wright-Obama connection in 2008, the story littered print and TV media. Meanwhile, a poll found that 85 percent of Americans had at least some knowledge of the matter.
We rate Gingrich's claim False.
CBC News, Face the Nation, Jan. 4, 2015
ABC News, Obama's Pastor: God Damn America, U.S. to Blame for 9/11, March 13, 2008
WikiSource, Full text: Obama race speech, March 18, 2008
Seattle Times, Obama decries pastor's remarks, March 15, 2008
Pew Research Center, Public Closely Tracking Details of Campaign, March 13, 2008
Pew Research Center, Most Aware of Ferraro’s Comments, Wright Videos, March 20, 2008
Pew Research Center, Obama and Wright Controversy Dominate News Cycle, March 27, 2008
Pew Project for Excellence in Journalism, The Pastor, The Candidate, And The Speech Lead The News, March 24, 2008
Albuquerque Journal, Questions Linger After 'The Speech', March 24, 2008, via Nexis
Buffalo News, Wright's hate speech spurs serious questions, March 24, 2008, via Nexis
Charleston Daily Mail, Obama's denials just don't ring true; Someone knew that Wright's views would spell trouble, March 20, 2008, via Nexis
Naples Daily News, Obama's disavowal of minister's anti-America rant unbelievable, March 19, 2008, via Nexis
Tennessean, Obama's ex-pastor elicits debate, March 19, 2008, via Nexis
Read About Our Process
In a world of wild talk and fake news, help us stand up for the facts.