When Gov. Rick Scott walked into a Starbucks in downtown Gainesville, he got an earful from a woman who attacked his positions on health care.
A video of the woman yelling at Scott for about a minute drew more than 259,000 hits on YouTube in about 24 hours and was shown on national television the next day.
"You cut Medicaid so I couldn’t get Obamacare," yelled the woman, Cara Jennings, a former Lake Worth city commissioner who is now a stay-at-home mother. "You are an a------! You don’t care about working people. ... You should be ashamed to show your face around here."
Scott countered by saying, "We’ve got a million jobs."
"A million jobs? Great. Who here has a great job or is looking forward to finishing school? Do you really feel like you have a job coming up?" Jennings said. "You stripped women of access to public health care. Shame on you, Rick Scott! We depend on those services."
In this fact-check we will explain whether Scott "stripped women of access to public health care." Jennings is referencing a law Scott signed in March that pertains to clinics that provide abortions. (Here is our fact-check about her comments on Medicaid, an issue on which we gave Scott a Full Flop for changing his position on Medicaid expansion in 2015. We also checked Scott's claim about 1 million jobs.)
Scott’s action related to public health care
The Palm Beach Post in 2010 described Jennings, then a city commissioner, as an advocate for the poor, illegal immigrants and homeless.
Here's what Jennings had to say on Facebook: "I am upset about the awful bill Governor Scott signed last week - cuts funding to Planned Parenthood and restricts abortion access. Just last night I looked online to see if there is a march planned to defend our rights to abortion. And then today, the Governor walked into the coffee shop I was at.....and left with no coffee. (video credit to the stranger who recorded the scene)."
On March 25, Scott signed a bill that removes state funding from any clinic that does abortions. HB 1411 passed the House 76-40 and the Senate 25-15, and it takes effect July 1.
A key provision in the law is that it prohibits public funding for an organization that owns, operates or is affiliated with a licensed abortion clinic. The law includes several requirements for abortion clinics, including annual licensure inspections, and prohibits selling or transferring fetal remains. In 2014, there were 72,073 abortions performed in Florida.
Federal funding is already banned for abortions due to the federal Hyde Amendment, which includes limited exceptions. Florida’s Medicaid program will cover an abortion if needed to save the life of the mother or if she got pregnant as a result of rape or incest. Those exceptions continue under the new law.
Planned Parenthood serves about 5,500 Florida patients through Title X, a family-planning program that it provides through a state contract, and about another 2,000 more people through Medicaid in Florida.
The state Department of Health spent about $139,000 for the Title X services provided by Planned Parenthood in 2014-15 and expected to spend about $163,000 in 2015-16. The Florida Medicaid program paid about $106,000 in claims to Planned Parenthood in 2014-15, according to staff analysis of the bill.
Planned Parenthood offers many types of services beyond abortion, including birth control, STD testing and cervical cancer screening. These are the types of services that state dollars supported.
So how much will Planned Parenthood lose in annual funding? We heard figures ranging from $114,000 from Scott’s office to $500,000 from Planned Parenthood.
Scott’s office argued that the funding cut is small compared to the overall state dollars given to clinics.
"Over $5 million in state funds are provided for non-abortion services at many charitable clinics and county health departments," according to a March 30 statement by Scott. "HB 1411 makes sure no state funds can indirectly fund abortions by supporting the same institutions that perform them. For Planned Parenthood, this would only affect about $114,000 in funds they get annually."
Family planning services remain funded at various clinics and centers that don’t provide abortions, including all 67 county health departments. So Jennings exaggerated when she said that Scott "stripped women of access to public health care" because access to certain types of health care remain available.
The Florida Alliance of Planned Parenthood Affiliates issued its own statement that Scott was low-balling the amount of money clinics could lose. Laura Goodhue, executive director of the Florida Alliance of Planned Parenthood Affiliates, told PolitiFact Florida that she expects the total loss of money to be closer to $500,000.
In a news release, Planned Parenthood said Scott was downplaying the effects "of patients losing access to care by only sharing the state funds that would be prohibited under this legislation. However, because the legislation is broadly written, Planned Parenthood will also lose access to reimbursements from local government entities and federal funding from the Title X program that is contracted through local county Health Departments."
Planned Parenthood arrived at a potential figure of losing $500,000 based on $50,000 for Medicaid, $147,000 for Title X, and then funding for specific services or counties -- the largest chunk in Palm Beach.
The two Planned Parenthood affiliates each had a budget of about $11 million last year. Planned Parenthood is determining whether it can find alternate sources of funding, so it couldn’t yet say how many fewer patients may be served.
Also, 70 percent of Planned Parenthood centers are located in medically underserved areas, which means that sometimes they are "the only place where people can receive publicly funded family planning services," according to Planned Parenthood.
Critics of Florida’s new law say similar provisions in Texas led about 20 clinics to shut down. Critics of the Texas law argued that it was unconstitutional before the U.S. Supreme Court in March. A spokesman for the ACLU of Florida said that it is analyzing the impact of the law but it hasn’t announced any decision about whether it will challenge it in court.
Supporters of the bill, such as John Stemberger of the Florida Family Policy Council, argued that it will protect women.
The federal government has warned state officials that the bill may place Florida out of compliance with federal Medicaid law that bans states from restricting individuals from accessing care from any qualified provider. But it’s unlikely federal officials will consider action until the law goes into effect July 1.
The Starbucks activist said Scott "stripped women of access to public health care."
Scott signed a law this year that cuts off state funding for any clinic that provides abortions, including Planned Parenthood. We heard estimates that it will cut anywhere from $114,000 to $500,000 for Planned Parenthood, which provides other health services to low-income women.
It’s possible to wrongly assume from Jennings’ statement that Scott slashed women’s health care services broadly across the state. The cut targets abortion clinics, so it isn’t a cut for health care offices that don’t provide the procedure, such as county health departments.
There is some truth to the statement, but it’s too soon to tell exactly how the law will curtail women’s access to publicly supported health care.
We rate this claim Half True.https://www.sharethefacts.co/share/058d917d-1380-4c63-b4c9-0d26b9e31af3
YouTube, Woman screaming at Gov. Rick Scott at Starbucks in Gainesville, April 4, 2016
Facebook, Cara Jennings, April 4, 2016
Florida House, H.B. 1141 Termination of pregnancies, approved by Gov. Rick Scott on March 25, 2016
Gov. Rick Scott, Press statement, March 30, 2016
Florida Alliance of Planned Parenthood Affiliates, Press release, March 30, 2016
Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services, Informational bulletin, June 1, 2011
Live Action News, "Florida Governor Rick Scott signs bill defunding Planned Parenthood," March 28, 2016
Reuters, "Florida governor signs law ending funding to clinics providing abortions," March 25, 2016
Sun Sentinel, "Video shows woman berating Gov. Rick Scott at Starbucks," April 6, 2016
Palm Beach Post, "Cara Jennings, Lake Worth activist, confronts Gov. Scott at Starbucks," April 6, 2016
Orlando Sentinel, "Law tightens abortion limits," March 26, 2016
Sarasota Herald Tribune, "Scott signs abortion bill," March 25, 2016
Miami Herald, "Florida drops cases against Planned Parenthood clinics," March 28, 2016
Miami Herald, "Gov. Rick Scott signs abortion restrictions, medical marijuana laws," March 25, 2016
Miami Herald, "Abortions soon may be harder to obtain in Florida," March 9, 2016
News Service of Florida, "Feds could block state ban on Planned Parenthood money," April 1, 2016
PolitiFact, "Rick Scott correct that Florida created 1 million jobs on his watch," April 7, 2016
PolitiFact Florida, "Gov. Rick Scott shifts again on Medicaid expansion," April 7, 2015
PolitiFact, Fact-checks about abortion, Accessed April 6, 2016
Interview, Laura Goodhue, Executive Director of the Florida Alliance of Planned Parenthood Affiliates, April 6, 2016
Interview, Jackie Schutz, Gov. Rick Scott spokesman, April 6, 2016
Interview, Baylor Johnson, ACLU of Florida spokesman, April 6, 2016
Interview, Marissa Padilla, U.S. Centers for Medicare and Medicaid spokeswoman, April 6, 2016
Read About Our Process
In a world of wild talk and fake news, help us stand up for the facts.