Donald Trump, the presumptive Republican presidential nominee, says he favors energy from all sources to power America. Wind is on his list, but in remarks in Bismarck, N.D., Trump emphasized that wind turbines are not without their drawbacks.
"There are places for wind but if you go to various places in California, wind is killing all of the eagles," Trump said. "You know if you shoot an eagle, if you kill an eagle, they want to put you in jail for five years. And yet the windmills are killing hundreds and hundreds of eagles. … They’re killing them by the hundreds."
Setting aside Trump’s exaggeration about killing all of the eagles, we wondered, are wind turbines in California killing "hundreds and hundreds," as he said?
The truth is, we lack complete data, but Shawn Smallwood, California’s leading ornithologist for the study of raptors and wind turbines, told us Trump is exaggerating.
Smallwood says about 100 eagles die each year due to impacts with the spinning blades on windmills.
"Mr. Trump could not have arrived at his number (hundreds and hundreds) from any reliable source, unless he is referring to all eagles killed by industrial-scale wind turbines since they were installed in the early 1980s," Smallwood said. "Cumulatively over time, there have been hundreds of eagles killed, probably about 2,000."
We reached out to the Trump campaign and did not hear back.
Smallwood has worked intensively on one of the country’s first wind farms at Altamont Pass in Northern California. At one time, nearly 7,000 windmills churned out power there. But a combination of lawsuits and public pressure has cut that number by more than half.
"My best estimate for golden eagle fatalities in the Altamont Pass was 60 per year until the last couple of years when the old turbines started getting replaced by larger turbines that are being more carefully sited to reduce eagle fatalities," Smallwood said.
Today, Smallwood said the number of eagle fatalities is much lower.
Altamont Pass lies in Alameda County. Government figures show 14 golden eagles killed there in 2013. And that was two years before one of the leading operators in the wind farm announced it was shutting down over 800 turbines.
By the way, bald eagle deaths appear to be rare. Also, as a species, there is less concern because their population, about 70,000, is growing, while the population of golden eagles, about 20,000, is at best holding steady and could be declining.
To be sure, Smallwood said much information is missing statewide. Several facilities fail to provide regular monitoring reports, or at least, they fail to make them public.
Audubon California agrees with Smallwood’s estimate. Spokesman Garrison Frost told us "this is about as accurate as you’re going to get."
A spokesman for the American Bird Conservancy told us that they believe the number remains high.
"It is unknown how many golden eagles are being killed each year in California, but based on what we know from Altamont, it is likely that over 100 are dying each year at wind farms," said Steve Holmer. "Many of these birds could be saved with proper siting and mitigation measures."
Trump said that in California, windmills are killing hundreds and hundreds of eagles. The best estimate is that about 100 golden eagles die each year from collisions with wind turbine blades. The data are not perfect, but the people most concerned about the welfare of the eagles do not go along with Trump’s figure.
While the data are sketchy, the information at hand tells us that windmills were more deadly in the past, but today, fewer turbines, new designs and better siting have reduced fatalities.
Trump is correct that California wind farms are a threat to eagles but not on the magnitude he suggested. The statement contains an element of truth but ignores critical facts that would give a different impression. We rate this claim Mostly False.https://www.sharethefacts.co/share/e5f15eef-d26b-4245-8199-5f363459c36e
Washington Post, There’s a lot to unpack in just one of Donald Trump’s answers about energy policy, May 26, 2016
Journal of Raptor Research, Bald Eagle and Golden Eagle Mortalities at Wind Energy Facilities in the Contiguous United States, 2013
Alameda County Community Development Agency, Mortality in the Altamont Pass, 2015
Biological Conservation, Estimates of bird collision mortality at wind facilities in the contiguous United States, Oct. 14, 2013
National Wind Coordinating Collaborative, Wind Turbine Interactions with Wildlife and their Habitats, May 2015
Save the Eagles International, US windfarms kill 10-20 times more than previously thought, April 2014
PolitiFact, Checking George Will on birds and wind turbines, May 3, 2010
Email interview, Shawn Smallwood, ornithologist, May 27, 2016
Email interview, Peter Marra, Migratory Bird Center, Smithsonian Conservation Biology Institute, May 27, 2016
Interview, Steve Holmer, senior policy advisor bird conservancy, May 27, 2016
Interview, Garrison Frost, spokesman, California Audubon Society, May 27, 2016
Interview, lana DeBare, communications director, Golden Gate Audubon Society, May 27, 2016
Read About Our Process
In a world of wild talk and fake news, help us stand up for the facts.