With the general election campaign in full swing, the attacks have begun as Republican Marc Molinaro tries to unseat Democratic Gov. Andrew Cuomo. During a news conference in Manhattan, Molinaro criticized Cuomo’s stewardship of the Metropolitan Transportation Authority, which is responsible for New York City buses, subways, and commuter rail lines into Connecticut, Long Island and southeastern New York. Molinaro explained how he would do things differently than the incumbent.
"We’re going to start by, instead of focusing on vanity projects and the colors of tiles in Midtown Tunnel, or by the way, stealing money from the MTA and sending it upstate for projects that have nothing to do with transit, we’re going to focus the New York state taxpayers’ dollars on signal switches, and subway cars, on platform rehab and accessibility," Molinaro said.
Is Molinaro right? Did the governor steal money from the MTA to send upstate?
The MTA carries 8.6 million riders on an average weekday and had an operating budget of $13 billion in 2017. Riders frequently face delays and deal with overcrowded trains and trains that break down, putting the transit authority in the spotlight.
Molinaro ties his claim to a story published in the New York Daily News in July 2017. The newspaper reported that the MTA in 2016 had been instructed by the Cuomo administration to send a $4.9 million check to the Olympic Regional Development Authority. The authority’s finances had suffered because of a warm winter. The authority operates or manages upstate ski areas at Whiteface, Gore, and Belleayre mountains and the Lake Placid Olympic facilities.
The Molinaro campaign provided only a link to a related news story as evidence of his claim.
The state Division of Budget does not dispute that the MTA directly transferred $4.9 million to the Olympic authority, said spokesman Morris Peters.
The state routinely charges state authorities for services that state government personnel provide them, and it has done so for years. Since at least 2010, the state has charged the MTA around $5 million annually for services it provided the authority, as it does for 13 other authorities, Peters said.
Section 2975 of state law allows for "recovery of state governmental costs from public authorities and public benefit corporations." The state can collect money for staff time, equipment and facilities, and other services the state provides to support authorities. Under the law, the money is to be collected by the state treasurer and credited to the state’s general fund, though other appropriations can be made by the budget director. A portion of these payments is to be used to fund the authorities budget office.
The MTA owed the state $4.9 million in 2016, and the Olympic authority needed the money soon because of the warm winter, Peters said. Sending the $4.9 million to the state’s general fund, so the state could then send it to the troubled ski areas, would create a delay, he said.
These types of direct payments have happened for years. In more than a dozen instances since 2010, authorities were told to send their payment to another entity to deal with a critical budget need, instead of sending it to the state’s general fund.
"It’s not the most transparent budget move in the world," said Rachael Fauss, a senior research analyst with Reinvent Albany, an organization focused on transparency in government. Though it’s "just not great policy," Fauss said, "it’s legal, it’s allowed."
The Office of the State Comptroller, which reports on state finances, and is mentioned in the state law authorizing these payments, declined to comment on the claim. A spokesman referred us to an audit of the Olympic authority that was published two years ahead of the $4.9 million transaction. The audit recommended better cash management.
The MTA also declined to comment on the claim.
The transfer of $4.9 million directly from the MTA to an upstate authority that manages ski resorts raised eyebrows when it was initially reported, because of the MTA’s financial and operational problems and because it prompted questions about whether it was a sound budget practice.
Molinaro’s claim that the money was sent from the MTA to the Olympic redevelopment authority for non-transit projects is correct.
State law, however, allows the state to recover money from authorities for the work that state agencies do on behalf of the authorities, contradicting Molinaro’s claim that Cuomo was "stealing" from the MTA. What's more, the $4.9 million could have been collected by the state regardless of who was governor.
We rate his claim False.
Marc Molinaro news conference on Sept. 14, 2018, via Facebook. Accessed on Sept. 14, 2018.
The MTA Network. Accessed on Sept. 20, 2018.
"New York’s Subways Are Not Just Delayed. Some Trains Don’t Run at All," Aug. 7, 2017. New York Times. Accessed on Sept. 20, 2018.
Telephone and email conversation with Morris Peters, spokesman, state Division of Budget, Sept. 19, 2018.
New York State Consolidated Laws, Public Authorities, Article 9, Title 10, Section 2975. Accessed Sept. 20, 2018.
"Cuomo under fire $4.9 million gift from NYC subway to Adirondack ski hills," July 12, 2017, North Country Public Radio. Accessed Sept. 20, 2018.
Telephone and email correspondence with Rachael Fauss, senior research analyst, Reinvent Albany, Sept. 19, 2018.
Telephone and email correspondence, Matthew Sweeney, spokesman for the Office of the State Comptroller, Sept. 20, 2018.
Email correspondence with Katherine Delgado, Molinaro spokeswoman, Sept. 18, 19, 20, 2018.
Read About Our Process
In a world of wild talk and fake news, help us stand up for the facts.