Stand up for the facts!
Misinformation isn't going away just because it's a new year. Support trusted, factual information with a tax deductible contribution to PolitiFact.
I would like to contribute
Michael Moore so loves Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez as a politician that he wants the Constitution changed so the New York Democrat, who is the youngest woman ever elected to the U.S. House, can run for president.
Moore, the documentary filmmaker and liberal pundit, made the comment on The Last Word, an MSNBC talk show. In the same interview, while assessing potential Democratic candidates for president in 2020, he also made a claim we want to check about a controversial idea floated by Ocasio-Cortez — about a 70 percent tax rate.
Suggesting the idea is loved by most Americans, Moore said:
"I’m talking about a Fox News Poll this week, where it said 70 percent of the American public agree with her on having the top marginal rate for the rich — their taxes — 70 percent rate, on the rich. And that’s a Fox News Poll saying that over two-thirds of the country support her."
There is widespread support among Americans to raise taxes on the rich.
But do 70 percent support a 70 percent tax rate — as reported by the conservative TV outlet?
First, a bit on the idea that Ocasio-Cortez floated on CBS’ 60 Minutes, which her office has told PolitiFact is more a discussion-starter than a proposal:
The 70 percent income tax rate would affect dollars received above $10 million.
That rate would be a big jump from the current top marginal tax rate of 37 percent, which kicks in for income above $510,300 for individuals and $612,350 for married couples.
It’s estimated that about 16,000 would be affected by the 70 percent rate.
Now, to that Fox News Poll.
Moore’s claim is based on a Fox News Poll that was conducted Jan. 20-22, one of Moore’s producers told us. The producer also cited a Washington Post news story, which said that the poll found 70 percent support for raising taxes on income above $10 million.
One thing to note is the poll was of a narrower group than Moore said — a random sample of registered voters, not all Americans. More importantly, despite Moore’s claim, the poll did not ask about a specific maximum tax rate.
Here are the poll question and the results:
Do you favor or oppose increasing tax rates only on families earning over $10 million a year?
Favor: 70 percent
Oppose: 24 percent
Don’t know: 5 percent
So, that’s 70 percent support for increasing tax rates on families earning over $10 million.
But the poll didn’t ask about raising the top rate on those families to 70 percent — or any particular rate at all.
So, Moore is not accurately quoting the Fox News Poll.
When we pointed that out to Moore’s producer, the producer sent us a statement in which Moore says:
"Public polling overwhelmingly shows that the American people are in favor (of) raising taxes on the wealthy and on corporations, and we finally have more leaders in Washington who aren’t afraid to advocate for it."
So, there is support for Moore’s broader point. For example, a The Hill/HarrisX Daily Poll of registered voters, conducted about a week before the Fox News Poll, found 59 percent support a 70 percent top tax rate.
The question and the results from that poll:
Currently the top tax rate is 37 percent. Would you favor or oppose a tax proposal that would apply a 70 percent rate to the 10 millionth dollar and beyond for individuals making $10 million a year or more in reportable income?
Strongly favor: 29 percent
Somewhat favor: 30 percent
Somewhat oppose: 20 percent
Strongly oppose: 21 percent
Moore said, "Seventy percent of the American public agree with" Ocasio-Cortez "on having the top marginal (tax) rate for the rich" at 70 percent, and "that's a Fox News Poll saying that."
A Fox News Poll found 70 percent of registered voters, not all Americans, support the general idea of raising income tax rates on families earning over $10 million. But we don’t know from the poll what percentage of Americans supports making the top tax rate 70 percent.
So Moore got the details wrong, but there is some support for his broader point about U.S. sentiments toward taxing wealthier Americans. We rate Moore’s statement Mostly False.
MSNBC, Michael Moore interview (2:30), Feb. 2, 2019
Email, Michael Moore producer Basel Hamdan, Feb. 4, 2019
PolitiFact, "Explaining Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez's 70 percent marginal tax rate idea," Jan. 8, 2019
Fox News Poll, January 2019 poll results (Question 25), Jan. 30, 2019
Email, Charles Franklin, professor of law and public policy and director of the Marquette Law School Poll, Feb. 4, 2019
Email, American Enterprise Institute senior fellow and polling expert Karlyn Bowman, Feb. 4, 2019
Email, polling expert Steven Smith, professor of social science and political science at Washington University, Feb. 4, 2019
Washington Post, "Republicans support higher taxes on the super-rich, according to a Fox News survey," Jan. 31, 2019
The Hill, "Poll: A majority of Americans support raising the top tax rate to 70 percent," Jan. 15, 2019
Read About Our Process
In a world of wild talk and fake news, help us stand up for the facts.