Stand up for the facts!
Misinformation isn't going away just because it's a new year. Support trusted, factual information with a tax deductible contribution to PolitiFact.
I would like to contribute
Arguing that reparations is a matter of "making amends and direct redress," Coates made a claim about wealth that we want to check, saying:
"The typical black family in this country has one-tenth the wealth of the typical white family."
What we found is that he is citing the most respected and most recent authority on the racial wealth gap.
Reparations, if eventually enacted, would likely include a formal apology for America’s history of slavery, as well as some form of financial compensation to descendants of slaves.
Wealth is often confused with income, and while the two often go hand in hand, they are different. Income is how much money a person makes from a job or investments. Wealth is the value of everything a person owns after factoring in debt. The equity in a home, retirement savings and bank accounts, for example, are part of a person’s wealth.
We asked Coates’ publisher for more information on Coates’ remark, but did not hear back.
PolitiFact Texas checked a similar claim from Beto O’Rourke, a former Texas congressman now running for the 2020 Democratic nomination for president. O’Rourke said "black Americans have 10 times less wealth than white Americans." That rated Mostly True.
Coates’ claim is more precise in that he referred to the typical family.
The claim is accurate when speaking about family median wealth. Economists told us median wealth data represents a typical family more than would data on average wealth. (The latter can be skewed by families with extreme wealth.)
Median wealth is the halfway point — half of families have wealth above the median, and half below.
Wealth is measured as net worth — the difference between a family’s gross assets and their liabilities.
Here, with some additional details, are the figures cited by PolitiFact Texas:
The table shows that the median family net worth, or wealth, for black families was $17,600 in 2016, or roughly one-tenth that of the typical white family.
Those 2016 figures, from the Federal Reserve Board’s Survey of Consumer Finances, are the most recent available. Five experts told us that’s the most solid data source on wealth.
The figures exclude some things that could be considered "wealth," such as aid from government programs, said economist Ryan Bourne of the Cato Institute
The survey, done every three years, collects information about various family finances, including income, net worth and credit use. "No other study for the country collects comparable information," the agency says.
It’s worth noting that the table also shows that black families closed the wealth gap with white families a bit between 2013 and 2016. But the report said "the long-standing and substantial wealth disparities" between families of different racial and ethnic groups "have changed little in the past few years."
The report offered a couple of possible explanations for the gap:
"Well over half of white households are homeowners (73%), compared with just under half of black" households.
White households "tend to be older, more highly educated, more likely to have received an inheritance and less likely to be a single parent."
A February 2019 report by the Federal Reserve Bank of Cleveland, however, drew a different picture.
"We find that the income gap is the primary driver behind the wealth gap and that it is large enough to explain the persistent difference in wealth accumulation."
Coates said, "The typical black family in this country has one-tenth the wealth of the typical white family."
The best way to measure typical wealth is with the median net worth, and the most recent figures are for 2016. The median net worth — gross assets minus liabilities — for black families was $17,600, about one-tenth the wealth of white families, which was $171,000.
We rate Coates’ statement True.
YouTube, Ta-Nehisi Coates testimony (4:09), June 19, 2019
PolitiFact Texas, "Beto O'Rourke says U.S. blacks have 10 times less wealth than whites," Aug. 23, 2018
Federal Reserve Board, Survey of Consumer Finances, Sept. 27, 2017
Washington Post, "A new explanation for the stubborn persistence of the racial wealth gap," March 14, 2019
Washington Post, "Why the racial wealth gap persists, more than 150 years after emancipation," June 19, 2019
Brookings Institution, "A conversation about the racial wealth gap—and how to address it," June 18, 2019
Email, senior fellow Frank Sammartino of the Tax Policy Center, June 24, 2019
Tax Policy Center, "Median value of family net worth," March 11, 2019
Email, Ohio State University and Institute for Policy Studies economist Darrick Hamilton, June 24, 2019
Federal Reserve Bank of Cleveland, "What Is Behind the Persistence of the Racial Wealth Gap?" Feb. 28, 2019
Federal Reserve Board, "Changes in U.S. Family Finances from 2013 to 2016: Evidence from the Survey of Consumer Finances," September 2017
Email, professor emeritus of economics Abdur Chowdhury of Marquette University, June 21, 2019
Email, Ryan Bourne, chair for the public understanding of economics at Cato Institute, June 21, 2019
Email, American Enterprise Institute economic policy resident scholar Aparna Mathur, June 21, 2019
Read About Our Process
In a world of wild talk and fake news, help us stand up for the facts.