Stand up for the facts!
Our only agenda is to publish the truth so you can be an informed participant in democracy.
We need your help.
I would like to contribute
You know the saying that you can’t take it with you? Well, maybe you can if it’s a federal government benefit -- and that’s a problem says a Florida congressman.
Republican U.S. Rep. Greg Steube says tax dollars are being wasted on benefits for dead people.
"It’s estimated that in 2018 alone, dead people received $1 billion in benefits from Medicare, Medicaid, Social Security payments, and federal pensions," Steube said in a May 28 press release.
Steube introduced legislation to require federal agencies and departments to verify eligibility for benefits for individuals 105 years of age or older.
Steube is correct that the federal government spends a lot of money on benefits for people without verifying their information against death data, but his statement requires some caveats.
Improper payments are payments made by the government to the wrong person, in the wrong amount, or for the wrong reason. Improper payments include fraud and abuse, errors and instances in which a payment lacked the required documentation. (Not every improper payment is an overpayment.)
In 2018, improper payments added up to about $151 billion. Since 2003, improper payments have added up to $1.5 trillion.
Steube is zeroing in on one type of improper payment, which the government labels "failure to verify death data."
There are various reasons for improper payments. By searching the 2018 dataset at paymentaccuracy.gov, we found that the improper payments for "failure to verify death data" added up to about $966 million before any effort to recover those dollars.
The largest chunk of improper payments was for Social Security -- about $796 million. (The remainder was from Medicaid, retirement and disability. Medicare information had not yet been reported.)
One key caveat about Steube’s statement about dead people receiving health care benefits: Medicare and Medicaid payments are made to health care providers -- not the beneficiaries.
"No beneficiary receives a payment," said Joseph R. Antos, a health care and retirement policy expert at the conservative American Enterprise Institute.
Steve Ellis, vice president of Taxpayers for Common Sense, said the category "failure to verify death data" is failure to check if people are dead, not necessarily that they are all dead.
Social Security receives death information from multiple sources, including family members, banks and other government agencies. Its "Death Master File" has 90 million records, but even then states it isn’t comprehensive of all deaths. The system isn’t perfect -- sometimes the Social Security Administration has prematurely declared a person dead. And not all federal agencies have the same access to death data, a problem some lawmakers want to rectify.
While the $1 billion figure cited by Steube is large, it’s a small fraction of the total payments, Ellis said. For example, the Social Security improper payments rate in 2018 was 0.7% of total paid out, he said.
The federal government certainly can and should do better, Ellis said. But the situation doesn’t get fixed because it doesn’t add up to enough money to lead to an outcry to change it.
The Committee for a Responsible Federal Budget found in 2016 that if Social Security could get rid of all improper payments, it would reduce costs by at most .6%.
Steube said, "It’s estimated that in 2018 alone, dead people received $1 billion in benefits from Medicare, Medicaid, Social Security payments, and federal pensions."
The data for 2018 showed about $966 million in improper payments for "failure to verify death data." Most of those improper payments were for Social Security.
Also, beneficiaries don’t get the benefits directly for Medicare or Medicaid -- those go to providers.
We rate this claim Mostly True.
U.S. Rep. Greg Steube, Press release, May 28, 2019
Congressional Research Service, Improper Payments in High-Priority Programs: In Brief, July 2018
Paymentaccuracy.gov, High-Priority Programs and Programs over $100M in Monetary Loss
Paymentaccuracy.gov, Resources, 2018 data set
FORBES, Federal Agencies Admit To $1.2 Trillion In Improper Payments Since 2004, March 23, 2019
Committee for a Responsible Federal Budget, Would Reducing Fraud Make Social Security Solvent? Feb. 17, 2016
Office of Management and Budget, Memo, June 26, 2018
Office of Inspector General Social Security Administration, Audit, Feb. 5, 2019
Office of Inspector General U.S. Health and Human Services, Medicare Payments Made on Behalf of Deceased Beneficiaries in 2011, Oct. 30, 2013
Office of Inspector General, Search for "deceased beneficiaries," Accessed June 3, 2019
Washington Post, Agencies can’t always tell who’s dead and who’s not, so benefit checks keep coming, Nov. 3, 2019
Interview, Rachel Harris, U.S. Rep. Greg Steube’s spokeswoman, June 4, 2019
Interview, Steve Ellis, vice president, Taxpayers for Common Sense, June 4, 2019
Interview, Joseph R. Antos, a health care and retirement policy expert at the American Enterprise Institute, June 4, 2019
Interview, Adam Andrzejewski, CEO and founder of OpenTheBooks.com, June 4, 2019
Read About Our Process
In a world of wild talk and fake news, help us stand up for the facts.