Stand up for the facts!
Our only agenda is to publish the truth so you can be an informed participant in democracy.
We need your help.
I would like to contribute
If Your Time is short
A Facebook video focuses on bottling limitations for liquid milk to explain the need for milk dumping.
That is a factor, but so is the plunging demand for cheese, butter and other dairy products with restaurants shuttered.
And the types of dairy products needed have changed with people confined to their homes, which factories aren’t immediately able to adapt to.
Soaring milk production and plummeting consumption have dealt a series of devastating blows to Wisconsin dairy farmers in recent years.
But the coronavirus pandemic has been a next-level gut-shot.
Shuttered schools and restaurants have cut off much of the demand for dairy, even as panicked shoppers bought out milk and other dairy products — and just about everything else in sight — as the quarantine began.
A heavily-viewed Facebook video painted the scene this way:
"Although grocery store dairy shelves remain sparse … dairy farmers are being forced to dump thousands of pounds of milk down the drain," says the two-minute clip from Courtenay DeHoff TV.
The clip goes on to say it’s not as simple as shifting production from school products to grocery store ones.
"Production lines are shuttering, and they’re scrambling to suddenly mass produce jugs when they are used to mass producing the little cardboard boxes handed out at schools."
This post was flagged as part of Facebook’s efforts to combat false news and misinformation on its News Feed. (Read more about our partnership with Facebook.)
Are farmers really dumping milk even as grocery stores are short of it? And are production limitations on liquid milk to blame?
We checked it out.
Experts we spoke with said the factors cited in the video are accurate, but said a few other important elements are at play as well.
The quarantine has affected both the way liquid milk is consumed and the kind of processed dairy products needed. The Wall Street Journal said that has left dairy producers with at least 10% more milk than the industry can use.
Dennis Rodenbaugh, executive vice president at Dairy Farmers of America, the largest U.S. dairy cooperative, told the Wall Street Journal for an April 9, 2020, story that as much as 7% of the milk produced in the U.S. the prior week was dumped.
Patrick Geoghegan, executive vice president of industry relations for Dairy Farmers of Wisconsin, said the market swings have been enormous.
"Milk is being disposed of because of a massive and sudden loss of markets — more than half the nation’s restaurants are closed, sales of cheese are down 70 percent and some 44 percent of the nation’s cheese is sold through foodservice channels," he said in an email to PolitiFact Wisconsin, citing the group’s industry research.
Some of the demand that remains is for products the industry isn’t set up to immediately produce. Shifting butter production, for example, from tiny packets for restaurants to large blocks for grocery stores can’t happen overnight.
But the use of liquid milk had changed dramatically as well — and that’s the element the Facebook video focused on.
Geoghegan said sales of fluid milk were up 55% for two consecutive weeks in March, though by early April it had fallen back to about 35% above norm.
As of early April, grocery stores are more consistently stocked, but there simply wasn’t the space or production to meet that initial demand in time.
"The shelf just doesn’t hold enough and they (couldn’t) restock often enough," said Doug Adams, president of Prime Consulting, which researches the dairy industry.
Dean Foods confirmed that their shift in production was in line with what the video described. They reduced production of paperboard milk cartons for schools by "well over 50%" after schools closed.
"As panic buying reached its peak, we shifted production to focus on products most in demand (whole and 2% milk for retail business) to maximize our output efficiency," said Anne Divjak, vice president of government relations & external communications. "Demand has since normalized and we are back to normal production runs but still seeing significant declines in school milk and foodservice business."
School milk does comprise about 7% of all liquid milk sales, Adams said. But much of that demand remains since school feeding programs remain active.
Geoghegan said there have even been intermittent shortages of school milk, since bottlers have diverted resources to meet grocery store demand.
A Facebook video focused on liquid milk said bottling limitations mean grocery stores are short on milk even as farmers are dumping it.
That is a factor, but it over-simplifies the situation a bit. Disappearing markets for cheese, butter and other dairy products in restaurants play a critical role in the suddenly changing dairy economy as well, experts say.
Milk is being dumped not just because it can’t be bottled in the proper way, but because the overall demand for all dairy products is down. And because the forms of butter and cheese needed have changed with people largely confined to their homes.
We rate this Half True.
Facebook post, Courtenay DeHoff TV, Dairy Disaster, April 3, 2020
Wall Street Journal, Farmers Dump Milk, Break Eggs as Coronavirus Restaurant Closings Destroy Demand, April 9, 2020
Email exchange with Anne Divjak, vice president of government relations and external communications, Dean Foods, April 6-9, 2020
Email exchange with Doug Adams, president, Prime Consulting, April 9, 2020
Email exchange with Patrick Geoghegan, executive vice president of industry relations, Dairy Farmers of Wisconsin, April 9, 2020
Milwaukee Journal Sentinel, Wisconsin farmers forced to dump milk as coronavirus slams a fragile dairy economy, April 1, 2020
Read About Our Process
In a world of wild talk and fake news, help us stand up for the facts.