Stand up for the facts!
Our only agenda is to publish the truth so you can be an informed participant in democracy.
We need your help.
I would like to contribute
Kamala Harris’ flawed Social Security, Medicare attack on Donald Trump
If Your Time is short
Trump did not promise to gut Social Security and Medicare.
His deferral of the payroll tax deferral could cost Social Security as much as $100 billion. And Trump has said he does not want workers to repay the money.
Trump has not offered a clear plan for managing the impact on Social Security’s finances beyond taking money from the general fund.
The payroll tax deferral does not affect money for Medicare.
A couple of days before she became Joe Biden’s running mate, Sen. Kamala Harris, D-Calif., jabbed President Donald Trump for threatening two pillars of America’s social safety net.
"Trump just promised that if he wins reelection, he’ll gut Social Security and Medicare," Harris posted Aug. 9 on Instagram.
Harris was talking about what Trump said when he unilaterally gave workers a four-month break on the payroll tax that helps fund Social Security.
Trump’s action, via an executive memorandum, said nothing about Medicare payroll taxes.
The meaning of Trump’s words at the signing event were unclear, and spurred legitimate confusion. But Harris exaggerated what was known even then. And more is known now.
Each paycheck, employees see 6.2% of their wages go to Washington — a part of the payroll tax — to help fund Social Security. At an Aug. 8 event at Trump’s Bedminster, N.J., golf resort, Trump signed a memorandum that ordered Treasury Secretary Steve Mnuchin to defer those payments for four months, from September through the end of the year.
That means someone making the median weekly wage of about $1,000 could see an extra $62 in their paycheck. (We say "could" because the memo says employers don’t need to send the money to Washington. It doesn’t say they must give it to their workers.)
Deferring taxes means they would be due at some point. At the event, Trump made two comments to reassure the people who saw a little extra money.
"If I’m victorious on Nov. 3, I plan to forgive these taxes and make permanent cuts to the payroll tax," Trump said. "So I’m going to make them all permanent."
A bit later, he said, "If I win, I may extend and terminate. In other words, I’ll extend it beyond the end of the year and terminate the tax."
This triggered a debate over what Trump had in mind for the future.
White House economic adviser Larry Kudlow later said Trump was talking solely about letting workers keep the tax holiday money.
But the Biden-Harris campaign took away a different meaning.
Spokesman Michael Gwin told us that when Trump said he would "make permanent cuts to the payroll tax," that meant eliminating the employee side of the tax completely.
That was a possible interpretation, even if Trump lacked the power to make it happen.
Trump’s temporary deferral on payroll taxes costs somewhere between $80 billion and $100 billion.
Trump said he doesn’t want workers to pay it back. His memo tells the Treasury secretary to "explore avenues, including legislation, to eliminate the obligation to pay the taxes deferred."
If workers aren’t on the hook, then there are two options.
The money either comes out of Social Security’s trust funds, or general revenues.
The last trim on payroll taxes came as the country was climbing out of the Great Recession. The Obama administration and Congress dropped the tax by two percentage points in 2011-12. The total cost was $224 billion, and the law that made it happen said Congress would backfill the trust fund money from general revenues.
The Biden-Harris campaign told us that if Trump had that in mind, he could have said so, or included it in the memo.
Treasury Secretary Steve Mnuchin told Fox News Sunday that the money would be made up with dollars from the general fund. The administration can’t promise that on its own. Congress, which controls federal spending, would need to pass a bill to make it happen. (That could be the "legislation" mentioned in the memo.)
If Congress doesn’t backfill the money, Social Security runs out of money a bit sooner.
Today, the combined Social Security trust funds are projected to be depleted as of 2035.
William Hoagland with the Bipartisan Policy Center estimates the cost of the payroll tax deferral at $80 billion.
"A hit of $80 billion not replenished would not gut the program," Hoagland said. "It would only impact the date of depletion, possibly a year or two earlier than expected."
A final note about statements that came after Harris' post: On Aug. 12, Trump said that he hoped to forgive the deferred payroll tax payments, backfill those payments from the general fund, and eliminate the payroll tax for Social Security going forward. He also promised to find another way to fund the program.
The next day, White House spokeswoman Kayleigh McEnany said, "What he was meaning yesterday is that he wants permanent forgiveness of the deferral."
Harris said Trump "promised that if he wins reelection, he’ll gut Social Security and Medicare."
Trump did not make that statement, and his payroll tax deferral does not affect the funding for Medicare.
The element of truth is that Trump offered no clear plan to replenish the loss to the Social Security trust fund, which could undermine Social Security. In the scheme of things, a $100 billion loss would advance the trust fund depletion date from 15 years from now to 13 or 14 years from now.
We rate this claim Mostly False.
Kamala Harris, Instagram post, Aug. 9, 2020
White House, Memorandum on Deferring Payroll Tax Obligations in Light of the Ongoing COVID-19 Disaster, Aug. 8, 2020
White House, Remarks by President Trump in Press Briefing, Aug. 8, 2020
Legal Information Institute, 26 U.S. Code § 3101.Rate of tax, accessed Aug. 12, 2020
Congressional Research Service,Payroll Tax Cuts as Economic Stimulus: Past Experience and Economic Considerations, Aug. 23, 2019
U.S. Congress, Tax relief, unemployment insurance reauthorization, and job creation Act of 2010, Dec. 17, 2020
Congressional Research Service, Social Security: Temporary Payroll Tax Reduction, May 7, 2012
Congressional Budget Office, Combined OASDI Trust Funds, March 2012
Social Security Administration, Cumulative combined OASI and DI income less cost (actuarial balance) for the long-range projection period 2019-2094, April 22, 2020
Committee for a Responsible Federal Budget, How Much Would President Trump's Executive Orders Cost?, Aug. 8, 2020
Congressional Budget Office, The federal budget in 2019, April 2020
U.S. Joint Committee on Taxation, General Explanation Of Tax Legislation Enacted In The 112th Congress, Feb. 25, 2013
Email exchange, G. William Hoagland, vice president, Bipartisan Policy Center, Aug. 12, 2020
Email exchange, Eugene Steuerle, cofounder, Urban-Brookings Tax Policy Center, Aug. 12, 202
Interview, Michael Gwin, spokesman, Biden for President, Aug. 12, 2020
Read About Our Process
Browse the Truth-O-Meter
More by Jon Greenberg
Kamala Harris’ flawed Social Security, Medicare attack on Donald Trump
Support independent fact-checking.
Become a member!
In a world of wild talk and fake news, help us stand up for the facts.