Stand up for the facts!
Misinformation isn't going away just because it's a new year. Support trusted, factual information with a tax deductible contribution to PolitiFact.
I would like to contribute
If Your Time is short
In a memo made public in 2012, bin Laden called for the assassination of then-President Barack Obama, saying it would lead the United States into crisis because “Biden is totally unprepared for the post.”
Bin Laden was killed in 2011, and officials say Obama was never in danger.
The al Qaeda terrorist leader didn’t endorse Biden. A Trump campaign ad says Trump is endorsed by veterans and first responders, while Biden is endorsed by bin Laden, but bin Laden never had the choice between Trump and Biden.
It’s Father’s Day weekend. What do you get for a very wealthy man who also occupies the Oval Office?
Donald Trump Jr. had something for his father: A scrap of text from the seized documents of Osama bin Laden, the former head of al Qaeda, mastermind behind the 9/11 attacks, killed by U.S. special operations forces in 2011.
In an interview with President Donald Trump, Trump Jr. unveiled a passage describing bin Laden’s desire to kill President Barack Obama.
"He wanted to assassinate President Obama because it would put Joe Biden in charge, and essentially he's so grossly incompetent, it would lead to the destruction of America," Trump Jr. said June 18 on his YouTube program "Triggered." "What does it say to you, that basically the Democrat nominee for president of the United States got the posthumous Osama bin Laden endorsement?"
The father and son were engaging in a bit of political theater, because Trump senior said that if it was true, he’d make a commercial around it.
"It’s true," Trump Jr. said.
"OK, we speak the truth," Trump said.
And then they played the ad, which contrasted Trump and Biden. Fighter jets and endorsements from veterans and firefighters symbolized Trump.
"Joe Biden endorsed by Osama bin Laden" was the line about Biden.
Here, we examine whether there’s any truth to that.
Here’s the accurate part of that exchange. During the years bin Laden was holed up in his compound in Pakistan, he still sought to cripple American power in the Middle East.
When American special operations forces raided bin Laden’s compound in 2011, on Obama’s orders, they found a trove of computer files. The Office of the Director of National Intelligence translated and published the last of that material in 2017. Among the many memos was one where bin Laden called for the assassination of Obama.
"Obama is the head of infidelity, and killing him automatically will make Biden take over the presidency," bin Laden wrote, according to a 2012 Washington Post article. "Biden is totally unprepared for that post, which will lead the U.S. into a crisis."
Now, this plot never went far, and officials said this never posed a real risk to Obama. But bin Laden had a poor opinion of Biden.
The Oxford Dictionary defines endorsement as the "act of giving one's public approval or support to someone or something."
Politicians seek endorsements all the time, and roll them out at strategic moments in their campaigns to win more votes. An endorsement is a positive statement that speaks to a candidate’s good qualities.
Political scientist Janine Parry at the University of Arkansas said Trump Jr.’s use of the term doesn’t "pass the smell test" for two reasons.
First, "declaring someone ‘totally unprepared’ for the job is the opposite of an endorsement by any definition," Parry said. "A close second is bin Laden’s stated goal that a Biden presidency would lead the U.S. into a crisis. This, too, is the antithesis of an endorsement by any standard."
Through a political-science lens, bin Laden’s words don’t constitute an endorsement.
"To be persuasive, endorsements need to come from endorsers who are both knowledgeable and trustworthy," Hofstra University political scientist Craig Burnett said. "I strongly suspect that, for most people, bin Laden fails on both counts."
Trump Jr.’s statement, reinforced by the campaign ad, makes the further stretch that bin Laden was somehow weighing in on the choice between Trump and Biden. Bin Laden has been dead for nine years. If creating a crisis in the U.S. was his goal, we can’t know which candidate in 2020 he would prefer.
Trump Jr. said bin Laden endorsed Biden. Bin Laden said Biden was unprepared for the presidency. That is the exact opposite of an endorsement.
We rate this claim False.
Triggered, Interview with President Donald Trump, June 18, 2020
Washington Post, The bin Laden plot to kill President Obama, March 16, 2012
Office of the Director of National Intelligence, Bin Laden's bookshelf, Jan. 19, 2017
Cheryl Boudreau, The Persuasion Effects of Political Endorsements, 2016
Oxford Dictionary, Endorsement, accessed June 19, 2020
Email exchange, Janine A. Parry, professor of political science, University of Arkansas, June 19, 2020
Email exchange, Craig Burnett, associate professor of political science, Hofstra University, June 19, 2020
Read About Our Process
In a world of wild talk and fake news, help us stand up for the facts.