If Your Time is short
Bernie Sanders’ proposals would eliminate student-loan debt for 45 million borrowers within six months.
He has proposed trillions of dollars in tax increases to pay for the loan forgiveness and other social programs.
But there simply isn’t enough data yet on Sanders’ tax proposals to determine how much in additional taxes a particular taxpayer might have to pay.
A Facebook post took a sarcastic swing at Sen. Bernie Sanders’ proposal to cancel all student loan debt, claiming the savings would be more than wiped out by higher taxes he’s calling for.
"I pay $165 a month on my student loans for the next 13 years to pay them off," the post said. "With Bernie Sanders’ plan, my student loans will be forgiven. I’ll only have to pay $450 extra in taxes a month for the next 25 years to make sure I’ll have no more student debt."
At $450 per month, that’s $5,400 more in taxes per year.
The post was flagged as part of Facebook’s efforts to combat false news and misinformation on its News Feed. (Read more about our partnership with Facebook.)
While unofficial tax calculators have cropped online purporting to show the tax implications of Sanders’ plans, experts told us there simply isn’t enough data yet on Sanders’ tax proposals to determine how much in additional taxes a particular taxpayer might have to pay.
Sanders says that within six months, his proposal would cancel the $1.64 trillion in student debt owed by 45 million Americans, saving a typical borrower $3,000 per year. The $3,000 is based on 2018 government data that shows the typical monthly payment is between $200 and $299 per month.
Sanders would pay for the cancellation by imposing a new tax on securities transactions, or what Sanders calls "Wall Street speculation," to generate what his campaign says would be more than $2.4 trillion over the next decade.
Specifically, he would place a 0.5% tax on stock trades — 50 cents on every $100 of stock — a 0.1% fee on bond trades and a 0.005% fee on derivatives trades.
Looking at the investment tax alone, a person would have to buy or sell $1.08 million worth of stock per year in order to incur $5,400 in new tax liabilities, said Andrew Reschovsky, professor emeritus of public affairs and applied economics at the University of Wisconsin-Madison.
"I suspect that there are not many holders of outstanding student loan debt that could afford financial transactions of this magnitude," he told us.
But the investment tax is not the only new one Sanders has proposed.
A calculator on a pro-Sanders website, bernietax.com, estimates that a single person making $250,000 per year and currently paying $3,000 in health costs would lose $5,500 per year in disposable income due to a 4% Sanders tax proposes as one way to pay for his Medicare for All proposal. So as far as this calculator is concerned, there is a way to get to the figure used in the Facebook post.
But the tax calculator "is a complete black box," Reschovsky told us. "There is no indication about what assumptions are made and how the calculations are carried out."
Moreover, Sanders is proposing several trillion dollars’ worth of tax increases, but those proposals haven’t been scored in enough detail to know whether $5,400 per year in extra taxes is an accurate estimate for a particular person, said Tax Foundation economist Erica York.
"It is beyond impossible to know how much he'd pay under Sanders' tax plan," said Howard Gleckman, senior fellow at the Urban-Brookings Tax Policy Center. "And his tax bill would vary dramatically depending on how much money he made and how he made it."
A Facebook post said: "I pay $165 a month on my student loans for the next 13 years to pay them off. With Bernie Sanders’ plan, my student loans will be forgiven. I’ll only have to pay $450 extra in taxes a month for the next 25 years to make sure I’ll have no more student debt."
Sanders’ various proposals to raise taxes have not been scored out in enough detail to determine how much more any given taxpayer might pay.
We rate the statement False.
Facebook, post, Feb. 28, 2020
U.S. Sen. Bernie Sanders, "The Bernie Sanders College for All Fact Sheet," accessed March 3, 2020
Politico, "How Bernie Sanders would cancel all student loan debt," June 24, 2019
Email, Andrew Reschovsky, professor emeritus of public affairs and applied economics at the University of Wisconsin-Madison, March 4, 2020
Email, Erica York, economist with the Center for Federal Tax Policy at Tax Foundation, March 4, 2020
Email, Howard Gleckman, senior fellow at the Urban-Brookings Tax Policy Center, March 4, 2020
Read About Our Process
In a world of wild talk and fake news, help us stand up for the facts.