Facts are under assault in 2020.
We can't fight back misinformation about the election and COVID-19 without you. Support trusted, factual information with a tax deductible contribution to PolitiFact
I would like to contribute
If Your Time is short
• Kevin O’Brien, a former aide to Bullock, was fired from the Democratic Governors Association, which Bullock chaired, for sexually harassing a coworker. O’Brien later went to work from the New York City mayor’s office where he was fired for harassing two more women.
• Bullock claims that when he heard about the harassment, he immediately decided it was appropriate to terminate O’Brien from the Democratic Governors Association. But he has admitted that he didn’t tell the mayor’s office why O’Brien was terminated.
• Bullock has apologized for not telling New York Mayor Bill de Blasio about the reason for O’Brien’s termination.
The National Republican Senatorial Committee has produced an ad suggesting that Montana Gov. Steve Bullock, a Democratic candidate for the Senate, "failed to act" after one of his aides was fired for sexual harassment.
"We know Steve Bullock used his position to help his friends and family make money. But there’s a darker side," a narrator says. "Bullock’s most senior political aide was caught sexually harassing women. Bullock knew about the harassment but said nothing, remaining silent when the aide took another job where he harassed women again. Steve Bullock covered for his friend at the expense of these women. Think about that."
As the narrator speaks, the words "failed to act" flash on the screen.
Bullock is running against first-term incumbent Republican Sen. Steve Daines in a toss-up race viewed as critical to determining whether Democrats or Republicans control the Senate. The Montana Senate race is one of 18 pivotal House and Senate contests up for election on Nov. 3 that PolitiFact is tracking.
The first claim of the ad, that Steve Bullock used his position to help his friends and family make money, was featured more prominently in another NRSC ad. Other fact-checking organizations have looked closely at the nepotism allegations against Bullock and found them false and baseless.
However, the majority of the ad is devoted to a claim that the NRSC hasn’t made before: that Bullock said nothing after his most senior political aide was caught sexually harassing women.
The NRSC’s claims revolve around Kevin O’Brien, a former aide to Bullock and New York City Mayor Bill de Blasio. O’Brien was fired from two organizations for sexual harassment: the Democratic Governors Association, which Bullock chaired, and the New York City mayor’s office.
However, the 30-second NRSC ad leaves out some important context. Here, we’ll break down the controversy over Bullock’s handling of Kevin O’Brien in detail and determine whether the claims in the NRSC’s attack ad are accurate.
O’Brien first went to work for Bullock, then Montana attorney general, in 2009. O’Brien served as campaign manager for Bullock’s gubernatorial campaign in 2012 and became deputy chief of staff to the governor in 2013.
In 2015, Bullock served a one-year term as chairman of the Democratic Governors Association, a political group that supports Democratic governors and candidates in their election campaigns. That year, O’Brien left the employ of the governor’s office and started work as a senior adviser for the Democratic Governors Association, serving as Bullock’s representative.
Ten months into his new job, O’Brien was accused of sexually harassing another employee at an after-work event. An internal investigation substantiated the employee’s allegations, and O’Brien was fired with Bullock’s approval. Bullock told the Billings Gazette that he made the decision to terminate O’Brien the moment he became aware of the allegations. In a statement to the New York Times, Bullock said that he "fully agreed with the decision" to fire O’Brien.
A month after his termination, O’Brien secured a job as chief of staff in the New York City mayor’s office. A press secretary for New York City Mayor Bill de Blasio told the New York Times that the city’s Department of Investigation at the time conducted a background check on O’Brien that included contacting both the Democratic Governors Association and the Montana Department of Administration, which handles personnel matters for the state. According to the press secretary, neither the governors association nor the state of Montana offered any "adverse information" about O’Brien’s employment history.
Amber Conger, director of communications for the Montana Department of Administration, told PolitiFact that the human resources division subjected O’Brien to an "employment verification check" when New York’s Department of Investigation called, providing basic information about his tenure at the Governor’s office, like the dates he was employed and his title.
"No staff at (the Department of Administration) HR division had any knowledge of harassment issues involving Kevin O’Brien while he was employed by the state, or by any other employer," she wrote in an email.
Bullock has claimed that he didn’t know that O’Brien had applied for a job at the mayor’s office until after he was hired. In October 2017, almost two years after O’Brien was hired in de Blasio’s office, Bullock met with both de Blasio and O’Brien at Gracie Mansion, according to the New York Times’ review of de Blasio’s schedule. But Bullock said later he didn’t tell the mayor why O’Brien had been terminated.
O’Brien was forced to resign from his position at the mayor’s office less than six months later when an internal investigation found that he had sexually harassed two city employees. A year later, the New York Times published several stories on his ouster after it obtained documents of the investigation.
De Blasio criticized Bullock and the Democratic Governors Association, saying that he found it "personally frustrating" that neither had told his office about the previous harassment allegations.
In Feb. 2019 after the New York Times broke the story about O’Brien’s firing from the mayor’s office, Bullock apologized to Montanans in a Medium post. "Should I have called Mayor de Blasio? Should I have let more people know? Was I naïve to think this wouldn’t happen again? The answer is yes," he wrote. "I was wrong and naive to think I did enough. I should have done more to ensure future employers would learn of his behavior."
A campaign ad says Bullock "failed to act" when his "most senior political aide was caught sexually harassing women. Bullock knew about the harassment but said nothing, remaining silent when the aide took another job where he harassed women again."
It’s not accurate that Bullock didn’t act. O’Brien was working for the Democratic Governor’s Association when allegations of sexual harassment surfaced, ultimately leading to O’Brien’s termination. Bullock, who was chair of the association at the time, says that when he became aware of the allegations, he decided it was appropriate to terminate O’Brien.
However, Bullock has conceded that he didn’t tell Bill de Blasio about the reasons for O’Brien’s termination when he became aware that the NYC mayor’s office had hired him. O’Brien was subsequently fired again for harassing two additional women.
The claim is partially accurate but leaves out some important details. We rate it Half True.
A tweet, Jul. 31, 2020
Billings Gazette, Gazette opinion: Bullock didn't do enough in O'Brien case, but does plenty after, Feb. 5, 2019
Democratic Governors Association, About US
FactCheck.org, Unproven nepotism allegation in Montana Senate race, Aug. 31, 2020
Helena Independent Record, Former Bullock staffer fired amid sexual harassment allegations, Jan. 29, 2019
Medium, I’m committed to doing better, Feb. 2, 2019
New York Times, De Blasio blames Democratic governors’ group for hiding sexual harassment case, Jan. 30, 2019
New York Times, Ousted de Blasio aide was fired over sexual harassment before, Jan. 28, 2019
New York Times, Top de Blasio aide was quietly ousted over sex harassment charges; Mayor is ‘deeply sorry,’ Jan. 17, 2019
NRSC, "Darker Side," Oct. 1, 2020
USA Today, Fact check: False nepotism claim against Montana's governor in GOP ad, Sep. 8, 2020
Read About Our Process
In a world of wild talk and fake news, help us stand up for the facts.