Dramatically scale back the U.S. Education Department
"Largely we can eliminate the Department of Education."
We can't fight back misinformation about the election and COVID-19 without you. Support trusted, factual information with a tax deductible contribution to PolitiFact
"Largely we can eliminate the Department of Education."
Despite President Donald Trump's efforts to scale back the U.S. Education Department, Congress hasn't approved either a decrease in its budget or proposals to downsize the agency. The administration has, however, succeeded in cutting back some of the agency's oversight powers.
The 2017 federal budget, enacted during President Barack Obama's administration, gave the Education Department $68.2 billion in discretionary funding for the year. Discretionary funding is the amount of funding Congress decides to give the department each year, making it a better indicator of Congress' views than mandatory funding for long-term programs such as student loans and school lunches. Trump's first budget for the 2018 fiscal year proposed scaling back the department's budget by 13% compared with the year before.
But Congress didn't approve the cut, and the final 2018 budget raised discretionary funding to $70.8 billion.
Still, Trump is trying to fulfill his campaign promise. His 2021 budget proposal includes a "8.4% reduction below the fiscal year 2020 appropriation" for the Education Department. Congress hasn't released their final budget yet.
One reason Congress won't approve the president's education budget requests may be that voters don't support big cuts in federal education spending. A 2019 Education Next poll found that large majorities of Republicans and Democrats believed that federal education spending should increase or stay the same, with only 15% of Republicans and 3% of Democrats supporting cuts.
The White House in 2018 introduced a broad restructuring plan that included merging the Education and Labor departments into one cabinet agency. This wasn't unprecedented. From 2011 to 2018, lawmakers in the House of Representatives introduced seven bills that proposed abolishing or defunding the Education Department.
Despite some GOP support, the plan mostly received bipartisan pushback and was restricted later by Congress' 2019 funding bill. Congress didn't approve the merger, and the Education Department is still operating as its own agency.
The Trump administration has effectively curtailed the agency's oversight powers by eliminating certain guidances and rules. This includes an Obama-era guidance that was meant to reduce racial disparities in school disciplinary measures, and regulations that kept states accountable for improving teacher training programs and student testing. There are many more examples of deregulation by the Trump administration in the Education Department.
The Trump administration has tried to reduce the Education Department's funding and power, but it hasn't "eliminated" the department. We rate this Promise Broken.
U.S. Department of Education, Department of Education FY 2017 Congressional Action, July 17, 2017
U.S. Department of Education, FY 2018 Budget Summary and Background Information, May 23, 2017
New America, Mandatory and Discretionary Spending, accessed on June 30, 2020
U.S. Department of Education, Department of Education FY 2018 Congressional Action, March 27, 2018
U.S. Department of Education, FY 2019 Budget Summary and Background Information, Feb 12, 2018
U.S. Department of Education, Department of Education FY 2019 Congressional Action, Oct 9, 2018
U.S. Department of Education, FY 2020 Budget Summary, March 11, 2019
U.S. Department of Education, Department of Education FY 2020 Congressional Action, Feb 10, 2020
U.S. Department of Education, FY 2021 Budget Summary, Feb 10, 2020
Education Next, Results from the 2019 Education Next Poll, Nov 22, 2019
NPR, White House Proposes Merging Education And Labor Departments, June 21, 2018
Brookings, Why Trump is trying to reduce the status of the Department of Education, July 16, 2018
Government Executive, Congress Begins Formally Blocking Trump's Government Reorganization Plan, Sept 12, 2018
The Washington Post, Congressional Republicans poised to overturn Obama-era education regulations, March 6, 2017
Brookings, Tracking deregulation in the Trump era, June 24, 2020
The Chronicle of Higher Education, Trump Wants to Drastically Alter the Education Dept. Here's What You Need to Know., June 21, 2018
As a presidential candidate, Donald Trump promised to dramatically scale back the Education Department. In his fiscal year 2018 budget proposal, he doesn't come close to eliminating the department, but he did urge deep cuts.
Overall, his proposed budget would fund the department at $59 billion -- a $9 billion, or 13 percent, reduction from the prior year.
The cuts would include:
• Eliminating Supporting Effective Instruction State Grants program, which generally supports professional development for teachers and efforts to reduce class size. (Savings: $2.4 billion)
• Eliminating the 21st Century Community Learning Centers program for before-school, after-school and summer programs. ($1.2 billion)
• Eliminating the Federal Supplemental Educational Opportunity Grant program, which offers need-based financial aid for higher education. ($732 million)
• Reducing funding for federal TRIO programs (eight separate efforts targeted toward low-income and first-generation college students as well as students with disabilities) and for the GEAR UP program (which offers grants to states and partnerships to improve high-poverty, middle- and high schools). ($193 million combined)
That said, the budget proposal would maintain current spending levels for historically black colleges and universities; Pell Grants, a financial-aid program for higher education; and IDEA programs for students with special-education needs.
In addition, the budget would increase funding in certain areas favored by conservative education reformers, including an additional $1.4 billion for public- and private-school choice.
Presidential budget proposals are always opening volleys in the debate between the administration and Congress over how much executive branch agencies should be funded, so we'll have to see whether these cuts are actually enacted before giving this promise a final rating. The proposal also doesn't "largely … eliminate" the department.
Still, Trump's budget shows that he continues to seek deep cuts in the Education Department, so we rate his promise In the Works.
Office of Management and Budget, presidential budget proposal, fiscal year 2018
Education Department, main web page for GEAR UP program, accessed March 29, 2017
Education Department, main web page for TRIO programs, accessed March 29, 2017
New America Foundation, "Should 'Supporting Effective Instruction State Grants' Be Saved?" March 17, 2017
PolitiFact Trump-O-Meter promise, "Ensure funding for historic black colleges," accessed March 29, 2017