"Florida is considered the fourth-largest gambling state in the nation."
Ellyn Bogdanoff on Wednesday, October 26th, 2011 in a newspaper article
Ellyn Bogdanoff said 'Florida is considered the fourth-largest gambling state in the nation'
Supporters of a proposed bill that would allow three massive destination casino resorts in South Florida often argue that gambling is already a big business here -- in fact, one of the largest in the country.
"Florida is considered the fourth-largest gambling state in the nation, but it has let the industry drive policy decisions and that has produced the worst kind of gaming,'' Sen. Ellyn Bogdanoff, R-Fort Lauderdale, said in an October 2011 interview about her casinos bill. "To me, no kind of gaming is good, but we as policymakers have to decide, do we want gaming with five-star hotels or Internet cafes in strip malls?"
That fourth-largest ranking claim has been repeated multiple times by Bogdanoff, including in a joint editorial with state Rep. Erik Fresen, R-Miami, and by other individuals, including former U.S. Rep. Lincoln Diaz-Balart. Diaz-Balart is a lawyer and adviser for the Genting Group, which has purchased the waterfront Miami Herald property with plans to build a mega casino-resort there.
We wondered if the ranking is true.
The roots of the claim
Bogdanoff's legislative assistant, Aaron Nevins, told us that the source of her claim came from a Oct. 24, 2011, report by Bernstein Research, a leading watcher of gambling stocks.
"Florida has more gaming options than Las Vegas," the report states. "There is currently $3.4B of gaming occurring in Florida or $7.4B if one includes the lottery ... There are 8 casinos in the state run by Native Americans. Seven of these are Seminole and one is Miccosukee. These casinos generated revenues of just over $2B in 2009, making Florida the fourth largest state for tribal gaming...."
Setting aside the numbers for a second, the Bernstein report makes clear it is discussing tribal gaming not gaming overall in that section, a distinction not made by Bogdanoff.
"She misspoke," Nevins told PolitiFact in a Dec. 20 interview. "Florida is the fourth-largest state for tribal gaming."
Other measures, rankings
What else is out there?
We asked Nevins if there were any other sources that ranked states' gambling revenues -- and he quickly found a separate report about states' gambling revenues in fiscal year 2010 by the Nelson A. Rockefeller Institute of Government, a group that describes itself as the public policy research arm of the State University of New York.
According to the Rockefeller report, 43 states operate lotteries, 15 allow commercial casinos, 12 have racinos, and over 40 states allow pari-mutuel wagering. Lotteries and casinos generate the bulk of gambling-related revenues.
The report on Page 5 compares states' revenues from lotteries, casinos, racinos and traditional pari-mutuel wagering. In Florida, revenues totaled about $1.4 billion -- ranking the state third behind New York and Pennsylvania.
The group also found that -- in the states where data was available -- Florida ranked third in Native American casino revenues, behind California and Connecticut.
(A brief pit stop here to explain why the Bernstein and Rockefeller reports were billions apart on their Florida figures. The Rockefeller report cited about $1.25 billion for the lottery, which is the amount that went to the state's Education Enhancement Trust Fund, while Bernstein cited total lottery revenues of about $4 billion. Those figures can be seen in this chart on page 117 from Florida's Department of Economic and Demographic Research.)
Now, back to the Rockefeller chart showing Florida at No. 3. How could Florida be ahead of Nevada, which had $829.3 million in revenues, placing at No. 12? This chart looks at gambling revenues from four sources -- lotteries, casinos, racinos and pari-mutuel wagering -- combined. Nevada only has one category here -- casinos -- while Florida has the lottery, racinos (race tracks with slot machines) and pari-mutuel wagering.
But let's take a look at a few other charts in the Rockefeller report that examine states' gambling rankings in various ways:
* States' reliance on gambling revenues: In fiscal year 2009, Florida was 15th at 3.3 percent. Nevada -- at 12.5 percent -- had the highest percentage of gambling revenue as a share of the state's own-source revenue.
* States' share of nationwide gambling revenues: Florida was third at 5.8 percent behind New York and Pennsylvania for fiscal year 2010.
* Gambling revenue per resident 18 & above: Florida was 21st at $94.4. Rhode Island was No. 1.
* Gambling revenue as a percentage of personal income: Florida was 19th at 0.2 percent. West Virginia was No. 1.
And there are even more charts in the report that compare gambling revenues between 2009 and 2010 and zero in on single sources of gambling such as racinos. But you get the picture -- each measure of gambling can result in a different state being the top, second or fourth.
And we'll toss in one more source of state-by-state comparisons. We found a ranking of states related to commercial casino activity from the American Gaming Association's 2011 state of the states survey.
For example, on state-by-state consumer spending, or gross gaming revenue -- what a casino earns before it pays taxes, salaries or other expenses, Florida ranked 16th in the country. On tax revenue, Florida ranked 15th. (The AGA is focused here on its definition of commercial casinos, which includes racinos -- but note these rankings don't reflect tribal establishments or the lottery.)
And if you guessed Nevada as No. 1 for commercial casino tax revenue you'd be wrong -- Pennsylvania and Indiana were higher. How could Indiana be higher than Nevada?
"Indiana ranks higher than Nevada because, while its gross gaming revenue is lower than Nevada, its tax rate is much higher, yielding a larger tax contribution from commercial casinos in the state," said Holly Wetzel, spokeswoman for the association.
Check out this article from Stateline.org, a publication of the Pew Center on the States:
"Nevada can still lay claim to being the nation’s leading casino state, with a total take of $10.4 billion last year, but casino revenue and casino tax revenue are two very different things. State tax policies for casinos vary widely. Tax rates often are higher for casinos located at racetracks, sometimes called 'racinos,' where the slot machines tend to be operated by the state lottery as opposed to the more traditional state regulatory gaming commission."
What's the best source?
So is there a preferred way to compare states to conclude which one is the largest, or fourth-largest, gambling state in the nation? Does it all depend on what point you want to make or what you are looking at?
We posed those questions to experts in the industry as well as academics.
Wetzel, of AGA, told us in an interview: "I don't think there is a right or wrong or agreed-upon way to measure it. It depends upon what question you are asking." Wetzel said most firms comparing markets look at gross gaming revenues -- what a casino earns before it pays taxes, salaries or other expenses. It can also be useful to look at tax contributions -- but there are different tax rates in various states.
"You can slice it and dice it anyway you want to depending on what story you are wanting to get at," Wetzel said. "The way we rank it is gross gaming revenue."
Lucy Dadayan, one of the authors on the Rockefeller report, agreed with Bogdanoff that gambling is already in Florida in a big way.
"However, the statement by the senator isn’t made in terms of reliance on gambling, or on any adjusted basis," Dadayan told PolitiFact Florida in an e-mail. "So total gambling expenditures (which we don’t collect) is the best measure in that regard. From the figures we collect, I’d say total gambling revenues to the state are the most useful measure, and Florida is in the 3rd place by this measure. The choice of the measure is really dependent on the purpose of the comparison."
Dean Gerstein, principal investigator for an in-depth gambling study done for the federal government in 1999 and now vice provost and professor at Claremont Graduate University, said the best measure depends on the point a person is trying to make.
"A measure is a statistical construct designed to best match the concept you have in mind. If the concept is the sheer size of an industry, then total revenues/sales is the usual metric," Gerstein said. "If it is the significance of the industry to the 'local' economy, it is the industry’s local wages plus locally retained profits (including the tax rake) generated, as a percentage of local wage/profit retention/tax.
"If you are interested in gambling by residents, you want to know how much the local residents gamble away per capita, regardless of where they do so. Hence all the CA residents who trek to Vegas are exporting money. But all the multinational corporations that own Vegas casinos are exporting profits. The preferred stat depends on what you are interested in, and it is important to think straight about this. Note that the states with the largest populations — CA, TX, NY, FL — tend to dominate any stat that is based in some part on total population, while Nevada and other small-pop mountain states will be down in the weeds. When you put population in the denominator (that is, 'per capita'), that changes things."
As Bogdanoff introduced her casino bill she said: "Florida is considered the fourth-largest gambling state in the nation..." But this isn't as simple as college football rankings. There isn't one universally accepted measure.
Now, Bogdanoff's legislative assistant acknowledges she should have specified tribal gaming. But that said, Bogdanoff's broader point is certainly supported from the majority of research, which suggests that -- if you include the state lottery -- Florida is certainly a big gambling state. No. 4? That's a lot less clear and very much dependent on what you measure and how you measure it.
On balance, we rate this claim Half True.
Published: Tuesday, December 27th, 2011 at 1:41 p.m.
Bernstein Research, "U.S. Gaming: What Florida means for the shape of U.S. gaming," Oct. 24, 2011
Nelson A. Rockefeller Institute of Government, "Back in the Black," June 23, 2011
American Gaming Association, "State of the States AGA survey of casino entertainment," 2011
Florida Department of Economic and Demographic Research, Florida Tax Handbook, 2011
U.S. Census, "Income and apportionment of state-administered lottery funds," 2010
North American Association of state and provincial lotteries, Lottery sales and profits, Fiscal years 2009 and 2010
Contemporary Economic Policy, "The effect of legalized gambling on state government revenue," January 2011
Stateline, "States' casino tax revenue tops $7 billion," May 5, 2011
Miami Herald/St. Petersburg Times, "Casino bill would help mega-resorts, hurt racetracks," Oct. 26, 2011
Miami Herald, "Genting: Our Miami casino won't be the largest in the world," Dec. 12, 2011
Miami Herald's Naked Politics Blog, "Casino magnates & analysts offer conflicting views of Miami's casino potential," Oct. 29, 2011
Miami Herald, "On casino resorts bill, supporters set the record straight," Nov. 26, 2011
Miami Herald, "Diaz-Balart: Casino resorts won't change South Florida's character, brand," Dec. 10, 2011
Miami Herald, "Genting: Our Miami casino won't be the largest in the world," Dec. 12, 2011
Sun-Sentinel, "'Destination casino' bill sets the stage for gambling debate in Florida," Oct. 26, 2011
Interview, Aaron Nevins, legislative assistant to Sen. Ellyn Bogdanoff, Dec. 20, 2011
Interview, Janet Brashear, Senior Analyst, Gaming, Lodging, & Leisure at Bernstein Research, Dec. 20, 2011
Interview, Lucy Dadayan, Senior Policy Analyst at the Nelson A. Rockefeller Institute of Government, Dec. 20, 2011
Interview, Holly Wetzel, spokeswoman for the American Gaming Association, Dec. 20-21, 2011
Interview, Dean Gerstein, vice provost and professor at Claremont Graduate University, Dec. 21, 2011
Interview, David G. Schwartz, director of the Center for Gaming Research University of Nevada Las Vegas, Dec. 21, 2011
Interview, Joe Weinert, vice president for Spectrum Gaming, Dec. 21, 2011
Interview, Doug Walker, associate professor of economics, College of Charleston, Dec. 21, 2011
Interview, Roger Gros, publisher Global Gaming Business Magazine, Dec. 21, 2011
We want to hear your suggestions and comments. Email the Florida Truth-O-Meter with feedback and with claims you'd like to see checked. If you send us a comment, we'll assume you don't mind us publishing it unless you tell us otherwise.