The Truth-O-Meter Says:
Garcia

Says David Rivera "received a $5,000 campaign contribution from Congressman Spencer Bachus, who is currently under House Ethics investigation for insider trading."

Luis Garcia on Wednesday, February 15th, 2012 in a campaign press release

David Rivera took a $5,000 donation from Spencer Bachus who is under investigation, says Luis Garcia

Miami Beach state Rep. Luis Garcia says that U.S. Rep. David Rivera, R-Miami, took money from a peer accused of insider trading.

"Last week, Congressman David Rivera allowed House Republican leaders to strip key provisions from the STOCK Act that would crack down on corruption of public officials and on those who peddle political inside information for profit. Rivera has received a $5,000 campaign contribution from Congressman Spencer Bachus, who is currently under House Ethics investigation for insider trading, and whose behavior is the target of the STOCK Act," said Garcia, a Democrat, in a Feb. 15 campaign press release.

In a related report about whether Rivera "allowed" Republican leaders to soften the bill, we examined in detail the Stop Trading on Congressional Knowledge (STOCK) Act, which passed the Senate and House in February. Although insider trading by members of Congress is already illegal, the STOCK Act is a response to newspaper reports and academic research that raise suspicions that politicians on Capitol Hill use their unique access to information to make lucrative trades.

The bill is intended to make it crystal clear that members can’t inside trade, and it requires them to disclose their transactions within 30 to 45 days.

In this item, we will explore whether Rivera received a $5,000 contribution from Bachus, who is under investigation for insider trading.

For questions about the campaign donation, Rivera’s congressional office spokeswoman referred us to a generic email address for Rivera’s campaign, and we did not get a reply. We also tried to reach Rivera directly but were unsuccessful.

First, some background about Rivera. A longtime state legislator, Rivera was elected to Congress in 2010 and now faces re-election in 2012. Rivera is the subject of a criminal probe by the FBI and the Internal Revenue Service related to $510,000 in undisclosed payments from a former dog track to a company owned by his mother.

The press release noted that Rivera received a contribution in 2010 from Bachus’ Growth and Prosperity Political Action Committee. The PAC’s report filed with the Federal Election Commission showed that it gave to multiple congressional campaigns, including $5,000 to Rivera’s congressional campaign on May 13, 2010 (Rivera’s FEC report shows that he received the donation June 24, 2010.)

The Center for Responsive Politics shows a summary of donations by Bachus’ Growth and Prosperity PAC -- it spent about $724,000, for the 2010 cycle. The contribution to Rivera’s campaign was not among the top recipients or vendors.

In November 2011, 60 Minutes aired a report inspired by the book Throw Them All Out, by Peter Schweizer, which cast a spotlight on Bachus, R-Ala., and his trades during the 2008 financial crisis.

"While Congressman Bachus was publicly trying to keep the economy from cratering, he was privately betting that it would, buying option funds that would go up in value if the market went down," the 60 Minutes report stated. "He would make a variety of trades and profited at a time when most Americans were losing their shirts."

The Washington Post reported on Feb. 9, 2012, that the Office of Congressional Ethics had launched an investigation of Bachus, chairman of the House Financial Services Committee, over possible violations of insider-trading laws. Bachus "has been a frequent trader on Capitol Hill, buying stock options while overseeing the nation’s banking and financial services industries," the Post stated, explaining that it was the first investigation of its kind of a member of Congress. The Post wrote that the OCE has found probable cause that insider-trading violations have occurred.

The Post report was based on anonymous sources, which we cannot independently confirm or refute. However, we’ve seen nothing that refutes the Post’s key findings. And Bachus himself released a statement on the matter.

"I welcome the opportunity to set the record straight," Bachus said in a statement. "I respect the congressional ethics process. I have fully abided by the rules governing members of Congress and look forward to the full exoneration this process will provide."

Among the examples cited in the Post article: On Sept. 18, 2008, Bachus participated in a closed-door briefing with then-Treasury Secretary Hank Paulson and Federal Reserve Chairman Ben S. Bernanke. Paulson wrote in a book that they discussed the high likelihood of decline across the entire economy if drastic steps weren’t taken, but Bachus denied that he received any insider information. The next day Bachus made trades that earned him profits.

"The Office of Congressional Ethics has requested information and I welcome this opportunity to present the facts and set the record straight," Bachus said in a statement quoted in the Post report. Bachus’ spokesman did not respond to PolitiFact Florida.

Facing a primary challenge on March 13 (which Bachus won), Bachus defended himself in an ad in which he blamed "liberal Washington reporters" and "Obama’s Democratic allies" and claimed that "news reports are clear. The attacks are false." The ad shows a headline from The Hill which quoted a former federal judge and SEC head, tapped by Bachus to review the allegations, as saying that he is innocent. Two former SEC chairman also said in a guest editorial that the allegations are "laughable." 

"If Mr. Bachus attended a meeting in which the troubled state of the economy (and how to deal with it) was discussed, that hardly was a state secret at the time of the meeting. Moreover, immediately after the meeting, the organizers disclosed what had been discussed," stated the editorial.

So Bachus’ PAC gave money to Rivera’s campaign in May 2010 for a race he won that year, and nearly three years later the Washington Post reported that Bachus was under investigation.

Our ruling

Garcia said that "Rivera has received a $5,000 campaign contribution from Congressman Spencer Bachus, who is currently under House Ethics investigation for insider trading."

Technically, the donation came from Bachus’ PAC and not Bachus as an individual, but that isn’t a key difference in this case. More significantly, the donation was made in 2010, years before news broke about the recent investigation. We should also note that although Bachus has acknowledged providing information to the ethics office, their findings have not been made public. Obviously, we don’t know what its findings will be. But in a literal sense, Garcia’s claim about the donation is accurate. But it omits the additional information that the donation was made before Bachus was under investigation. We rate this claim Mostly True.

Advertisement
About this statement:

Published: Friday, March 16th, 2012 at 2:25 p.m.

Subjects: Campaign Finance, Ethics

Sources:

Federal Election Commission, Growth and Prosperity Political Action Committee quarterly report, July 15, 2010

Center for Responsive Politics, Growth and Prosperity PAC, Accessed March 13, 2012

Luis Garcia press release, "Luis Garcia: Congressman Rivera shouldn’t use his office as a ‘Get Out of Jail Card,’" Feb. 15, 2012

Democratic Congressional Campaign Committee press release, "Rivera Fails to Fight For Stronger STOCK Act," Feb. 9, 2012

New York Times The Caucus ad, "Alabama Congressman, Under investigation, defends himself in ad," March 6, 2012

The Hill On the Money Blog, "Former SEC official says Bachus is in the clear," Feb. 24, 2012

Gadsden Times, "Guest commentary: The politics of Congressional ethics," March 8, 2012

Congressman David Rivera, Committees and caucuses, Accessed March 13, 2012

Office of Congressional Ethics, Frequently asked questions, Accessed March 13, 2012

House Committee on Ethics, Website, Accessed March 13, 2012

U.S. Library of Congress, Stop Trading on Congressional Knowledge Act S. 2038, Passed the House Feb. 9. 2012

U.S. Library of Congress, Stop Trading on Congressional Knowledge Act H.R. 5015, Introduced March 28, 2006

U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission, "Testimony of Robert Khuzami, director of the division of enforcement, on H.R. 1148, the Stop Trading on Congressional Knowledge Act," Dec. 6, 2011

GOP, Legislative digest S. 2038, Feb. 9, 2012

House Majority Leader Eric Cantor, "Leader Cantor statement on House consideration of the STOCK Act," Feb. 7, 2012

U.S. Rep. Louise Slaughter (D-New York), About the STOCK Act, Accessed March 9, 2012

Journal of Finance and Quantitative Analysis, "Abnormal returns from the common stock investments of the U.S. Senate," December 2004

Journal of Business and Politics, "Abnormal returns from the common stock investments of the U.S. House of Representatives," 2011

CNBC, "Insider Trading on Capitol Hill: Congressional Democrats do it better," May 27, 2011

AP, "South Fla US Rep Rivera added to Cantor fundraiser," July 19, 2011

Miami Herald Naked Politics blog, "Republican leader Eric Cantor has ‘concerns’ about Rivera," Feb. 25, 2011

Miami Herald, "Feds investigate Congressman Rivera on Casino contract," July 21, 2011

60 Minutes, "Congress: Trading stock on inside information?" Nov. 13, 2011

Politico, "Eric Cantor under fire for STOCK Act tweaks," Feb. 8, 2012

Politico, "STOCK Act Limps toward passage," Feb. 29, 2012

Washington Post, "Rep. Spencer Bachus faces insider trading investigation," Feb. 9, 2012

Washington Post, "In probing Congress, challenges for SEC," Feb. 11, 2012

Miami Herald, "Garcia clams Penelas and national Democrats," March 7, 2012

AP, "Bachus re-election bid tops Alabama House races," March 3, 2012

New York Times, "Senate to choose an insider trading bill," March 5, 2012

Bloomberg News, "Bachus predicts ‘full exoneration’ in ethics investigation," Feb. 10, 2012

Interview, Stephanie Formas, Democratic Congressional Campaign Committee, March 8, 2012

Interview, State Rep.Luis Garcia, March 8, 2012

Interview, Christian Ulvert, campaign spokesman for Congressional candidate Luis Garcia, March 9, 2012

Interview Meredith McGehee, Policy Director, Campaign Legal Center, March 9, 2012

Interview, Jacob Frenkel, a lawyer in private practice in Maryland and former SEC Enforcement lawyer and federal prosecutor of securities and public corruption offenses, March 8, 2012

Interview, Alan Ziobrowski, a business professor at George State University who published papers in 2004 about stock purchases of Senators and in 2011 about Congress, March 8, 2012

Interview, Dillon Victoria, spokeswoman for U.S. Rep. Louise Slaughter, March 9, 2012

Written by: Amy Sherman
Researched by: Amy Sherman
Edited by: Angie Drobnic Holan

How to contact us:

We want to hear your suggestions and comments. Email the Florida Truth-O-Meter with feedback and with claims you'd like to see checked. If you send us a comment, we'll assume you don't mind us publishing it unless you tell us otherwise.

Do you know your lawmaker?
Browse The Florida Truth-O-Meter:
Subscribe: