The Truth-O-Meter Says:
ACLU of Florida

Florida has "the most errors and exonerations from death row."

ACLU of Florida on Tuesday, May 27th, 2014 in a news release

Florida ACLU says state has 'the most errors and exonerations from death row'

On May 27, 2014, the U.S. Supreme Court struck down Florida’s standard for executing intellectually disabled convicts, finding that the state’s IQ cutoff of 70 is too rigid.

Justice Anthony Kennedy wrote in the majority opinion that the standard, "creates an unacceptable risk that persons with an intellectual disability will be executed, and thus is unconstitutional."

The case stemmed from a death sentence for Freddie Lee Hall, who in 1978 killed Deputy Lonnie Coburn and raped and murdered 21-year-old Karol Hurst. Hall scored between 60 and 80 on IQ tests over the decades.

Howard Simon, executive director of the ACLU of Florida, said in a statement that Florida’s death penalty system is "broken" and that the Legislature must address its failings.

"Florida is the only state in the country where the vote of a simple majority of jurors can recommend that a person receive a sentence of death. This has contributed to our state’s record of having the most errors and exonerations from death row."

Does Florida hold the record for death row exonerations?

Death penalty exonerations

The ACLU of Florida obtained the information about Florida’s exoneration record from the Death Penalty Information Center, a nonprofit clearinghouse that has written reports critical of the death penalty.

The center shows the number of exonerations in 26 states that have the death penalty at any point between the 1970s through mid March 2014.

The center counts an exoneration as a case where a defendant has been acquitted, pardoned or had their case dropped by prosecutors. Common scenarios that led to exonerations include cases where evidence was withheld by the prosecution, or where the defendant had ineffective trial counsel and then got a new trial that resulted in acquittal or dropped charges, said Richard Dieter, executive director of the center. More recently, DNA tests have also led to exonerations.

So how do the numbers stack up? Florida was indeed No. 1, with 24 exonerations, followed by Illinois with 20 and Texas with 12.

But there’s also a separate source of data -- the National Registry of Exonerations, a joint project of the University of Michigan Law School and the Center on Wrongful Convictions at the Northwestern University School of Law. Launched in 2012, the registry provides information on exonerations for several types of crimes since 1989, including in death penalty cases.

The registry uses a different definition of exonerations and it starts the clock ticking later than the other database does, so -- not surprisingly -- it produces different numbers.

The registry shows that Illinois had 18 death penalty exonerations while both Louisiana and Texas had 10, followed by Florida with 8.

These numbers suggest that Florida isn't in a category by itself in exonerations. For instance, in Illinois, several high-profile exonerations were so embarrassing that Republican Gov. George Ryan placed a 10-year moratorium on executions in 2000. In 2011, the Legislature passed a bill to abolish the death penalty and Democratic Gov. Pat Quinn signed it.

So two sources count the numbers differently. Let’s take a closer look at what the statistics say about Florida’s use of the death penalty.

Florida requires a unanimous vote by a jury to find a defendant guilty. However, during the penalty phase, Florida requires only a simple majority of the jury -- seven of 12 jurors -- to recommend a death sentence.

Florida is the only state that allows such a simple majority vote, ACLU of Florida spokesman Baylor Johnson said. Two other states -- Alabama and Delaware -- allow for the death penalty to be imposed by less than a unanimous jury, but they have a higher standard than Florida does. Alabama requires a 10-2 vote, while Delaware requires that a unanimous jury find aggravating circumstances.

Johnson pointed to a 2006 study by Oklahoma City University School of Law, which showed that based on jurors’ reports, jury members in Florida deliberated for less time and reviewed evidence less frequently than jurors in other states. A 2006 American Bar Association study of the death penalty raised concerns about allowing a non-unanimous jury vote for capital punishment.

Kent Scheidegger, legal director of the Criminal Justice Legal Foundation, which supports the death penalty, takes issue with the use of the word "exonerate" on such lists.

"When typical readers read that word, they think of a person who has been affirmatively shown not to have committed the crime," he told PolitiFact Florida.

A person can be deemed "exonerated" if his conviction is overturned and the evidence is insufficient to prove guilt beyond a reasonable doubt, he argued. But the person could still be guilty, he argued.

Our ruling

Florida has "the most errors and exonerations from death row," ACLU of Florida executive director Howard Simon said in a press release.

According to a count by the Death Penalty Information Center, Florida has exonerated 24 death row inmates -- the most of any state in the nation. But another resource that uses a different definitions of "exoneration" and has a different time period -- the National Registry of Exonerations -- shows Florida had eight exonerations, fewer than Illinois, Louisiana and Texas. The ACLU's claim makes it seem like Florida is unchallenged for the most exonerations, but the data is actually murkier. So we rate this claim Half True.

Advertisement
About this statement:

Published: Monday, June 2nd, 2014 at 11:24 a.m.

Subjects: Legal Issues, Supreme Court

Sources:

ACLU of Florida, "ACLU of Florida responds to U.S. Supreme Court striking down Florida law setting strict I.Q. limit for executions," May 27, 2014

Death Penalty Information Center, Execution numbers by state and death sentences by state, Accessed May 27, 2014

Death Penalty Information Center, Florida, New York, California and Texas, Accessed May 27, 2014

American Bar Association, "Evaluating Fairness and Accuracy in state death penalty systems: The Florida Death Penalty Assessment Report, September 2006

Florida Commission on Capital Cases, "Case histories A review of 23 individuals released from death row," 2002

Oklahoma City University School of Law, "The decision maker matter: the empirical examination of the way the role of the judge and jury influence death penalty decision-making," January 2006

New York Times,  "Court extends curbs on the death penalty in a Florida ruling," May 27, 2014

Los Angeles Times, "3 former California governors back proposed death penalty initiative," Feb. 12, 2014

PolitiFact, "Sacramento Bee says Texas ranks first in executions," Feb. 8, 2013

PolitiFact, "Florida surpassed New York in population, Bill Clinton says," April 14, 2014

Interview, Baylor Johnson, ACLU of Florida spokesman, May 27, 2014

Interview, Samuel Gross, University of Michigan law professor and editor of the National Registry of Exonerations, May 28, 2014

Interview, Austin Sarat, Associate Dean of the Faculty, political science professor Amherst college, May 28, 2014

Interview, Jennifer Meale, Florida Attorney General spokesman, May 29, 2014

Interview, Richard Dieter, executive director of the Death Penalty Information Center, May 29, 2014

Interview, Chris Slobogin, Vanderbilt law professor, May 29, 2014

Interview, Kent Scheidegger, Legal Director of the Criminal Justice Legal Foundation, May 29, 2014

Interview, Brad King, president Florida Prosecuting Attorneys Association, May 29, 2014

Written by: Amy Sherman
Researched by: Amy Sherman
Edited by: Louis Jacobson

How to contact us:

We want to hear your suggestions and comments. Email the Florida Truth-O-Meter with feedback and with claims you'd like to see checked. If you send us a comment, we'll assume you don't mind us publishing it unless you tell us otherwise.

Do you know your lawmaker?
Browse The Florida Truth-O-Meter:
Subscribe: